Short-term surgical outcomes in patients with unilateral complete cleft lip and palate after presurgical nasoalveolar molding therapy: A three-dimensional anthropometric study

Jiayi Yin, Shiming Zhang, Ning Huang, Bing Shi, Qian Zheng, Chao YangFrontiers in Pediatrics 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Our result indicated that PNAM therapy decreased cleft width and vertical distance between Crista philtri. It also increased nasal symmetry by decreasing columellar deviation, increasing nostril height.

Introduction

Repairing a unilateral complete cleft lip and palate (UCLP) is a complex surgical challenge due to the significant gap between tissues and the associated distortion of the nasal and maxillary structures. Traditionally, surgeons had to close these wide gaps by stretching the available tissue, which often resulted in scarring and suboptimal facial symmetry.

Presurgical nasoalveolar molding (PNAM) was developed as a non-surgical intervention to gradually "mold" the infant's tissues into a more favorable position before the primary surgery. By reducing the cleft gap and reshaping the nose, PNAM aims to facilitate a more tension-free surgical repair. This study provides a rigorous three-dimensional (3D) anthropometric evaluation of how PNAM therapy alters nasolabial morphology in the short term.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a retrospective study involving 36 patients (21 boys, 15 girls) treated at the West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, between 2017 and 2021. The cohort consisted of 18 infants who received PNAM therapy and 18 age-matched controls who did not.

The PNAM Intervention

The PNAM group utilized a customized dental plate equipped with a nasal stent, following the Grayson technique. This appliance was adjusted weekly to progressively reduce the cleft gap and elevate the collapsed nasal cartilage.

3D Anthropometric Analysis

To ensure high-fidelity measurements without the motion artifacts common in digital 3D scanning of infants, the team utilized dental plaster casts. Twelve specific nasolabial landmarks were identified on these casts and measured using electronic vernier calipers and protractors. To standardize the statistical analysis, all left-sided clefts were mirrored to the right side.

Anthropometric landmarks and measurement parameters (e.g., cleft width, nostril height, and columellar deviation) evaluated on 3D dental plaster casts.

Key Results and Insights

The study found that the PNAM group achieved statistically significant improvements ($p < 0.05$) across several morphological metrics compared to the control group:

  • Nasal Symmetry: Nostril height on the cleft side increased significantly (4.80 mm in the PNAM group vs. 3.02 mm in the control). Additionally, columellar deviation was drastically reduced, moving the base of the nose closer to the midline.
  • Cleft Reduction: The cleft width was significantly narrowed, and the vertical distance between the double Crista philtri (the ridges of the upper lip) was reduced, allowing for better tissue approximation during surgery.
  • Nostril Width: On the cleft side, nostril width decreased by an average of 1.1 mm in the PNAM group.
An infant undergoing PNAM therapy, showing the appliance and nasal stent used to reshape the nasal cartilage and reduce the cleft gap.

An important insight from the data is that PNAM primarily redistributes and reshapes existing tissue rather than stimulating new growth, as evidenced by the lack of significant differences in total columellar length or bi-alar width between groups. The nasal stent proved critical for "uncapping" collapsed alar cartilage, which is essential for achieving long-term nasal symmetry.

Conclusion

PNAM therapy significantly improves facial symmetry in infants with UCLP prior to primary surgery. By centering the columella and narrowing the cleft gap, clinicians can achieve superior alignment of tissues, potentially leading to better aesthetic and functional outcomes. While this study validates the efficacy of PNAM using accessible 3D anthropometric methods, further long-term research is needed to determine if these symmetry gains persist throughout the child's growth and development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our result indicated that PNAM therapy decreased cleft width and vertical distance between Crista philtri. It also increased nasal symmetry by decreasing columellar deviation, increasing nostril height.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yin2022short,
  author = {Jiayi Yin and Shiming Zhang and Ning Huang and Bing Shi and Qian Zheng and Chao Yang},
  title = {{Short-term surgical outcomes in patients with unilateral complete cleft lip and palate after presurgical nasoalveolar molding therapy: A three-dimensional anthropometric study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pediatrics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fped.2022.1101184},
}
Figure