TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel continuous-time model of speculative trading where agents face asymmetric, increasing costs for holding long and short positions. This framework allows for short-selling and explains how these costs, along with a "delay option," influence asset prices and bubble dynamics, offering a more nuanced view than previous models that assumed constant costs and prohibited shorting.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles a long-standing puzzle in financial economics: understanding the formation and collapse of asset price bubbles. Traditional models, like those by Harrison and Kreps, often assume risk-neutral agents with heterogeneous beliefs but prohibit short-selling and impose constant costs for holding assets. While these models explain the "resale option" (agents buying assets hoping to sell them at a higher price to more optimistic future buyers), they fail to capture several observed phenomena: the impact of short-selling costs on prices, the role of increasing marginal costs in asset pricing, and the influence of an agent's option to delay trading. The authors aim to build a more realistic model that incorporates these factors, particularly the asymmetry in shorting costs, to better explain real-world market behavior, such as the collapse of the MBS market.
Methods
The core of the paper is a continuous-time, finite-horizon model with n types of risk-neutral agents trading a single asset. The key innovation lies in the introduction of asymmetric and increasing marginal costs of carry for holding positions. Specifically, the cost of going short is generally higher than the cost of going long, and these costs increase with the magnitude of the position. This setup leads to a Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation of a novel form that characterizes the equilibrium price. The authors also incorporate an option to delay trading, which, combined with increasing costs, can lead to dynamic prices being lower than static (buy-and-hold) prices. They analyze the model using comparative statics and limiting cases to understand the impact of various parameters, including supply and cost coefficients.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a theoretical model and does not use empirical datasets for training or evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Asymmetric Costs Matter: The difference in costs between holding long and short positions significantly impacts prices and bubble dynamics. Higher shorting costs tend to inflate prices, while lower shorting costs can deflate them.
- Increasing Costs Create Bubbles (and Anti-Bubbles): Unlike constant cost models, increasing marginal costs mean agents' valuations decrease as their positions grow. This, combined with the "delay option," can lead to dynamic prices being lower than static prices, a reversal of the classic "resale option" effect.
- Shorting's Role: The ability to short-sell introduces a "repurchase option" for pessimists, which can depress prices. A decrease in shorting costs can lead to a bubble collapse, as seen in the MBS market.
- Supply Influences Price: In contrast to earlier models, the supply of the asset now affects equilibrium prices due to the increasing marginal costs.
- Planner's Perspective: The equilibrium can be understood as the outcome of a planner with limited instruments trying to maximize initial prices, highlighting the economic intuition behind the complex HJB equation.
Key Results
- The paper derives a unique equilibrium price function characterized by a novel HJB equation.
- Comparative statics show that prices decrease with increased supply, increased cost of long positions, and decreased cost of short positions.
- In limiting cases:
- When long position costs approach zero (a+ → ∞), the model reduces to previous risk-neutral models where dynamic prices exceed static prices.
- When short position costs approach infinity (a− → 0), shorting is effectively prohibited, and the model's behavior is analyzed.
- Examples demonstrate that the delay option can cause static prices to exceed dynamic prices, even without short-selling, and that lowering shorting costs can lead to bubble implosions.
Limitations and Future Work
- Quadratic Costs: The model assumes quadratic costs for holding positions. While the paper discusses extensions to linear costs, it notes that costs quadratic in the value of the portfolio can lead to non-existence of equilibria if prices can be zero.
- Risk Neutrality: Agents are risk-neutral, which simplifies the model but abstracts from risk aversion's direct impact on portfolio choice. The increasing costs serve as a proxy for risk aversion's effect on marginal valuation.
- Homogeneous Beliefs in Limits: While the general model features heterogeneous beliefs, some limiting cases (e.g., zero net supply with symmetric costs) lead to outcomes where agents' views average out.
- Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more general cost functions, incorporating risk aversion more directly, and extending the model to include heterogeneous beliefs about volatility. They also note that their model could be supplemented with an equilibrium model of supply to explain episodes where supply dynamics play a significant role.
Summary updated