Shapes of gravity: tensor non-Gaussianity and massive spin-2 fields

Garrett Goon, Kurt Hinterbichler, Austin Joyce, Mark TroddenApollo 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the presence of massive spin-2 fields during inflation could leave detectable imprints on the gravitational wave background, specifically through non-Gaussianities. The authors develop a model-independent framework to classify these imprints, finding that they can significantly alter the expected patterns and potentially be larger than standard gravitational wave signals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Inflation, the hypothesized period of rapid expansion in the early universe, is expected to produce a nearly Gaussian spectrum of primordial gravitational waves. However, deviations from this Gaussianity, known as non-Gaussianities, can carry crucial information about the physics of inflation. While the standard model of cosmology, with only the inflaton and the graviton, predicts specific forms of tensor non-Gaussianities (primarily from the graviton's self-interactions), the presence of other fields, particularly those with high spins like spin-2 particles, could introduce new interaction structures. These new structures could lead to different, potentially observable, shapes of non-Gaussianity. This paper addresses the question of what these new shapes might be and how they could be detected, focusing on the impact of massive spin-2 fields.

Methods

The authors employ a model-independent approach by focusing on the on-shell cubic vertices of interactions involving spin-2 fields. They utilize the cosmological wavefunction formalism, computing it via the path integral approximated by the action evaluated on a classical solution. A key technical component is the derivation of the bulk-to-boundary propagator for a general massive spin-2 field in de Sitter space. They then systematically classify all possible gauge-invariant on-shell cubic interactions between massless and massive spin-2 fields, and between these fields and the graviton. The analysis is performed in d=3 spacetime dimensions for simplicity, allowing for analytical calculations of the resulting wavefunction coefficients and, ultimately, the tensor bispectrum.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • New Shapes of Non-Gaussianity: The presence of massive spin-2 fields introduces new cubic interaction structures beyond those of pure General Relativity. These new structures, when mixed with the graviton, lead to distinct "shapes" of tensor non-Gaussianity.
  • Model Independence: The framework developed is model-independent, meaning it applies to any theory with massive spin-2 fields, regardless of whether they are fundamental or composite.
  • Potential for Enhancement: The contributions from these additional spin-2 fields to the graviton bispectrum can, in principle, be larger than the intrinsic Einstein gravity bispectrum, offering a mechanism to enhance the observable non-Gaussianity.
  • Partially Massless Fields as Key: The paper highlights the partially massless spin-2 field (with mass $m^2 = 2H^2$) as a special case where analytical calculations are tractable and which saturates the Higuchi bound for stable massive spin-2 fields on de Sitter space.
  • Universality of 3-Point Functions: The form of 3-point correlation functions in de Sitter space is highly constrained by symmetries, leading to a finite number of possible shapes, which the authors systematically explore.

Key Results

The paper provides a comprehensive classification of possible on-shell cubic vertices involving massless, partially massless, and massive spin-2 fields. It derives explicit expressions for the cubic wavefunction coefficients that contribute to the graviton bispectrum. For the specific case of a partially massless spin-2 field, analytical expressions for these coefficients and their impact on the graviton bispectrum are presented. The authors demonstrate that these new shapes can be larger than the standard GR contributions and can lead to a significant boost in the observable non-Gaussianity.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that for generic spin-2 masses, analytical evaluation of the non-Gaussianity is not possible, requiring numerical methods. While the paper focuses on d=3 dimensions for analytical tractability, future work could extend these calculations to higher dimensions. The paper also suggests that a more thorough investigation of the degeneracy of these shapes with vacuum modifications or slow-roll suppressed corrections would be valuable. Furthermore, exploring the implications of these findings for higher-point correlation functions and the potential for a systematic analysis using conformal symmetry are identified as important future directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{goon2019shapes,
  author = {Garrett Goon and Kurt Hinterbichler and Austin Joyce and Mark Trodden},
  title = {{Shapes of gravity: tensor non-Gaussianity and massive spin-2 fields}},
  booktitle = {Apollo},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.17863/cam.58643},
}
Figure