Short-Term Optimal Operation Method for Hydro–Wind–Thermal Systems Considering Wind Power Uncertainty

Jia Lu, Jiaqi Zhao, Zheng Zhang, Yaxin Liu, Yang Xu, Tao Wang, Yuqi YangEnergies 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hierarchical optimization approach for short-term operation of hydro-wind-thermal power systems. By incorporating wind power uncertainty through confidence intervals and leveraging the flexibility of cascade hydropower, the method effectively reduces wind curtailment, increases clean energy generation, and lowers operational costs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of wind power into electricity grids presents a significant challenge due to its inherent uncertainty and intermittency. This leads to wind curtailment, where generated wind power cannot be utilized, and strains the grid's stability. Traditional methods struggle to efficiently manage the complex interplay between variable wind power, dispatchable hydropower, and thermal power sources, especially in large-scale systems. The paper aims to address this by developing a method that can optimally schedule these diverse energy sources in the short term, minimizing costs and maximizing clean energy utilization while accounting for wind power's unpredictable nature.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a hierarchical optimization framework that breaks down the complex problem into manageable layers:

  • Wind Power Layer: A non-parametric method is used to establish a confidence interval for wind power output. This interval, rather than a single predicted value, captures the uncertainty, providing a more realistic representation of potential output.
  • Hydropower Layer: An Improved Particle Swarm Optimization (IPSO) algorithm is employed to optimize the operation of cascade hydropower stations. This algorithm is enhanced with techniques like tent mapping for initial population diversity, an improved inertia weight mechanism to prevent premature convergence, and a crossover strategy to maintain population quality. The goal here is to use hydropower's flexibility to smooth out the wind power fluctuations within its confidence interval.
  • Thermal Power Layer: A heuristic algorithm is used to determine the optimal output of thermal power units. This algorithm prioritizes units based on their coal consumption cost and considers start-up/shutdown constraints to minimize generation costs while meeting the remaining load demand.

This hierarchical approach decomposes the problem, allowing for specialized optimization techniques to be applied to each energy source, thereby reducing overall complexity and improving solution efficiency.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its proposed method using data from a regional power grid in China during a typical winter day. This dataset includes:

  • A group of wind farms with an installed capacity of 2238 MW.
  • A two-stage cascade hydropower plant with a total installed capacity of 2520 MW.
  • A group of thermal power plants with a total installed capacity of 13,500 MW across 29 units.
  • System load data.

The scheduling period is one day, with a time interval of 15 minutes. The paper also presents figures showing actual system load and wind power output, as well as the 90% confidence interval of wind power output.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confidence Intervals for Uncertainty: Representing wind power uncertainty with a confidence interval, rather than a single point estimate, is crucial for robust short-term scheduling. This allows the system to plan for a range of possibilities, leading to more resilient operations.
  • Hydropower as a Flexible Buffer: Cascade hydropower stations, with their rapid response and ramp-up capabilities, are vital for absorbing the variability of wind power. The paper demonstrates how optimizing their operation can effectively smooth out wind power fluctuations.
  • Hierarchical Optimization for Complexity: Decomposing the complex hydro-wind-thermal system into separate, yet coordinated, layers significantly improves the efficiency and speed of the optimization process. This modular approach allows for tailored algorithms for each energy source.
  • IPSO for Enhanced Hydropower Scheduling: The improved PSO algorithm offers a more effective way to optimize hydropower dispatch compared to standard PSO, leading to better water utilization and increased clean energy generation.

Key Results

The proposed method achieved significant improvements:

  • Efficient Solution: The method attained an efficient solution in 83.5 seconds, meeting the timeliness requirements for short-term optimal dispatch.
  • Increased Hydropower Generation: An additional 455,600 kWh of hydropower was generated after optimization.
  • Reduced Coal Consumption Costs: The cost of coal consumption was reduced by ¥233,300.
  • Smoother Thermal Power Output: The peak-to-valley difference in thermal power output decreased by 675.07 MW, and the standard deviation decreased by 216.91 MW, indicating a more stable and efficient thermal power operation.
  • Full Wind Power Consumption: The method ensured full consumption of wind power within its confidence interval, significantly reducing wind curtailment.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Limited Applicability in Low Hydropower Regions: The method's effectiveness might be reduced in areas with limited hydropower resources.
  • Exclusion of Meteorological Factors: The current model does not explicitly incorporate meteorological factors beyond their impact on wind power prediction.
  • Future Work: The authors propose to consider multi-energy complementary scheduling that integrates meteorological factors in future research. They also suggest that the method is applicable to regions with abundant hydropower and wind resources, such as Africa, and can serve as a reference for grid operation with high renewable energy penetration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wind curtailment, caused by wind power uncertainty, has become a prominent issue with the large-scale grid connection of wind power. To fully account for the uncertainty of wind power output, a short-term hydro-wind-thermal operation method based on a wind power confidence interval is proposed. By utilizing the flexible start-stop and efficient ramp-up of cascade hydropower plants to smooth fluctuations in wind power output, a multi-objective optimal scheduling model that minimizes the cost of power generation and maximizes the consumption of clean energy is constructed. To reduce the solution’s complexity, we chunk the model according to the energy type using a hierarchical solution. The overall solution framework, which integrates a nonparametric method, a heuristic algorithm, and an improved particle swarm algorithm, is constructed to solve the model rapidly. The simulation results of a regional power grid show that the proposed method can attain an efficient solution in 83.5 seconds. Furthermore, the proposed method achieves an additional 455,600 kWh of hydropower and a reduction of ¥233,300 in the cost of coal consumption. These findings suggest that the proposed method is a good reference for the short-term operation of a hydro-wind-thermal combination in large-scale wind power access areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2024short,
  author = {Jia Lu and Jiaqi Zhao and Zheng Zhang and Yaxin Liu and Yang Xu and Tao Wang and Yuqi Yang},
  title = {{Short-Term Optimal Operation Method for Hydro–Wind–Thermal Systems Considering Wind Power Uncertainty}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/en17205075},
}
Figure