ShORR-1, a Novel Tomato Gene, Confers Enhanced Host Resistance to Oidium neolycopersici

Yi Zhang, Kedong Xu, Dongli Pei, Deshui Yu, Ju Zhang, Xiaoli Li, Guo Chen, Hui Yang, Wenjie Zhou, Chengwei LiFrontiers in Plant Science 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper identifies and characterizes a novel tomato gene, ShORR-1, which plays a crucial role in conferring resistance to the powdery mildew pathogen Oidium neolycopersici (On). The study reveals that different variants of ShORR-1 (ShORR-1-G from a resistant cultivar and ShORR-1-M from a susceptible one) have antagonistic effects, with ShORR-1-G promoting resistance and ShORR-1-M potentially enhancing susceptibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Powdery mildew is a significant disease affecting tomato crops, causing substantial yield losses. While several resistance genes (Ol-X) have been identified in wild tomato relatives, the precise molecular mechanisms underlying these resistance responses are not fully understood. Previous research identified a differentially expressed transcript-derived fragment (DE-TDF) in resistant tomato lines that was absent in susceptible ones. This study aims to identify the gene responsible for this DE-TDF, elucidate its function in Ol-1-mediated resistance to Oidium neolycopersici, and understand how its variants contribute to differential resistance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Gene Identification and Cloning: They used the DE-TDF (M14E72-213) from previous cDNA-AFLP analysis to identify and clone the full-length open reading frames (ORFs) of the corresponding genes from both resistant (Solanum habrochaites G1.1560, carrying the Ol-1 gene) and susceptible (S. lycopersicum Moneymaker, MM) tomato varieties. These were named ShORR-1-G and ShORR-1-M, respectively.
  • Subcellular Localization: To determine where ShORR-1 functions within the cell, they fused the ORFs of ShORR-1-G and ShORR-1-M to Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) and expressed them transiently in onion epidermal cells.
  • Virus-Induced Gene Silencing (VIGS): To assess the necessity of ShORR-1 for resistance, they used VIGS to knock down the expression of ShORR-1-G in the resistant G1.1560 plants.
  • Gene Overexpression and Silencing: They generated transgenic tomato plants (both MM and G1.1560) that either overexpressed ShORR-1-G or ShORR-1-M, or had their endogenous ShORR-1-M expression silenced.
  • Phenotypic Analysis: Plants were inoculated with Oidium neolycopersici (On), and their resistance was assessed macroscopically (disease symptoms) and microscopically (fungal growth, haustoria formation, hypersensitive response (HR)).
  • Biochemical Assays: Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) accumulation, a key component of plant defense, was measured using DAB staining.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Quantitative Reverse Transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) was used to measure the transcript levels of ShORR-1 and six known defense-related marker genes in response to On infection and in transgenic lines.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as datasets in the context of machine learning. The study utilizes:

  • Tomato Genotypes: Solanum habrochaites G1.1560 (resistant, carrying Ol-1 gene) and S. lycopersicum Moneymaker (MM) (susceptible).
  • Pathogen: Oidium neolycopersici (On) isolate China.
  • Public Databases: Solanaceae Genomics Network (SGN) database for gene annotation and homology searches.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Antagonistic Roles of ShORR-1 Variants: The most striking finding is that ShORR-1-G and ShORR-1-M, despite high sequence similarity, have opposing roles in plant defense. ShORR-1-G enhances resistance, while ShORR-1-M appears to promote susceptibility. This highlights the importance of subtle sequence differences in gene function.
  • ShORR-1 is Essential for Ol-1-Mediated Resistance: Silencing ShORR-1-G in the resistant G1.1560 line completely abolished its resistance to On, demonstrating its indispensable role in the Ol-1 resistance pathway.
  • Mechanism Involves H2O2 and Abnormal Haustoria: Overexpression of ShORR-1-G in susceptible plants led to increased H2O2 accumulation and the formation of abnormal haustoria. These abnormal haustoria may impair nutrient uptake by the fungus, contributing to resistance.
  • Plasma Membrane Localization: ShORR-1 proteins are localized to the plasma membrane, suggesting they might be involved in sensing external signals or interacting with other membrane-bound proteins in the defense pathway.
  • Hormonal Signaling Involvement: The study suggests that ShORR-1-G-mediated resistance is linked to the salicylic acid (SA) pathway (upregulation of PR1 and PR2 genes) and potentially the suppression of the jasmonic acid (JA) pathway (repression of COI1).

Key Results

  • Identification of ShORR-1: A novel gene, ShORR-1, was identified and characterized. ShORR-1-G and ShORR-1-M differ by 13 amino acids.
  • Silencing ShORR-1-G leads to susceptibility: VIGS of ShORR-1-G in resistant G1.1560 plants resulted in increased susceptibility to On, with fungal growth and sporulation comparable to susceptible plants.
  • Overexpressing ShORR-1-G confers resistance: Overexpression of ShORR-1-G in susceptible MM plants significantly enhanced their resistance to On, reducing fungal growth and biomass.
  • Overexpressing ShORR-1-M increases susceptibility: Conversely, overexpressing ShORR-1-M in MM plants led to increased susceptibility to On.
  • H2O2 accumulation and HR: ShORR-1-G overexpression enhanced H2O2 accumulation and hypersensitive response (HR) in attacked cells, which are hallmarks of plant defense.
  • Abnormal haustoria: ShORR-1-G overexpression led to the formation of abnormal haustoria, which may hinder fungal nutrient acquisition.
  • Defense gene expression: ShORR-1-G overexpression altered the expression of defense-related genes, notably upregulating SA-responsive genes (PR1, PR2) and downregulating JA-responsive genes (COI1).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Functional Significance of Amino Acid Differences: While the study highlights the antagonistic roles of ShORR-1-G and ShORR-1-M due to amino acid differences, the precise functional impact of each of the 13 differing amino acids requires further investigation through site-directed mutagenesis.
  • Phosphorylation and Ubiquitination: The paper notes the presence of potential phosphorylation and ubiquitination sites on ShORR-1 proteins. Verifying the functional relevance of these post-translational modifications is a future direction.
  • Interaction Partners: Identifying proteins that interact with ShORR-1 could provide deeper insights into its molecular mechanism and the signaling pathways it influences.
  • Role in Other Resistance Genes: The study focuses on Ol-1-mediated resistance. Further research could explore if ShORR-1 plays a role in other Ol-X resistance mechanisms or in resistance to other pathogens.
  • Crosstalk with Hormonal Pathways: While evidence suggests involvement of SA and JA pathways, further validation through experiments with tomato lines having perturbed hormonal pathways is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

A previous complementary cDNA-amplified fragment length polymorphism (cDNA-AFLP) analysis examined responses to the powdery mildew pathogen <i>Oidium neolycopersici</i> (<i>On</i>) of the resistant cultivar <i>Solanum habrochiates</i> G1.1560, carrying the <i>Ol-1</i> resistance gene, and susceptible cultivar <i>S. lycopersicum</i> Moneymaker (MM). Among other findings, a differentially expressed transcript-derived fragment (DE-TDF) (M14E72-213) was upregulated in near isogenic line (NIL)-<i>Ol-1</i>, but absent in MM. This DE-TDF showed high homology to a gene of unknown function, which we named <i>ShORR-1</i> (<i>Solanum habrochaites Oidium Resistance Required-1</i>). However, MM homolog of <i>ShORR-1</i> (named <i>ShORR-1-M</i>) was still found with 95.26% nucleic acid sequence similarity to <i>ShORR-1</i> from G1.1560 (named <i>ShORR-1-G</i>); this was because the cut sites of restriction enzymes in the previous complementary cDNA-AFLP analysis was absent in <i>ShORR-1-M</i> and differs at 13 amino acids from <i>ShORR-1-G</i>. Transient expression in onion epidermal cells showed that ShORR-1 is a membrane-localized protein. Virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) of <i>ShORR-1-G</i> in G1.1560 plants increased susceptibility to <i>On</i>. Furthermore, overexpressing of <i>ShORR-1-G</i> conferred MM with resistance to <i>On</i>, involving extensive hydrogen peroxide accumulation and formation of abnormal haustoria. Knockdown of <i>ShORR-1-M</i> in MM did not affect its susceptibility to <i>On</i>, while overexpressing of <i>ShORR-1-M</i> enhanced MM's susceptibility to <i>On</i>. We also found that changes in transcript levels of six well-known hormone signaling and defense-related genes are involved in <i>ShORR-1-G</i>-mediated resistance to <i>On</i>. The results indicate that <i>ShORR-1-M</i> and <i>ShORR-1-G</i> have antagonistic effects in tomato responses to <i>On</i>, and that <i>ShORR-1</i> is essential for <i>Ol-1</i>-mediated resistance in tomato.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019shorr,
  author = {Yi Zhang and Kedong Xu and Dongli Pei and Deshui Yu and Ju Zhang and Xiaoli Li and Guo Chen and Hui Yang and Wenjie Zhou and Chengwei Li},
  title = {{ShORR-1, a Novel Tomato Gene, Confers Enhanced Host Resistance to Oidium neolycopersici}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2019.01400},
}
Figure