Sex differences in deep brain shape and asymmetry persist across schizophrenia and healthy individuals: A meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-Schizophrenia Working Group

Daniel G. Cimmino, Brinley N. Zabriskie, Steven G. Luke, Boris A. Gutman, Dmitry Isaev, Kathryn Alpert, David C. Glahn, Amanda Rodrigue, Sinead Kelly, Godfrey D. Pearlson, Vince D. Calhoun, Stefan Ehrlich, Ole A. Andreassen, Diana Tordesillas‐Gutiérrez, Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Raquel E. Gur, Ruben C. Gur, Gianfranco Spalletta, Fabrizio Piras, Gary Donohoe, Colm McDonald, Edith Pomarol‐Clotet, Raymond Salvador, Andriana Karuk, Aristotle N. Voineskos, Peter Kochunov, Stefan Borgwardt, Ingrid Agartz, Erik G. Jönsson, Tilo Kircher, Frederike Stein, Katharina Brosch, Igor Nenadić, Felice Iasevoli, Giuseppe Pontillo, Andrea de Bartolomeis, Annarita Barone, M. Ciccarelli, Annabella Di Giorgio, Arturo Brunetti, Sirio Cocozza, Mario Tranfa, Anthony James, Mojtaba Zarei, Morgan Hough, Lena Flyckt, Geraldo F. Busatto, Pedro G. P. Rosa, Maurício H. Serpa, Marcus V. Zanetti, Theo G.m. van Erp, Adrian Preda, Dana Nguyen, Paul M. Thompson, Jessica A. Turner, Lei Wang, Derin CobiabioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This large-scale meta-analysis reveals that sex differences in deep brain structure are remarkably consistent across both healthy individuals and those with schizophrenia. The study highlights that these sex-based morphological patterns are a fundamental aspect of brain organization, suggesting that future neurobiological research, particularly in schizophrenia, must account for sex as a critical variable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Schizophrenia is a complex disorder characterized by significant cognitive and perceptual disturbances, often accompanied by neurobiological abnormalities. While research has identified structural differences in the brain associated with schizophrenia, the role of sex in these differences has been less clear. Clinical presentations of schizophrenia can vary between men and women, hinting at potentially distinct underlying neurobiological mechanisms. This study aims to disentangle the effects of schizophrenia diagnosis and biological sex on the shape and asymmetry of deep brain structures, seeking to understand if sex differences in brain morphology are altered by the disease or if they persist independently.

Methods

The researchers employed a meta-analytic approach, combining data from multiple international sites. They utilized the ENIGMA-Shape pipeline, a standardized protocol for analyzing T1-weighted structural MRI scans. This pipeline quantifies deep brain morphology using surface metrics, specifically focusing on shape deformation, which can be understood as "thinning/thickening" and "contraction/expansion" of brain regions. Statistical analyses involved mass univariate meta-analyses to assess main effects of diagnosis and sex, as well as their interaction. Additionally, meta-regression models were used to explore the relationships between brain shape and clinical variables (e.g., medication, symptoms) in individuals with schizophrenia.

Datasets

The study analyzed archival data from twenty-three cross-sectional samples collected through the ENIGMA Schizophrenia Working Group. This included a total of 6,861 participants: 2,826 individuals with schizophrenia (1,871 males and 955 females) and 4,035 healthy controls (2,158 males and 1,877 females).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sex Differences are Fundamental: The most striking finding is the robustness of sex differences in deep brain shape, persisting across both healthy individuals and those with schizophrenia. This suggests these are not artifacts of the disease but rather inherent characteristics of male and female brains.
  • Schizophrenia Doesn't "Override" Sex Differences: The lack of a significant diagnosis-by-sex interaction implies that schizophrenia doesn't differentially impact male and female brains in terms of deep brain shape. The observed sex differences in brain morphology are largely the same, whether individuals have schizophrenia or not.
  • Consistent Patterns Across Regions: Specific patterns of shape deformation were consistently observed. For instance, females generally showed more concave (thinner/contracted) shapes in regions like the thalamus, pallidum, putamen, and amygdala compared to males, regardless of diagnosis.
  • Clinical Correlates are Sex-Similar: While there were some relationships between brain shape and clinical factors (like medication or positive symptoms), these associations were largely similar for both men and women with schizophrenia, reinforcing the idea that the disease's impact on brain structure doesn't strongly diverge based on sex.

Key Results

  • Main Effect of Sex: Females exhibited more concave-than-convex shape differences in the thalamus, pallidum, putamen, and amygdala compared to males, across both diagnostic groups. These effects ranged from small to moderate (d = -0.35 to 0.20).
  • Main Effect of Diagnosis: Consistent with prior work, individuals with schizophrenia showed more concave-than-convex shape differences in the hippocampus, amygdala, nucleus accumbens, and thalamus, and more convex-than-concave differences in the putamen and pallidum compared to healthy controls.
  • No Diagnosis-by-Sex Interaction: This was a key finding, indicating that schizophrenia did not significantly alter the typical sex differences in deep brain shape.
  • Clinical Correlates: Small but significant relationships were found between higher chlorpromazine (CPZ) dose and shape-derived thinning/contraction in several deep brain regions in both male and female patients. Similarly, elevated positive symptoms (SAPS scores) were associated with thinning/contraction in specific regions for both sexes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the meta-analytic approach, while powerful for large sample sizes, can be limited by data heterogeneity across sites. The use of FreeSurfer software can also introduce noise in vertex-wise measurements.
  • Future Work: The study suggests further research is needed to explore these sex-based dimensions independently and to determine if these patterns extend to other brain regions and neurobiological aspects of schizophrenia. Investigating the granular (molecular, genetic) and macro (connectivity) bases of these sex differences could shed light on why they persist in the face of schizophrenia and their role in resilience or susceptibility. The authors also propose that treatments and diagnostic criteria might need reconsideration to better account for persistent sex differences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Schizophrenia (SCZ) is characterized by a disconnect from reality that manifests as various clinical and cognitive symptoms, and persistent neurobiological abnormalities. Sex-related differences in clinical presentation imply separate brain substrates. The present study characterized deep brain morphology using shape features to understand the independent effects of diagnosis and sex on the brain, and to determine whether the neurobiology of schizophrenia varies as a function of sex. Methods This study analyzed multi-site archival data from 1,871 male (M) and 955 female (F) participants with SCZ, and 2,158 male and 1,877 female healthy controls (CON) from twenty-three cross-sectional samples from the ENIGMA Schizophrenia Workgroup. Harmonized shape analysis protocols were applied to each site’s data for seven deep brain regions obtained from T1-weighted structural MRI scans. Effect sizes were calculated for the following main contrasts: 1) Sex effects;2) Diagnosis-by-Sex interaction; 3) within sex tests of diagnosis; 4) within diagnosis tests of sex differences. Meta-regression models between brain structure and clinical variables were also computed separately in men and women with schizophrenia. Results Mass univariate meta-analyses revealed more concave-than-convex shape differences in all regions for women relative to men, across diagnostic groups ( d = -0.35 to 0.20, SE = 0.02 to 0.07); there were no significant diagnosis-by-sex interaction effects. Within men and women separately, we identified more-concave-than-convex shape differences for the hippocampus, amygdala, accumbens, and thalamus, with more-convex-than-concave differences in the putamen and pallidum in SCZ ( d = -0.30 to 0.30, SE = 0.03 to 0.10). Within CON and SZ separately, we found more-concave-than-convex shape differences in the thalamus, pallidum, putamen, and amygdala among females compared to males, with mixed findings in the hippocampus and caudate ( d = -0.30 to 0.20, SE = 0.03 to 0.09). Meta-regression models revealed similarly small, but significant relationships, with medication and positive symptoms in both SCZ-M and SCZ-F. Conclusions Sex-specific variation is an overriding feature of deep brain shape regardless of disease status, underscoring persistent patterns of sex differences observed both within and across diagnostic categories, and highlighting the importance of including it as a critical variable in studies of neurobiology. Future work should continue to explore these dimensions independently to determine whether these patterns of brain morphology extend to other aspects of neurobiology in schizophrenia, potentially uncovering broader implications for diagnosis and treatment. Key Points Statistical analyses revealed significant main effects for diagnosis and sex in deep brain shape morphology. Among patients with schizophrenia, there was a pattern of thinning and surface contraction in the bilateral hippocampus, amygdala, accumbens, and thalamus, and a pattern of significant thickening and surface expansion in the bilateral putamen and pallidum compared to healthy control participants. Between males and females, there was a pattern of significant thinning and surface contraction in the bilateral thalamus, pallidum, putamen, and amygdala in females compared to males. There was no significant interaction between diagnosis and biological sex, suggesting that sex differences in deep brain shape and asymmetry among patients with schizophrenia reflect those observed in healthy individuals. Small but statistically significant relationships exist between brain structure and clinical correlates of schizophrenia were similar for both men and women with the disease, such that higher CPZ was associated with shape-derived thinning and surface contraction in the caudate, accumbens, hippocampus, amygdala, and thalamus, and elevated positive symptoms were associated with shape-derived thinning and surface contraction in the bilateral caudate, right hippocampus, and right amygdala.
BibTeX
@misc{cimmino2024sex,
  author = {Daniel G. Cimmino and Brinley N. Zabriskie and Steven G. Luke and Boris A. Gutman and Dmitry Isaev and Kathryn Alpert and David C. Glahn and Amanda Rodrigue and Sinead Kelly and Godfrey D. Pearlson and Vince D. Calhoun and Stefan Ehrlich and Ole A. Andreassen and Diana Tordesillas‐Gutiérrez and Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro and Theodore D. Satterthwaite and Raquel E. Gur and Ruben C. Gur and Gianfranco Spalletta and Fabrizio Piras and Gary Donohoe and Colm McDonald and Edith Pomarol‐Clotet and Raymond Salvador and Andriana Karuk and Aristotle N. Voineskos and Peter Kochunov and Stefan Borgwardt and Ingrid Agartz and Erik G. Jönsson and Tilo Kircher and Frederike Stein and Katharina Brosch and Igor Nenadić and Felice Iasevoli and Giuseppe Pontillo and Andrea de Bartolomeis and Annarita Barone and M. Ciccarelli and Annabella Di Giorgio and Arturo Brunetti and Sirio Cocozza and Mario Tranfa and Anthony James and Mojtaba Zarei and Morgan Hough and Lena Flyckt and Geraldo F. Busatto and Pedro G. P. Rosa and Maurício H. Serpa and Marcus V. Zanetti and Theo G.M. van Erp and Adrian Preda and Dana Nguyen and Paul M. Thompson and Jessica A. Turner and Lei Wang and Derin Cobia},
  title = {{Sex differences in deep brain shape and asymmetry persist across schizophrenia and healthy individuals: A meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-Schizophrenia Working Group}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.10.24.619733},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure