Shock tube flows past partially opened diaphragms

Paolo Gaetani, Alberto Guardone, Giacomo PersicoJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex flow dynamics in shock tubes when the diaphragm doesn't burst completely. Researchers found that incomplete diaphragm opening weakens the shock wave and creates significant post-shock pressure oscillations, which they explain through a combination of experimental and numerical simulations. They also developed a heuristic model to predict shock strength reduction and an analytical model for the frequency of these oscillations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In shock tubes, a diaphragm is used to separate a high-pressure driver section from a low-pressure driven section. When this diaphragm bursts, it initiates a shock wave that propagates down the driven section, creating a high-speed flow. Ideally, the diaphragm bursts instantaneously and completely, leading to a predictable one-dimensional flow. However, in reality, diaphragms can burst incompletely or over a finite time, leading to multi-dimensional effects that deviate from the ideal one-dimensional theory. These deviations, particularly the weakening of the shock wave and the generation of complex pressure oscillations behind it, can significantly impact experiments relying on shock tube flows, such as those for calibrating fast-response pressure probes. This paper aims to understand and quantify these non-ideal flow phenomena caused by partially opened diaphragms.

Methods

The study employs a dual approach: experimental measurements and numerical simulations.

  • Experimental Setup: A Plexiglas shock tube with a 80 mm internal diameter was used. Fast-response miniaturized pressure probes were strategically placed along the tube axis to capture pressure signals. High-speed cameras were used to record the diaphragm bursting process. To control the opening size, metallic disks with circular orifices were added to the diaphragm.
  • Numerical Simulations: An unsteady Euler solver was utilized, assuming an axisymmetric domain and ideal polytropic gas behavior. The simulations modeled the diaphragm as instantaneously opened, with the diaphragm dynamics itself not explicitly included. This simplification was justified by comparing simulation results with experimental data, showing good agreement after an initial transient period related to diaphragm opening.
  • Analysis Techniques: Fourier transforms were used for time-frequency analysis of pressure signals. A Mean Harmonic Energy (MHE) metric was employed to quantify the amplitude of post-shock oscillations. A simplified analytical model was developed to explain the wave propagation and frequency evolution of these oscillations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from the shock tube setup and data generated from numerical simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shock Weakening: Incomplete diaphragm opening significantly reduces the shock wave's intensity compared to a complete burst. This reduction is directly correlated with the relative area of the opened portion of the diaphragm.
  • Post-Shock Oscillations: The diffraction of the shock wave around the diaphragm edges, followed by reflections from the tube walls and interactions with the resulting wave system, generates complex, multi-dimensional pressure oscillations behind the leading shock.
  • Frequency Dependence: The local frequency of these post-shock oscillations is found to be limited by the acoustic speed in the post-shock region and the shock tube diameter. This frequency decreases with distance from the diaphragm as waves coalesce.
  • Analytical Modeling: A heuristic relation was proposed to predict shock strength reduction based on the diaphragm opening area. A simplified wave propagation model was developed to explain the observed frequency evolution of the post-shock disturbances.
  • Diaphragm Dynamics vs. Flow Field: While diaphragm opening time influences the initial flow, far downstream, the flow field simplifies, and the effects of diaphragm dynamics become negligible as initial perturbations coalesce into a single shock front.

Key Results

  • A heuristic correlation was developed for shock strength reduction as a function of the ratio of the opened diaphragm area to the tube's cross-sectional area: $(\Pi - \Pi_{1D})/\Pi_{1D} = (1 - (d/D)^2)^3$, where $d$ is the opened diameter and $D$ is the tube diameter.
  • The limiting local frequency of pressure oscillations was found to be approximately $(u+c)/D$, where $u$ and $c$ are post-shock flow velocity and speed of sound, respectively.
  • The amplitude of post-shock oscillations, quantified by Mean Harmonic Energy (MHE), decreases with increasing axial distance from the diaphragm and is inversely proportional to the diameter of the opening section.
  • Numerical simulations closely matched experimental pressure measurements, validating the models and providing detailed insights into the complex wave interactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Axisymmetric Assumption: The numerical model assumes an axisymmetric flow, which simplifies the problem but might not fully capture three-dimensional instabilities that could arise in real flows, particularly at higher Reynolds numbers or with more complex diaphragm geometries. The authors acknowledge that three-dimensional viscous effects are not considered.
  • Instantaneous Opening Approximation: While validated for distant flow fields, the assumption of instantaneous diaphragm opening in simulations might not perfectly represent the initial transient phase, especially for very slow opening times.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further investigation into the three-dimensional nature of these flows and the influence of viscous effects could provide a more complete understanding, especially for phenomena like the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability observed in the slip line. The analytical models could be further refined to better predict amplitude variations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unsteady compressible flows resulting from the incomplete burst of the shock tube diaphragm are investigated both experimentally and numerically for different initial pressure ratios and opening diameters. The intensity of the shock wave is found to be lower than that corresponding to a complete opening. A heuristic relation is proposed to compute the shock strength as a function of the relative area of the open portion of the diaphragm. Strong pressure oscillations past the shock front are also observed. These multi-dimensional disturbances are generated when the initially normal shock wave diffracts from the diaphragm edges and reflects on the shock tube walls, resulting in a complex unsteady flow field behind the leading shock wave. The limiting local frequency of the pressure oscillations is found to be very close to the ratio of acoustic wave speed in the perturbed region to the shock tube diameter. The power associated with these pressure oscillations decreases with increasing distance from the diaphragm since the diffracted and reflected shocks partially coalesce into a single normal shock front. A simple analytical model is devised to explain the reduction of the local frequency of the disturbances as the distance from the leading shock increases.
BibTeX
@article{gaetani2008shock,
  author = {Paolo Gaetani and Alberto Guardone and Giacomo Persico},
  title = {{Shock tube flows past partially opened diaphragms}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1017/s0022112008000815},
}

Loading related content...

Figure