Short-Term High-Intensity Interval Training on Body Composition and Blood Glucose in Overweight and Obese Young Women

Zhaowei Kong, Shengyan Sun, Min Liu, Qingde ShiJournal of Diabetes Research 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated whether short-term High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) could improve cardiorespiratory fitness, body composition, and blood glucose in overweight and obese young women, compared to Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training (MICT). While both training methods significantly improved cardiorespiratory fitness, HIIT was found to be more time-efficient and perceived as easier, with a trend towards improved blood glucose, but neither method significantly altered body composition or key hormones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Obesity is a major global health concern, and while regular physical activity is crucial for prevention and management, many individuals struggle to maintain sufficient exercise levels due to perceived time constraints. High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) has emerged as a time-efficient alternative to traditional Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training (MICT), showing promise in improving cardiorespiratory fitness and metabolic health. However, the effects of short-term HIIT on body composition and hormonal profiles in overweight and obese young women, particularly in comparison to MICT, remained unclear, with some studies showing inconsistent results regarding body composition changes. This paper aims to clarify these effects, specifically addressing whether HIIT can offer comparable or superior benefits to MICT within a short intervention period.

Methods

The study employed a randomized controlled trial design with 22 overweight and obese, inactive young women. Participants were randomly assigned to either a High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) group (n=11) or a Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training (MICT) group (n=11). Both groups underwent a five-week intervention, with four training sessions per week.

  • HIIT Protocol: Involved 20-minute sessions consisting of 60 repetitions of 8-second cycling bursts at approximately 90% of peak oxygen consumption (VO2peak), interspersed with 12 seconds of passive recovery.
  • MICT Protocol: Involved 40-minute continuous cycling sessions at 65% of VO2peak.

Key measurements taken before and after the intervention included:

  • Cardiorespiratory Fitness: VO2peak and peak power output (PPO) assessed via graded maximal exercise tests on a cycle ergometer.
  • Body Composition: Assessed using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) to measure total lean mass, total fat mass, and regional fat and lean mass (trunk and abdomen).
  • Blood Glucose: Fasting glucose levels.
  • Systemic Hormones: Fasting serum levels of leptin, growth hormone (GH), testosterone, cortisol, and fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF-21).
  • Perceived Exertion: Measured using the Borg scale during exercise.

Statistical analysis involved independent-sample t-tests for group comparisons and two-way mixed ANOVA to assess time and group effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized human participants as the subjects of the intervention and measurement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time Efficiency Matters: HIIT proved to be a significantly more time-efficient intervention, requiring half the total exercise time and energy expenditure compared to MICT, while yielding comparable improvements in cardiorespiratory fitness.
  • Perception is Key: Despite similar heart rate responses, HIIT was perceived as significantly easier than MICT, which could be a crucial factor for improving adherence in sedentary populations.
  • Cardiorespiratory Gains are Robust: Both HIIT and MICT effectively improved VO2peak and peak power output, demonstrating that even short-term, low-volume interval training can lead to substantial aerobic adaptations.
  • Body Composition Remains Elusive (in the short term): Contrary to some expectations, neither HIIT nor MICT led to significant changes in overall body composition (weight, BMI, total fat mass, or lean mass) within this five-week period. This suggests that longer intervention durations or different HIIT protocols might be needed to induce noticeable body composition changes in this demographic.
  • Hormonal Responses are Subtle: The study found no significant changes in fasting levels of key hormones (leptin, GH, testosterone, cortisol, FGF-21) after the intervention, indicating that short-term training may not be sufficient to alter these resting hormonal profiles.

Key Results

  • Cardiorespiratory Fitness: Both groups showed significant improvements in VO2peak (HIIT: +7.9%; MICT: +11.7%) and peak power output (HIIT: +13.8%; MICT: +21.9%). There were no significant differences in the magnitude of improvement between the groups.
  • Perceived Exertion: MICT was perceived as significantly harder than HIIT (p = 0.042).
  • Energy Expenditure: HIIT sessions required significantly less energy expenditure than MICT sessions (174 ± 28 kcal vs. 301 ± 45 kcal, p < 0.001), and the total intervention energy expenditure was also significantly lower for HIIT (3167 ± 549 kcal vs. 6011 ± 505 kcal, p < 0.001).
  • Body Composition: No significant changes were observed in weight, BMI, total fat mass, or total body fatness for either group. However, the MICT group showed a significant decrease in total lean mass (-3.9%) and leg lean mass (-3.3%), which was not observed in the HIIT group.
  • Blood Glucose: Fasting glucose levels showed a trend towards a decrease after the intervention (p = 0.062), but this was not statistically significant and did not differ between groups.
  • Hormones: No significant changes were found in serum levels of testosterone, cortisol, GH, leptin, or FGF-21 in either group.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study's sample size was estimated based on VO2peak changes, and the authors suggest that the small sample size limits the ability to draw definitive conclusions about body composition improvements compared to traditional exercise.
  • Seasonal Factors: The study was conducted during a period (mid-October to early December) when weight gain is more common, which could have influenced body composition results.
  • Lack of Non-Exercise Control Group: The absence of a control group that did not exercise makes it difficult to fully attribute all observed changes solely to the training interventions.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Longer Intervention Durations: To observe more substantial changes in body composition, longer HIIT interventions may be necessary.
  • Acute Hormonal Responses: Investigating the immediate hormonal responses to acute HIIT sessions, in addition to resting levels, could provide further insights.
  • Comprehensive Factor Management: Future studies should consider managing demographic characteristics, HIIT modality, daily physical activity, and nutritional status more thoroughly to better understand the impact of HIIT on metabolic outcomes and hormone mediation.
  • Inclusion of a Non-Exercise Control Group: This would allow for a clearer interpretation of the relative effects of the interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study was to determine the effects of five-week high-intensity interval training (HIIT) on cardiorespiratory fitness, body composition, blood glucose, and relevant systemic hormones when compared to moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) in overweight and obese young women. <i>Methods</i>. Eighteen subjects completed 20 sessions of HIIT or MICT for five weeks. HIIT involved 60 × 8 s cycling at ~90% of peak oxygen consumption ([Formula: see text]) interspersed with 12 s recovery, whereas MICT involved 40-minute continuous cycling at 65% of [Formula: see text]. [Formula: see text], body composition, blood glucose, and fasting serum hormones, including leptin, growth hormone, testosterone, cortisol, and fibroblast growth factor 21, were measured before and after training. <i>Results</i>. Both exercise groups achieved significant improvements in [Formula: see text] (+7.9% in HIIT versus +11.7% in MICT) and peak power output (+13.8% in HIIT versus +21.9% in MICT) despite no training effects on body composition or the relevant systemic hormones. Blood glucose tended to be decreased after the intervention (<i>p</i> = 0.062). The rating of perceived exertion in MICT was higher than that in HIIT (<i>p</i> = 0.042). <i>Conclusion</i>. Compared with MICT, short-term HIIT is more time-efficient and is perceived as being easier for improving cardiorespiratory fitness and fasting blood glucose for overweight and obese young women.
BibTeX
@article{kong2016short,
  author = {Zhaowei Kong and Shengyan Sun and Min Liu and Qingde Shi},
  title = {{Short-Term High-Intensity Interval Training on Body Composition and Blood Glucose in Overweight and Obese Young Women}},
  journal = {Journal of Diabetes Research},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/4073618},
}
Figure