Short-baseline electron neutrino oscillation length after the Troitsk experiment

C. Giunti, M. Laveder, Yufeng Li, H. W. LongPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We discuss the implications for short-baseline electron neutrino disappearance in the $3+1$ mixing scheme of the recent Troitsk bounds on the mixing of a neutrino with mass between 2 and 100 eV. Considering the Troitsk data in combination with the results of short-baseline ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{e}$ and ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ disappearance experiments, which include the reactor and Gallium anomalies, we derive a $2\ensuremath{\sigma}$ allowed range for the effective neutrino squared-mass difference between 0.85 and $43\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{eV}}^{2}$. The upper bound implies that it is likely that oscillations in distance and/or energy can be observed in radioactive source experiments. It is also favorable for the ICARUS@CERN experiment, in which it is likely that oscillations are not washed out in the near detector. We discuss also the implications for neutrinoless double-$\ensuremath{\beta}$ decay.

The Sterile Neutrino Hypothesis

In the standard three-flavor neutrino model, certain experimental results remain unexplained. Specifically, the Reactor Anomaly and the Gallium Anomaly point toward a deficit in electron neutrino and antineutrino flux over short distances (meters). The leading explanation is the 3+1 mixing scheme, which introduces a fourth, "sterile" neutrino state that is significantly more massive than the standard three.

While previous data suggested the existence of such a state, the mass scale—represented by the squared-mass difference $\Delta m^2_{41}$—remained poorly constrained, particularly at high values. This lack of an upper bound made it difficult to design experiments that could definitively observe the expected oscillatory behavior.

Constraining the Mass Scale with Troitsk

This study incorporates new data from the Troitsk tritium beta-decay experiment. Unlike oscillation experiments, Troitsk measures the absolute neutrino mass by observing distortions in the electron energy spectrum near the endpoint of beta decay. This kinematic approach is sensitive to the mass of the neutrino states regardless of whether they oscillate.

Figure 1: 95% CL allowed regions in the $\sin^2 2\theta_{ee}$–$\Delta m^2_{41}$ plane. The Troitsk data (purple dot-dashed line) provides a crucial upper bound, "capping" the high-mass region allowed by short-baseline (SBL) oscillation data alone.

As shown in Figure 1, the inclusion of Troitsk data effectively excludes the high-$\Delta m^2_{41}$ region. This "cap" is vital for defining the search parameters for future experiments, as it prevents the oscillation length from becoming arbitrarily small.

Global Analysis and Key Results

The authors performed a global fit combining SBL oscillation data (from reactor and Gallium experiments) with kinematic mass constraints from Mainz and Troitsk. Using a $\chi^2$ minimization approach, they identified the following $2\sigma$ (95.45% CL) allowed ranges:

  • Mass Difference: $0.85 \leq \Delta m^2_{41} \leq 43 \text{ eV}^2$.
  • Mixing Amplitude: $0.05 \leq \sin^2 2\theta_{ee} \leq 0.19$.

These results have profound implications for the "smoking gun" of neutrino physics: the direct observation of the oscillatory pattern. The constrained mass range implies an oscillation length ($L_{osc}$) between 6 cm and 3 m per MeV of neutrino energy. This range is ideal for upcoming radioactive source experiments and the ICARUS@CERN project, as oscillations are unlikely to be "washed out" by detector size.

Implications for Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay

If neutrinos are Majorana particles, the presence of a sterile neutrino would contribute to the effective Majorana mass ($m_{\beta\beta}$) measured in neutrinoless double-beta ($0\nu\beta\beta$) decay experiments. This provides a unique bridge between oscillation physics and the fundamental nature of neutrino mass.

Figure 3: $\Delta \chi^2$ as a function of the sterile neutrino contribution to the effective Majorana mass, $m_{\beta\beta}^{(4)}$. The combined SBL+Mainz+Troitsk fit (solid purple line) suggests a range potentially detectable by future experiments like EXO and KamLAND-Zen.

The analysis estimates the sterile neutrino's contribution to be $0.013 \lesssim m_{\beta\beta}^{(4)} \lesssim 0.20 \text{ eV}$ at $2\sigma$. As seen in Figure 3, this range overlaps with the sensitivity limits of current and next-generation experiments like EXO and KamLAND-Zen, providing a potential cross-check for the sterile neutrino hypothesis.

Conclusion

The addition of Troitsk data significantly narrows the parameter space for a fourth neutrino. By bounding $\Delta m^2_{41}$ from above, this work provides a clear roadmap for future short-baseline experiments. While tensions with cosmological data remain, the predicted mass range offers a promising window for discovery in both oscillation and $0\nu\beta\beta$ decay searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

We discuss the implications for short-baseline electron neutrino disappearance in the $3+1$ mixing scheme of the recent Troitsk bounds on the mixing of a neutrino with mass between 2 and 100 eV. Considering the Troitsk data in combination with the results of short-baseline ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{e}$ and ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ disappearance experiments, which include the reactor and Gallium anomalies, we derive a $2\ensuremath{\sigma}$ allowed range for the effective neutrino squared-mass difference between 0.85 and $43\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{eV}}^{2}$. The upper bound implies that it is likely that oscillations in distance and/or energy can be observed in radioactive source experiments. It is also favorable for the ICARUS@CERN experiment, in which it is likely that oscillations are not washed out in the near detector. We discuss also the implications for neutrinoless double-$\ensuremath{\beta}$ decay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giunti2013short,
  author = {C. Giunti and M. Laveder and Yufeng Li and H. W. Long},
  title = {{Short-baseline electron neutrino oscillation length after the Troitsk experiment}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.87.013004},
}
Figure