Shared decision-making in healthcare in mainland China: a scoping review

Xuejing Li, Dan Yang, Meiqi Meng, Junqiang Zhao, Yiyi Yin, Hefang Wang, Xiaoyan Zhang, Qian Liu, Mengdi Li, Jianping Liu, Yufang HaoFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

This scoping review, published in Frontiers in Public Health, maps the current landscape of Shared Decision-Making (SDM) in mainland China. By analyzing 60 studies through the lens of the Ottawa Decision Support Framework (ODSF), the authors reveal that while interest in SDM is growing, the practice remains in its "infancy," struggling with a lack of cultural localization and a heavy reliance on Western clinical models.

TL;DR

This scoping review evaluates the state of Shared Decision-Making (SDM) in mainland China, finding that the field is in an early, exploratory phase characterized by a lack of standardized tools and cultural tailoring. The research highlights a critical need to move beyond Western-centric frameworks to account for China’s unique "filial culture" and resource-constrained healthcare environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Shared Decision-Making—a process where clinicians and patients collaborate to reach healthcare choices—is the gold standard in Western medicine. However, implementing SDM in mainland China faces unique hurdles. Historically, Chinese medicine has followed a "paternalistic" model where the physician holds absolute authority.

Furthermore, the Chinese healthcare system deals with massive population pressures, uneven resource distribution, and a "filial culture" where medical decisions are often made by the family collective rather than the individual. This paper seeks to identify the "hotspots" and gaps in Chinese SDM research to determine if Western SDM products can be effectively transferred to this specific clinical and cultural context.

Methods

The authors conducted a scoping review, which is designed to map a broad field rather than answer a narrow clinical question (as a systematic review would).

  • Search Strategy: They queried six English databases (e.g., PubMed, Web of Science) and four Chinese databases (e.g., CNKI, WanFang) for studies published between 1968 and April 2021.
  • Theoretical Framework: Data was synthesized using the Ottawa Decision Support Framework (ODSF), which categorizes SDM into three pillars: Decisional Needs, Decision Support, and Decisional Outcomes.
  • Analysis: The team employed thematic analysis to classify the implementation process and used the "Three-Talk Model" to evaluate doctor-patient communication timing.

Datasets

The "dataset" for this review consists of 60 included studies (out of an initial 9,074 records).

  • Patient Demographics: The studies primarily focused on oncology (30%), cardiovascular diseases (11.67%), chronic diseases (11.67%), and mental health (11.67%).
  • Geographic Focus: Most research originated from major hubs like Guangdong, Hunan, Shanghai, and Beijing.
  • Study Types: Included a mix of randomized controlled trials (23.33%), cross-sectional studies (28.33%), and qualitative research (15%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Motivation Gap": Interestingly, "decision motivation" was a low-frequency finding in Chinese studies. The authors suggest this is a cultural artifact; Chinese patients are often more introverted and culturally conditioned to defer to authority, making it harder for researchers to detect an active desire to participate in decisions.
  • Physiological vs. Psychological: In Western SDM research, outcomes often focus on psychological well-being. In China, there is a much heavier emphasis on physiological outcomes (symptom reduction). The authors attribute this to the "limited resources" landscape, where basic physical health must be prioritized over higher-level decisional satisfaction.
  • The Role of the Family: Unlike the individualistic focus of Western SDM, Chinese decision-making is deeply influenced by "filial piety." Decisions are frequently a negotiation between the doctor and the patient’s family, sometimes even bypassing the patient to avoid "emotional burden."
  • Tool Immaturity: Most Patient Decision Aids (PDAs) in China are still paper-based booklets or simple videos. There is a notable absence of rigorous, standardized development processes (like the IPDAS standards) for these tools.

Key Results

  • Growth Trend: SDM research in China is accelerating, with the majority of literature produced between 2019 and 2021. However, the first clinical practice study only appeared as recently as 2015.
  • Decisional Needs: 66.07% of studies identified "inadequate knowledge" as the primary barrier for patients, followed by a lack of instrumental help (42.86%).
  • Implementation Gaps: While Western models promote multidisciplinary teams (including psychologists and social workers), SDM in China is almost exclusively implemented by physicians and nurses.
  • Framework Usage: Only about 20% of the studies used a theoretical framework to guide their research, with the ODSF being the most common (61.54% of those that used a theory).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Narrow Focus: The review focused on the needs of patients, largely ignoring the decisional needs of families and healthcare providers—a significant oversight given the family-centric nature of Chinese culture.
  2. Framework Bias: Using the Western-developed ODSF may have led researchers to overlook China-specific nuances that don't fit into Western coding categories.

Future Directions: The paper calls for the development of "localized" SDM models that integrate Chinese cultural values. There is also an urgent need for scientifically rigorous standards for developing digital PDAs and a shift toward evaluating long-term "post-decisional" outcomes rather than just immediate satisfaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

https://inplasy.com/?s=202130021.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023shared,
  author = {Xuejing Li and Dan Yang and Meiqi Meng and Junqiang Zhao and Yiyi Yin and Hefang Wang and Xiaoyan Zhang and Qian Liu and Mengdi Li and Jianping Liu and Yufang Hao},
  title = {{Shared decision-making in healthcare in mainland China: a scoping review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1162993},
}
Figure