Shhh! The Logic of Clandestine Operations

Pavel Naumov, Oliver OrejolaIJCAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a formal logic for reasoning about clandestine operations, where not only the actor's identity but the very existence of the operation is concealed. They develop a sound and complete logical system that captures the interplay between distributed knowledge and coalition power, enabling formal analysis of strategic deception.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In strategic interactions, especially in areas like international relations or security, operations are often designed to be hidden. While existing formalisms can model "covert" operations (where the actor is hidden), they struggle with "clandestine" operations, where the fact that an operation is happening at all is concealed. This distinction is crucial because it implies a deeper level of deception that affects what agents can know and infer about the state of the world. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a logical framework that can formally represent and reason about these more sophisticated forms of hidden actions.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development of a new logical system. This involves:

  • Formal Semantics: They define "clandestine games" with states, indistinguishability relations for agents, and a "mechanism" that describes possible operations. A key aspect is that clandestine operations are defined such that their execution is concealed from certain agents.
  • Syntax and Modalities: They introduce a new modality, denoted as $\Box_C \phi$, which signifies "coalition C knows which clandestine operation it can execute to achieve $\phi$." This modality is designed to capture the know-how aspect of clandestine operations, specifically the ability to achieve a goal through a hidden action.
  • Axiomatization: They propose a set of axioms for this new logic, including standard epistemic axioms (like truth and introspection) and novel axioms tailored to clandestine operations. A particularly important axiom is the "Coalition-Informant-Adversary Principle," which models the dynamics between a performing coalition, passive informants, and active adversaries.
  • Soundness and Completeness: They prove that their logical system is sound (all provable formulas are true in the semantics) and complete (all true formulas are provable), which is a strong theoretical guarantee for the expressiveness and correctness of their logic.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on formal logic and theoretical development, not empirical evaluation on datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clandestine vs. Covert: The paper clearly distinguishes between covert (actor hidden) and clandestine (operation itself hidden) operations, highlighting the need for a richer logical framework for the latter.
  • Know-How for Hidden Actions: The new modality $\Box_C \phi$ captures a specific type of "know-how" related to executing hidden operations, which is not directly expressible in existing coalition logics.
  • The Role of Complements: The logic explicitly models how the knowledge and perception of agents outside a performing coalition (their complements) are crucial for defining clandestine operations.
  • Coalition-Informant-Adversary Dynamics: The dedicated axiom for this scenario is a sophisticated way to model how different groups interact and influence knowledge about hidden actions, especially in the presence of adversaries.
  • Asynchronous Games: The semantics are based on asynchronous games, which is essential for modeling situations where agents might not be aware of transitions happening in the game world.

Key Results

The primary result is the development of a sound and complete logical system for reasoning about clandestine operations. This system provides a formal language and deductive apparatus to analyze strategic deception, coalition power, and distributed knowledge in scenarios involving hidden actions. While no quantitative results on specific tasks are presented, the theoretical achievement of a sound and complete logic is the main outcome.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalization of Clandestine Operations: The authors suggest exploring "partially-clandestine" modalities, where a coalition knows an operation that is unnoticeable to a specific friendly coalition (not just any outside agent).
  • Multi-Step Clandestine Operations: The paper focuses on single clandestine operations. Future work could extend the logic to handle sequences of clandestine actions, similar to multi-step strategies in know-how logics.
  • Non-Concealed Operations: While the current framework excludes non-concealed operations for simplicity, the authors note that their soundness and completeness results would likely hold if these were incorporated with appropriate modifications to the semantics.
  • Practical Applications: The paper lays the theoretical groundwork. Future research could explore how this logic can be applied to model real-world scenarios in areas like cybersecurity, game theory, or international relations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{naumov2023shhh,
  author = {Pavel Naumov and Oliver Orejola},
  title = {{Shhh! The Logic of Clandestine Operations}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2023/368},
}

Loading related content...

Figure