Short- and Long-Term Outcomes of Laparoscopic Versus Open Resection for Gastric Gastrointestinal Stromal Tumors

Qingfeng Chen, Chang‐Ming Huang, Mi Lin, Jian‐Xian Lin, Jun Lü, Chao‐Hui Zheng, Ping Li, Jian‐Wei Xie, Jia-Bin Wang, Qi‐Yue Chen, Long‐Long Cao, Ru‐Hong TuMedicine 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of laparoscopic versus open surgery for gastric gastrointestinal stromal tumors (GISTs). By employing propensity-score matching to account for patient and tumor characteristics, the research demonstrates that laparoscopic surgery offers significantly better short-term outcomes, including reduced blood loss and faster recovery, while achieving comparable long-term survival rates to open surgery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gastrointestinal stromal tumors (GISTs) are the most common mesenchymal tumors of the GI tract, with the stomach being the most frequent site. Complete surgical resection is the primary treatment for localized GISTs. While laparoscopic surgery has become increasingly prevalent for various GI conditions due to its minimally invasive nature, its application for gastric GISTs has been limited by concerns about selection bias in previous studies. Specifically, it was unclear whether the observed benefits of laparoscopic surgery were due to the technique itself or because it was preferentially used for patients with smaller tumors or less complex cases. This paper aims to address this gap by rigorously comparing the short- and long-term outcomes of laparoscopic versus open GIST resection, using a statistical method to minimize the impact of selection bias.

Methods

The researchers utilized a propensity-score matching (PSM) technique. This is a statistical method designed to reduce bias in observational studies by creating comparable groups. Here's how it works in this context:

  1. Propensity Score Calculation: For each patient, a "propensity score" was calculated. This score represents the probability of a patient receiving a particular treatment (laparoscopic vs. open surgery) based on a set of observed characteristics (covariates). These covariates included age, sex, BMI, tumor size, mitotic rate, risk classification, tumor resection type, tumor location, and whether the patient received imatinib treatment post-surgery.
  2. Matching: Patients were then matched 1:1 based on their propensity scores. This means for every patient who had open surgery, a patient who had laparoscopic surgery with a very similar propensity score was identified. This process aims to create two groups that are as similar as possible in terms of their baseline characteristics, mimicking the conditions of a randomized controlled trial.
  3. Outcome Analysis: After matching, the researchers compared the short-term outcomes (e.g., operation time, blood loss, recovery time, complications) and long-term outcomes (survival, recurrence) between the matched laparoscopic and open surgery groups.

This PSM approach is a standard, yet powerful, statistical tool for making observational data more comparable when randomization isn't feasible.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 214 patients who underwent primary gastric GIST resection at the Fujian Medical University Union Hospital between January 2006 and December 2014. This data was collected from a prospectively maintained database. The study included 133 patients who underwent laparoscopic resection (LAP group) and 81 patients who underwent open resection (OPEN group) before propensity-score matching. After PSM, 71 matched pairs were analyzed. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relies on the institution's patient data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Laparoscopic Surgery is a Protective Factor for Complications: The study found that laparoscopic surgery itself was associated with a lower risk of postoperative complications. This is a crucial finding, suggesting that the technique offers inherent benefits beyond just being less invasive.
  • Tumor Location and Proximal Resection are Risk Factors: Conversely, tumors located in the middle third of the stomach and the need for proximal gastrectomy (removing the upper part of the stomach) were identified as independent risk factors for postoperative complications. This highlights that while the method of surgery matters, the nature of the tumor and the extent of the surgery also play significant roles.
  • Short-Term Benefits are Clear, Long-Term are Equivalent: The most striking insight is the clear advantage of laparoscopic surgery for short-term recovery (less blood loss, faster return to diet, shorter hospital stay). However, after accounting for confounding factors with PSM, the long-term survival rates between the two groups became statistically similar, suggesting that for GISTs, the choice of surgical approach may not significantly impact long-term prognosis once selection bias is addressed.

Key Results

  • Before PSM:
    • Laparoscopic surgery was associated with significantly less blood loss (35 mL vs. 297 mL), shorter operation times (111 min vs. 190 min), and faster recovery (earlier return to fluid diet and flatus, shorter hospital stay).
  • Postoperative complication rates were significantly lower in the LAP group (6.8%) compared to the OPEN group (22.8%).
  • The 5-year cumulative survival rate showed a trend favoring the LAP group (95.4% vs. 85.9%), though not statistically significant (P=0.07).
  • After PSM:
    • The significant short-term benefits of laparoscopic surgery (less blood loss, shorter operation time, faster recovery) persisted.
  • The significant difference in postoperative complication rates remained (5.6% in LAP vs. 22.5% in OPEN).
  • Crucially, the 5-year cumulative survival rates became statistically similar between the LAP (93.1%) and OPEN (91.9%) groups (P=0.69), indicating that the long-term outcomes are comparable when patient characteristics are balanced.
  • Multivariate Analysis: Laparoscopic surgery was a protective factor for complications (OR=0.27), while tumors in the middle third of the stomach (OR=9.43) and proximal gastrectomy (OR=6.82) were independent risk factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Study: The study is retrospective, meaning data was collected after the events occurred. While PSM helps, it cannot account for unmeasured confounding factors.
  • Single Institution: Data comes from a single center, which might limit the generalizability of findings to other healthcare settings.
  • Sample Size for Long-Term Outcomes: While the study included a substantial number of patients, the sample size for long-term survival analysis, especially after PSM, might still be considered moderate.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that larger-scale, prospective, multicenter randomized controlled trials are still required to provide more definitive evidence, particularly for long-term outcomes and the specific impact of tumor location and proximal gastrectomy on complications. They also note that the conclusion regarding tumor location in the middle third of the stomach as an independent risk factor warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Published reports on laparoscopic resection of gastric gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST) were limited to small experiences and selection bias. Two hundred fourteen patients who underwent primary gastric GIST resection at our institution (January 2006-December 2012) were identified from a prospectively collected database. Laparoscopic resections (LAP) were performed in 133 patients, and open resections (OPEN) were performed in 81 patients. The short- and long-term outcomes were analyzed using propensity-score matching (PSM) by comparing the clinicopathological factors between these groups. The tumor resection method and tumor size were significantly different between the LAP and OPEN groups. After PSM, there were no differences (P > 0.05) in these clinicopathological factors. The LAP group had less blood loss and shorter operation time, time to first flatus, time to first fluid diet, time to gastric tube removal, and postoperative stay before PSM. In addition, there were no differences regarding the time of drainage tube removal or hospitalization expense. Other than the time of gastric tube removal, which was similar in these 2 groups, the short-term outcomes were similar before and after PSM. The rates of postoperative complications in the LAP and OPEN groups were 6.8% and 22.8%, respectively, before PSM (P = 0.001) and 5.6% and 22.5%, respectively, after PSM (P = 0.004). The multivariate analyses for complications showed that tumors were located in the middle of the stomach, and the operation method and proximal gastrectomy were independent risk factors before and after PSM. The 5-year cumulative survival rates in the LAP and OPEN groups were 95.4% and 85.9%, respectively, (P = 0.07) before PSM and 93.1% and 91.9%, respectively, (P = 0.69) after PSM (not significantly different). Laparoscopic resection for gastric GISTs had better short-term outcomes and similar long-term outcomes compared with open surgery. Localized gastric GISTs can be treated with laparoscopic surgery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2016short,
  author = {Qingfeng Chen and Chang‐Ming Huang and Mi Lin and Jian‐Xian Lin and Jun Lü and Chao‐Hui Zheng and Ping Li and Jian‐Wei Xie and Jia-Bin Wang and Qi‐Yue Chen and Long‐Long Cao and Ru‐Hong Tu},
  title = {{Short- and Long-Term Outcomes of Laparoscopic Versus Open Resection for Gastric Gastrointestinal Stromal Tumors}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000003135},
}
Figure