Shock to Thrill: Linking Sensation and Information Seeking

Ern Wong, Tobias U. Hauser, Pietro Pietrini, Charley M. WuPsyArXiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Sensation-seeking is traditionally viewed as a drive for intense, often risky experiences, but this paper suggests a different underlying motive: a hunger for information. By reanalyzing decision-making data with Bayesian models, the authors show that high sensation-seekers aren't necessarily "liking" aversive stimuli like electric shocks; rather, they are significantly less avoidant of the uncertainty surrounding those stimuli.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sensation-seeking (SS) is a personality trait linked to everything from extreme sports to substance abuse and antisocial behavior. Historically, researchers thought sensation-seekers simply assigned a higher "economic value" to intense sensations—meaning they might actually enjoy things others find aversive.

However, the authors of this paper argue that this "value-based" explanation is incomplete. They propose that SS might instead be driven by the exploration-exploitation trade-off. In this view, sensation-seekers are "information-seekers" who are willing to endure aversive outcomes (like a mild electric shock) if it helps them resolve uncertainty about their environment. The gap the authors tackle is whether SS is rooted in a distorted valuation of the stimulus itself or a strategic preference for informative, albeit risky, environments.

Methods

The researchers reanalyzed a dataset from a previous study (Norbury et al., 2015) using a suite of computational models to see which best explained participant behavior.

The task was a "two-armed bandit" game. Participants chose between different visual stimuli (bandits) that yielded points. In the test phase, some bandits were associated with a 75% chance of a mild electric stimulation (MES).

The authors compared four types of models:

  1. The Original Model: Assigned a fixed, binary value to the shock.
  2. Rescorla-Wagner (RW): A standard reinforcement learning model that updates the expected probability of a shock based on trial and error.
  3. Bayesian Learning (Mean Policy): Modeled shock probabilities as Beta distributions, focusing on the expected mean probability.
  4. Bayesian Learning (Uncertainty Policy - BLvar): This novel addition modeled not just the probability of a shock, but the uncertainty (variance) of that probability.

They used Hierarchical Bayesian Modeling (HBM) implemented in STAN to estimate parameters and used Leave-One-Out Information Criteria (LOO-IC) for model comparison.

Datasets

The study pooled data from two previous experiments:

  • Study 1: 39 healthy subjects (after exclusions) performing the sensation-seeking task.
  • Study 2: 28 healthy male subjects who performed the task under three conditions: baseline, placebo, and a 2.5mg dose of haloperidol (a dopamine antagonist).
  • Total N: 73 subjects for the primary analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Information Over Value: The winning model (BLvar) showed that choices were guided by the uncertainty of the shock rather than just its presence or its mean probability. Most people are "uncertainty-avoidant" (they dislike not knowing if a shock is coming), but high sensation-seekers show significantly reduced avoidance.
  • The "Less Avoidant" Sensation-Seeker: High SS scores didn't correlate with "liking" the shock. Instead, they correlated with the $\omega$ (omega) parameter, which represents the weight given to uncertainty. High sensation-seekers were simply less bothered by the "unknown" of the shock.
  • Dopamine's Role is Noisy: Interestingly, blocking dopamine with haloperidol didn't change the information-seeking strategy ($\omega$). Instead, it increased the $\tau$ (tau) parameter, making participants' choices more "stochastic" or random. This suggests dopamine might regulate the "noise" in our decisions rather than the core strategy of seeking information.

Key Results

  • Model Fit: The BLvar model (Bayesian learning with an uncertainty-based choice rule) outperformed all other models, including the original economic model.
  • Correlation with SS: There was a significant positive correlation ($\rho = 0.29, p = .02$) between self-reported sensation-seeking and the $\omega$ parameter. High SS individuals had "flatter" response curves, meaning their probability of choosing a bandit didn't drop as sharply when uncertainty increased.
  • Subscale Specifics: The link to uncertainty was strongest for the "Experience Seeking" and "Disinhibition" subscales of the Sensation-Seeking Scale (SSS-V).
  • Drug Effects: Haloperidol significantly increased choice stochasticity ($p < .001$) but had no significant effect on uncertainty avoidance ($p = .32$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a major hurdle: collinearity. In the original task design, bandits without shocks (CS-) had zero variability, while bandits with shocks (CS+) had high variability. This makes it difficult to perfectly tease apart whether a participant is seeking the shock itself or seeking the information provided by the probabilistic nature of the shock.

Future research should aim to "orthogonalize" these factors—creating scenarios where high-value rewards and high-uncertainty shocks are decoupled. The authors also suggest that studying "extreme" groups (like professional skydivers or clinical populations) might provide a clearer signal than the healthy student populations used here.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sensation-seeking (SS) is characterised by a proclivity for intense experiences and disregard for potential aversive consequences. While SS is implicated as a vulnerability factor in various mental disorders, the underlying mechanisms remain elusive. Recent approaches propose an alternative perspective, suggesting that SS may be linked to highly explorative, and therefore risky, behaviours driven by a preference for informative environments. To probe this hypothesis, we reanalysed a dataset where participants chose to self-administer or avoid mild electric stimulation (MES) in an economic decision-making task. Contrary to previous interpretations associating higher sensation-seeking with the positive economic value of experiencing MES, Bayesian models of learning reveal an alternative account: sensation-seekers are more attuned to information about stimuli-shock contingencies. Specifically, high sensation-seeking individuals are less avoidant of information about the possibility of a shock, supporting the idea that sensation-seeking is linked to a preference for informative environments.
BibTeX
@misc{wong2024shock,
  author = {Ern Wong and Tobias U. Hauser and Pietro Pietrini and Charley M. Wu},
  title = {{Shock to Thrill: Linking Sensation and Information Seeking}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.31234/osf.io/xa6yk},
  howpublished = {PsyArXiv},
}
Figure