Shape Sensing and Kinematic Control of a Cable-Driven Continuum Robot Based on Stretchable Capacitive Sensors

Wen‐Jun Shen, Jianhui He, Guilin Yang, Xiangjie Kong, Haotian Bai, Zaojun FangSensors 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel shape-sensing system for Cable-Driven Continuum Robots (CDCRs) using stretchable capacitive sensors. By accurately measuring the bending of the robot's flexible backbone, they achieve significantly improved trajectory tracking accuracy with a closed-loop control system, outperforming open-loop methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Continuum robots, with their inherent flexibility, are ideal for navigating confined and complex environments like those found in minimally invasive surgery or disaster response. However, their flexible nature makes precise control challenging. The bending of their backbone is influenced by factors beyond just cable lengths, such as gravity and payload, leading to inaccurate kinematic models. To overcome this, accurate "shape sensing" – determining the robot's exact configuration – is crucial. Existing methods like electromagnetic tracking, vision-based systems, and Fiber Bragg Gratings (FBGs) have limitations, including susceptibility to environmental interference, limited workspaces, time delays, or complex integration. This paper aims to provide a more accurate, cost-effective, and easily implementable shape-sensing solution for CDCRs.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a new shape-sensing approach for CDCRs, specifically for their Cable-Driven Continuum Joint Modules (CDCJMs). Each CDCJM uses a patterned flexible backbone that allows for 2-DOF bending. The researchers propose using two stretchable capacitive sensors strategically placed on the backbone to measure its bending. These sensors change capacitance based on their stretched length, which is directly related to the backbone's curvature.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Generic Shape-Sensing Model: A model is developed to relate the stretched lengths of the two sensors to the two joint variables (bending direction angle and bending angle) of the CDCJM.
  • Calibration for Location Errors: Recognizing that precise sensor placement is difficult, a calibration method is introduced to compensate for potential location errors of the stretchable sensors, thereby improving the accuracy of the shape-sensing model.
  • Sliding-Mode Closed-Loop Control: Based on the calibrated shape-sensing model, a robust sliding-mode control strategy is implemented for the CDCR. This control method is known for its effectiveness in handling parameter uncertainties.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize a custom-built CDCR prototype and a Qualisys motion capture system for ground truth measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stretchable Capacitive Sensors as a Viable Alternative: The paper demonstrates that stretchable capacitive sensors can effectively and accurately measure the bending of flexible robot structures, offering a compelling alternative to more complex or sensitive existing technologies.
  • The Importance of Sensor Calibration: Even with a well-designed sensor, location errors can significantly degrade accuracy. The proposed calibration method is crucial for achieving high-performance shape sensing.
  • Synergy of Shape Sensing and Control: The research highlights how accurate shape sensing is a prerequisite for effective closed-loop control in continuum robots, leading to dramatic improvements in trajectory tracking.
  • Cost-Effectiveness and Ease of Implementation: The authors emphasize that their approach offers advantages in terms of cost and ease of integration compared to other shape-sensing techniques.

Key Results

  • Shape-Sensing Accuracy: After calibration, the capacitance errors of the sensors were reduced to 0.1123 pF and 0.0679 pF. The errors in the measured joint variables ($\alpha$ and $\theta$) were approximately 0.03 rad and 0.01 rad, respectively.
  • Trajectory Tracking Improvement: For a CDCR composed of four CDCJMs, the average tracking error for a circular trajectory (55mm radius) was reduced from 49.23 mm (open-loop) to 8.40 mm (closed-loop). This represents an 82.94% reduction in tracking error.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that the accuracy of the shape-sensing model can be affected by location errors of the sensors, which is why the calibration method is so important.
  • While the method is presented as cost-effective, the specific cost comparison to other methods isn't detailed.
  • Future Work:
    • The paper focuses on 2-DOF bending. Future work could explore extending this approach to robots with higher degrees of freedom.
  • Further investigation into the long-term stability and durability of the stretchable capacitive sensors in demanding robotic applications could be beneficial.
  • Exploring different calibration strategies or sensor placement configurations might yield even greater accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

A Cable-Driven Continuum Robot (CDCR) that consists of a set of identical Cable-Driven Continuum Joint Modules (CDCJMs) is proposed in this paper. The CDCJMs merely produce 2-DOF bending motions by controlling driving cable lengths. In each CDCJM, a pattern-based flexible backbone is employed as a passive compliant joint to generate 2-DOF bending deflections, which can be characterized by two joint variables, i.e., the bending direction angle and the bending angle. However, as the bending deflection is determined by not only the lengths of the driving cables but also the gravity and payload, it will be inaccurate to compute the two joint variables with its kinematic model. In this work, two stretchable capacitive sensors are employed to measure the bending shape of the flexible backbone so as to accurately determine the two joint variables. Compared with FBG-based and vision-based shape-sensing methods, the proposed method with stretchable capacitive sensors has the advantages of high sensitivity to the bending deflection of the backbone, ease of implementation, and cost effectiveness. The initial location of a stretchable sensor is generally defined by its two endpoint positions on the surface of the backbone without bending. A generic shape-sensing model, i.e., the relationship between the sensor reading and the two joint variables, is formulated based on the 2-DOF bending deflection of the backbone. To further improve the accuracy of the shape-sensing model, a calibration method is proposed to compensate for the location errors of stretchable sensors. Based on the calibrated shape-sensing model, a sliding-mode-based closed-loop control method is implemented for the CDCR. In order to verify the effectiveness of the proposed closed-loop control method, the trajectory tracking accuracy experiments of the CDCR are conducted based on a circle trajectory, in which the radius of the circle is 55mm. The average tracking errors of the CDCR measured by the Qualisys motion capture system under the open-loop and the closed-loop control are 49.23 and 8.40mm, respectively, which is reduced by 82.94%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2024shape,
  author = {Wen‐Jun Shen and Jianhui He and Guilin Yang and Xiangjie Kong and Haotian Bai and Zaojun Fang},
  title = {{Shape Sensing and Kinematic Control of a Cable-Driven Continuum Robot Based on Stretchable Capacitive Sensors}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24113385},
}
Figure