Abstract
The complexity of neural activity is a commonly used read-out of healthy functioning in cortical circuits. Prior work has linked neural complexity to the level of maternal care in preterm infants at risk for developing mental disorders, yet the evolution of neural complexity in early human development is largely unknown. We hypothesized that cortical dynamics would evolve to optimize information processing as birth approaches, thereby increasing the complexity of cortical activity. To test this hypothesis, we conducted the first ever study relating prenatal neural complexity to maturation. MEG recordings were obtained from a sample of fetuses and newborns, including longitudinal data before and after birth. Using cortical responses to auditory irregularities, we computed several entropy measures which reflect the complexity of the MEG signal. Despite our hypothesis, neural complexity significantly decreased with maturation in both fetuses and newborns. Furthermore, we found that complexity decreased significantly faster in male fetuses for most entropy measures. Our surprising results lay the groundwork for the first ever mapping of how neural complexity evolves in early human development, with important implications for future efforts to develop predictive biomarkers of psychiatric disorders based on the complexity of perinatal MEG signals.
Introduction
Neural complexity—the unpredictability or richness of brain signals—is a reliable marker for consciousness in adults. It typically drops during deep sleep or anesthesia and increases during heightened states of awareness. Consequently, researchers have long hypothesized that as the human fetus develops the capacity for perception and consciousness, its neural complexity should rise. However, the prenatal period remains a "terra incognita" of brain dynamics. This study provides the first systematic investigation into how event-related neural complexity evolves during the final weeks of pregnancy and the first weeks of postnatal life, testing whether the brain starts in a state of high-entropy chaos that is sculpted into functional circuits.
Methods
The researchers employed Magnetoencephalography (MEG)—specifically fetal MEG (fMEG) and neonatal MEG—to record brain activity. The study utilized datasets from the fMEG Center at the University of Tübingen, including 81 recordings from 43 fetuses (gestational age 25–40 weeks) and 20 recordings from 20 newborns (age 13–59 days).
Participants were subjected to a "local-global" auditory oddball task. In this paradigm, sequences of tones (e.g., ssss) were occasionally interrupted by a "global deviant" (e.g., sssd). These sensory perturbations are designed to probe the thalamocortical system, similar to the Perturbational Complexity Index used in adults. The team calculated six entropy measures, including Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC) and Permutation Entropy (PermEn). Crucially, they used a novel decomposition technique to separate entropy changes into those caused by signal amplitude (the structured shape of the brain's response) and non-amplitude factors (such as the timing or phase of neural firing).
Results
Contrary to the initial hypothesis, total neural complexity significantly decreased with maturation in both fetuses and newborns. All six entropy measures showed a significant negative correlation with gestational age. The strongest effect was observed in PermEn32 (sensitive to 4–10 Hz activity), which yielded a t-statistic of -4.71 ($P_{FDR} < 0.0001$) in fetuses and -3.85 ($P_{FDR} < 0.005$) in newborns.
Decomposition analysis provided a critical explanation for this surprising decline. The maturation of Event-Related Fields (ERFs)—the brain's structured response to sound—increases signal amplitude and imposes a predictable "shape" on the data, which naturally lowers total entropy. While this amplitude component drove entropy down, the non-amplitude (phase) components actually showed an increase in entropy with age. This suggests that while the overall signal becomes more structured, the underlying neural timing is becoming more complex, potentially serving as the true marker of emerging consciousness. Additionally, the study found that complexity decreased significantly faster in male fetuses across most entropy measures.
Discussion
The findings suggest that the maturing brain undergoes a process of "canalization," where multiple possible neural configurations are pruned and sculpted into specific, efficient functional patterns. This transition from high-entropy chaos to structured order reflects the development of functional cortical circuits.
While temporal entropy decreases, the authors hypothesize that spatial entropy—how complexity varies across different brain regions—might increase as neural connections form. Future studies using Optically Pumped Magnetometers (OPMs) could map these spatial dynamics. Ultimately, establishing these developmental trajectories may allow researchers to use abnormal entropy patterns as early biomarkers for neurodevelopmental disorders like autism or schizophrenia, which are characterized by aberrant neural pruning.
Summary updated