Abstract
Objective: To reconstruct a sex-specific patient journey for Dutch persons with Parkinson's disease (PD) during the first 5 years after diagnosis. Method: We analyzed a national administrative medical claims database containing data of all patients newly diagnosed with PD between 2012 and 2016 in the Netherlands. We performed time-to-event analysis to identify the moments when patients received care from neurologists, allied healthcare therapists or general practitioners. We also extracted relevant clinical milestones: unexpected hospitalization for PD, pneumonia, orthopedic injuries, nursing home admission, and death. Results: We included claims data of 13,518 men and 8,775 women with newly diagnosed PD. While we found little difference in neurologist consultations, women visited general practitioners and physiotherapists significantly earlier and more often (all p-values < 0.001). Approximately 2 years after diagnosis, PD-related complications occurred for the first time (women: 1.8 years; men: 2.3 years), and after 5 years, 72.9% of women and 68.7% of men had experienced at least one. Discussion: Findings suggest that women experience complications and access most healthcare services sooner after diagnosis and more frequently than men, extending the debate about phenotypical differences in PD.
Introduction
Parkinson’s Disease (PD) is a notoriously heterogeneous condition; no two patients follow the exact same path. While it is established that men are more likely to develop PD and often do so at an earlier age, there has been a lack of longitudinal data mapping how the "journey" through the healthcare system differs between sexes. This study, published in Frontiers in Neurology, utilizes a massive national claims database to map the first five years of life with PD for over 22,000 patients in the Netherlands.
Methods
The researchers performed a retrospective cohort study using the Vektis database, which contains administrative medical claims for roughly 99.8% of the Dutch population. The study analyzed 22,293 newly diagnosed PD patients (13,518 men and 8,775 women) from 2012–2016.
- Time-to-Event Analysis: Kaplan-Meier estimators were used to determine the median time from diagnosis to specific "milestones."
- Milestones Tracked: These included visits to General Practitioners (GPs), neurologists, and allied health professionals (physiotherapists, occupational therapists, speech therapists), as well as clinical complications (pneumonia, orthopedic injuries, unexpected hospitalizations), nursing home admission, and death.
Healthcare Utilization: The "Earlier and More Often" Trend
A recurring theme in the results was that women accessed almost all healthcare services (except neurology) sooner and more frequently than men. For example, women saw a GP for the first time 10 days earlier than men and started physiotherapy nearly three months sooner (median 140 days vs 229 days).
Interestingly, the frequency of neurologist consultations was nearly identical between sexes. This suggests that while specialized "top-down" care is consistent, the "bottom-up" management in primary and allied care is where the sex divergence happens.
Clinical Milestones and Complications
Women hit clinical milestones and experienced complications significantly faster than men.
- Complication Velocity: Women experienced their first PD-related complication at a median of 1.8 years post-diagnosis, compared to 2.3 years for men.
- Orthopedic Injuries: These occurred significantly earlier in women (median 1,114 days) than in men (median > 1,826 days).
- Nursing Home Admission: Women were more likely to be living in a nursing home at the time of diagnosis (8.3% vs 5.0% for men). By year five, 27.2% of women were in nursing homes, versus 22.5% of men.
The Survival Paradox
Despite hitting complications faster and having higher rates of nursing home admission, women exhibited a lower 5-year mortality rate (14.6%) compared to men (18.3%). This suggests that while women may face a higher burden of morbidity and healthcare needs early in the disease course, they maintain a survival advantage over men.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The identified sex differences suggest that PD progression or healthcare-seeking behavior is deeply sex-specific, necessitating a more personalized approach to integrated care. The earlier orthopedic injuries in women might be partially explained by higher rates of underlying osteoporosis, while higher service usage might reflect different social support systems. Future work should validate these findings in other healthcare structures and investigate the underlying biological and social drivers of these divergent journeys.
Summary updated