SHANXIHIPPUS DERMATORHINUS COMB. NOV. WITH COMPARISONS TO OLD WORLD HIPPARIONS WITH SPECIALIZED NASAL APPARATI

Raymond L. Bernor, Shiqi Wang, Yan Liu, Yu Chen, Boyang SunRiviste 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Skulls, mandibles and dentitions of a new, monospecific lineage of late Miocene Chinese hipparionine horse, Shanxihippus dermatorhinus nov comb. are reported. We frame our description of this newly recognized genus with a comparison to primitive North American hipparion, Cormohipparion occidentale and Central European Hippotherium primigenium from the Vienna Basin and Hoewenegg, Germany. We recognize, for the first time that the Chinese early late Miocene hipparion “Hipparion” weihoense is primitive and referable to Hippotherium extending the range of that lineage in the early late Miocene (MN9 equivalent) from China to Central and Western Europe. We develop a multistate 53 character state analysis including primitive species of Hippotherium, Sivalhippus, Shanxihippus, Cremohipparion and Proboscidipparion to undertake a cladistic analysis using four consecutively further removed North American outgroups. We evaluate the phylogenetic relationships of these taxa and pose hypotheses of origin and biogeographic distribution of these superspecific taxa in the late Miocene of Eurasia. We conclude that Shanxihippus, Cremohipparion and Proboscidipparion are three distinct clades, held at Genus rank, that have converged in their snout lengthening and nasal retraction likely due to similarities in feeding adaptation.

Introduction: The Hipparionine Puzzle

The taxonomy of "hipparionine" horses—a diverse group of three-toed horses that dominated the Old World during the Miocene—has long been a puzzle for paleontologists. Specifically, several species from China and Europe exhibited bizarre facial anatomy, including extremely long snouts and nasal bones that were "retracted" (pushed back toward the eyes). Previously, many of these specimens were lumped into the broad genus Hipparion. This study seeks to determine if these specialized nasal structures were a sign of a single shared ancestry or if different groups of horses arrived at the same "design" independently.

Methodology

The researchers employed a combination of classical morphology and modern computational phylogenetics. Detailed anatomical descriptions of fossil skulls, mandibles, and teeth were conducted, focusing on two key specimens from Shanxi Province, China. To quantify these differences, a Log 10 Ratio Analysis was used to compare the proportions of various skull measurements (e.g., muzzle length, notch position) against a standard reference species, Hippotherium primigenium.

Furthermore, a Cladistic Analysis was performed using a matrix of 53 morphological characters across 14 taxa. This data was processed using TNT 1.1 software to generate the most parsimonious phylogenetic trees, using North American horses (Cormohipparion, Merychippus, and Parahippus) as outgroups to root the tree.

Geographic Distribution and Datasets

The study draws on several key fossil datasets from across the globe. Primary specimens include the lectotype skull (PMU M3872) and an adult female skull (AMNH 41 L310) from the Baode region of China. Comparative data was gathered from Sivalhippus (Pakistan), Cremohipparion (Greece and China), and Proboscidipparion (China and Turkey).

Geographic distribution of late Miocene hipparionine horse lineages across Eurasia and North America.

By identifying Hippotherium in China (formerly "Hipparion" weihoense), the authors demonstrate a massive, continuous biological corridor for horses stretching from Western Europe to East Asia around 11 million years ago. This reclassification significantly extends the known geographic range of the Hippotherium lineage.

Evolutionary Insights: Convergence and the "Pseudo-Proboscis"

The most significant finding is that Shanxihippus, Cremohipparion, and Proboscidipparion are not closely related members of a single "weird-nosed" group. Instead, they represent three distinct clades that independently evolved elongated snouts and retracted nasals. This is a striking example of convergent evolution.

The extreme retraction of the nasal bones suggests these horses possessed highly mobile upper lips or even small, tapir-like trunks (proboscides). This "pseudo-proboscis" is interpreted as a functional adaptation for selective feeding—the ability to deftly pick out high-quality leaves, forbs, or grass shoots in the diverse "Pikermian" woodlands of the late Miocene.

Key Results and Taxonomic Revisions

The authors formally erect the genus Shanxihippus (type species: S. dermatorhinus). The cladistic analysis places Shanxihippus as a sister group to Proboscidipparion, likely descending from an ancestor related to the Indian Sivalhippus.

Log 10 ratio plots comparing cranial measurements of Shanxihippus dermatorhinus against various Eurasian hipparionines.

Quantitatively, Shanxihippus is unique, possessing the narrowest muzzle width among the studied taxa and a nasal notch retracted as far back as the fourth premolar (P4). The specialized Shanxihippus lineage appears to have been endemic to China, thriving approximately 5.7 to 7.0 million years ago.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the cranial evidence is robust, the study is limited by the lack of postcranial anatomy (limbs and body skeleton) for Shanxihippus, which restricts our understanding of its locomotion. Future work should focus on finding associated skeletal material and performing stable isotope analysis of tooth enamel to confirm the specific dietary niches of these specialized horses. Ultimately, this research clarifies the complex evolutionary history of Eurasian horses and highlights the role of environmental selective pressures in shaping unique cranial morphologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Skulls, mandibles and dentitions of a new, monospecific lineage of late Miocene Chinese hipparionine horse, Shanxihippus dermatorhinus nov comb.are reported. We frame our description of this newly recognized genus with a comparison to primitive North American hipparion, Cormohipparion occidentale and Central European Hippotherium primigenium from the Vienna Basin and Hoewenegg, Germany. We recognize, for the first time that the Chinese early late Miocene hipparion “Hipparion” weihoense is primitive and referable to Hippotherium extending the range of that lineage in the early late Miocene (MN9 equivalent) from China to Central and Western Europe. We develop a multistate 53 character state analysis including primitive species of Hippotherium, Sivalhippus, Shanxihippus, Cremohipparion and Proboscidipparion to undertake a cladistic analysis using four consecutively further removed North American outgroups: Cormohipparion occidentale, Cormohipparion quinni, Merychippus insignis and Parahippus leonensis. We evaluate the phylogenetic relationships of these taxa and pose hypotheses of origin and biogeographic distribution of these superspecific taxa in the late Miocene of Eurasia. We conclude that Shanxihippus, Cremohipparion and Proboscidipparion are three distinct clades, held at Genus rank, that have converged in their snout lengthening and nasal retraction likely due to similarities in feeding adaptation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bernor2018shanxihippus,
  author = {Raymond L. Bernor and Shiqi Wang and Yan Liu and Yu Chen and Boyang Sun},
  title = {{SHANXIHIPPUS DERMATORHINUS COMB. NOV. WITH COMPARISONS TO OLD WORLD HIPPARIONS WITH SPECIALIZED NASAL APPARATI}},
  booktitle = {Riviste},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.13130/2039-4942/10202},
}
Figure