Shape Optimization of the Triangular Vortex Flowmeter Based on the LBM Method

Qiji Sun, Chenxi Xu, Xuan Zou, Wei Guan, Xiao Liu, Xu Yang, Ao RenSymmetry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel shape optimization for triangular vortex flowmeters using a Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM) coupled with Large Eddy Simulation (LES). The optimized design significantly improves vortex shedding frequency and reduces pressure drop, making it more effective for low-productivity gas wells.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vortex flowmeters are widely used for measuring fluid flow, but their accuracy and stability depend heavily on the performance of the vortex generator. Traditional designs, like cylinders or trapezoids, often suffer from weak vortex signals, low frequency, and interference from secondary vortices, especially at low flow rates common in mature gas wells. This limits their applicability and requires more sophisticated signal processing. The challenge is to design a vortex generator that produces strong, stable, and high-frequency vortexes while minimizing pressure loss, particularly under fluctuating flow conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated numerical simulation technique: the D3Q19 multiple-relaxation-time (MRT) lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) combined with large eddy simulation (LES) for turbulence modeling. This LBM-LES approach is well-suited for simulating complex, turbulent flow phenomena at high Reynolds numbers. They specifically used the OpenLB platform and incorporated a dynamic sub-grid-scale stress model (SGS) to accurately capture small-scale turbulent vortices. The optimization process involved systematically modifying the shape of a triangular vortex generator, focusing on three key areas: the incoming flow surface, the side profile, and the end fillet. Numerical simulations were performed to evaluate the impact of these geometric changes on vortex shedding frequency, lift force, and pressure drop.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Matters Dramatically: Even subtle changes to the geometry of the vortex generator, particularly the incoming flow surface angle, the side curvature, and the end fillet, have a profound impact on vortex dynamics, frequency, and stability.
  • Concave Sides for Better Vortexes: A concave arc on the side of the vortex generator, rather than a sharp corner, helps in the reverse expansion of the vortex, reducing interference from the main flow and increasing vortex intensity.
  • Smooth Ends Reduce Noise: Eliminating sharp inflection points at the end of the generator, by introducing a fillet, helps suppress secondary vortex generation and reduces noise interference, leading to more symmetrical vortex streets.
  • LBM-LES is Powerful for Complex Flows: The combination of LBM and LES proved effective in simulating the intricate 3D turbulent flow around the vortex generator, providing detailed insights into vortex shedding and pressure fields that would be difficult to obtain otherwise.
  • Trade-offs Exist: Optimizing for one parameter (e.g., high frequency) might negatively impact another (e.g., symmetry or pressure loss), requiring a careful balance.

Key Results

The optimized triangular vortex generator, featuring a 180° incoming flow surface, a concave arc side with a 25 mm curvature radius, and a 4 mm fillet radius at the end, demonstrated significant improvements:

  • Increased Vortex Shedding Frequency: Achieved a 2.72% to 13.8% increase compared to the original triangular design.
  • Reduced Pressure Drop: Showed a 17.2% to 53.9% reduction in pressure drop.
  • Improved Symmetry and Stability: The generated vortex streets were more symmetrical and stable, leading to better signal detection.
  • Adaptability: The optimized design is effective across a range of Reynolds numbers relevant to gas well production fluctuations (6.498 × 10⁵ ≤ Re ≤ 22.597 × 10⁵).
  • Smaller Influence Area: The optimized vortex generator had a smaller vorticity influence area in the pipeline, indicating less disturbance to the flow and lower resistance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Reynolds Number Performance: The study primarily focused on high Reynolds numbers relevant to typical gas well operations. The performance of the optimized vortex generator under very low Reynolds number conditions (which can occur in later stages of oil field development) needs further investigation.
  • Multiphase Flow: The simulations assumed pure methane gas. Real-world applications might involve liquid-phase fluids, which could affect vortex generation and stability. Future research should explore multiphase flow conditions and the impact of water content.
  • Experimental Validation: While the numerical simulations are robust, further experimental validation is required to confirm the accuracy and reliability of the optimized design in practical applications.
  • Inverse Analysis for High-Frequency Signals: The development of an inverse analysis program for high-frequency vortex signals is ongoing and will be crucial for a comprehensive evaluation of the optimized generator's performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sun2025shape,
  author = {Qiji Sun and Chenxi Xu and Xuan Zou and Wei Guan and Xiao Liu and Xu Yang and Ao Ren},
  title = {{Shape Optimization of the Triangular Vortex Flowmeter Based on the LBM Method}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/sym17040534},
}
Figure