Sex Differences in Cluster Headache: Insights from the Chinese Cluster Headache Register Individual Study (CHRIS)

Yuhan Wu, Chun-Fu Chen, Sui-yi Xu, Hongru Zhao, Xingkai An, Kaiming Liu, Wensheng Qu, Hongling Zhao, Ran Zhang, Dan Wang, Zhiliang Fan, Yuanrong Yao, Zhibin Zhou, Huifang Xu, Wei Gui, Yabin Ji, Ling Chen, Jianjun Chen, Bing Wen, Zheman Xiao, Hebo Wang, Liang Zhang, Qiuling Tong, Xiaosu Yang, Zhonglin Liu, Songjie Liao, Ziru Li, Kunlin Zhang, Lin Ma, Shuhua Zhang, Shengyuan Yu, Mingjie Zhang, Zhao DongResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Sex differences in the clinical characteristics of cluster headache (CH) remain controversial in both Eastern and Western studies, and such differences have not been thoroughly investigated among Chinese patients. Methods: This large-scale, multicenter cohort study included 1,206 patients from 31 provinces across China diagnosed with CH between May 2021 and December 2024, and was conducted within the framework of the Chinese Cluster Headache Register Individual Study. Demographic and clinical data were systematically collected from each participant using an electronic structured questionnaire, and compared all variables between sexes. Results: In total, 1,206 patients were enrolled, with a female-to-male ratio of 1:3.94. Demographic analysis showed that women had an earlier mean age of onset, higher educational attainment, and fewer unhealthy lifestyle factors compared with men. Women were also more likely to have comorbid migraine (28.28% vs. 15.90%, P < 0.001) and psychological conditions such as anxiety and depression, and to use oral rizatriptan for acute treatment (27.78% vs. 15.80%, P < 0.001). With respect to cranial autonomic symptoms (CASs), women experienced eyelid edema (18.85% vs. 12.47%, P = 0.010) and ptosis (56.97% vs. 49.90%, P = 0.048) more frequently, and reported migraine-associated symptoms more often. Conversely, men more commonly presented with conjunctival hyperemia (56.03% vs. 38.52%, P < 0.001), rhinorrhea (47.92% vs. 38.93%, P = 0.012), and facial sweating (38.15% vs. 30.74%, P = 0.032). Women had significantly higher frequencies of attacks during the early morning hours (2:00–8:00), whereas men experienced significantly more attacks during midday (10:00–14:00) and evening (16:00–20:00). Conclusion: This study provides the first comprehensive analysis of multidimensional sex differences in Chinese patients with CH, encompassing social characteristics, clinical phenotypes, psychological burden, and circadian attack distribution. These findings offer valuable evidence for developing precision medicine approaches and sex-specific clinical management strategies for CH.

Introduction

Cluster headache (CH) is a primary headache disorder characterized by excruciating, unilateral pain, often described as the "suicide headache." Historically, CH was considered a predominantly male condition, with early clinical reports suggesting a male-to-female ratio as high as 9:1. However, recent Western studies have indicated a narrowing of this gap and identified distinct sex-specific clinical features.

In Asian populations, data regarding sex differences in CH have remained sparse and inconsistent. This study addresses the critical need for large-scale, multidimensional evidence on how biological sex influences the manifestation, timing, and psychological impact of CH in China. Understanding these disparities is essential for improving diagnostic accuracy—particularly for women, whose symptoms often overlap with migraine—and for tailoring clinical management.

Methods

The study utilized data from the Chinese Cluster Headache Register Individual Study (CHRIS), a large-scale, multicenter cohort.

  • Participants: 1,206 patients (962 men and 244 women) were recruited from 67 healthcare centers across 31 Chinese provinces between May 2021 and December 2024.
  • Data Collection: A comprehensive 82-item electronic structured questionnaire was used to collect demographic data, clinical phenotypes, and treatment history.
  • Psychological Assessment: Validated Chinese versions of the GAD-7 and PHQ-9 scales were employed to assess anxiety and depression.
  • Statistical Analysis: Sex-based comparisons were performed using t-tests, Mann-Whitney U tests, and Chi-square tests to identify significant differences.

Results

Demographic and Lifestyle Disparities

The study revealed significant demographic differences between male and female CH patients. Women tended to have an earlier age of onset (median 21 vs. 25 years) and higher levels of educational attainment. Lifestyle factors also differed markedly; men were significantly more likely to smoke and consume alcohol compared to women.

Demographic and lifestyle characteristics of the study population by sex.

Clinical Phenotypes and "Migraine-Like" Features

A distinct "female phenotype" emerged, characterized by symptoms often associated with migraine. Women were significantly more likely to experience nausea, vomiting, photophobia, and dental pain. Furthermore, comorbid migraine was nearly twice as common in women (28.28%) than in men (15.90%).

In terms of cranial autonomic symptoms (CASs), men more frequently reported "classic" signs such as conjunctival hyperemia (56.03% vs. 38.52%) and rhinorrhea (47.92% vs. 38.93%). Women, however, showed higher rates of eyelid edema and ptosis.

Circadian Attack Distribution

One of the most notable findings was the sex-specific timing of attacks. Women experienced a peak in attack frequency during the early morning hours (2:00–8:00 AM). In contrast, men were more prone to attacks during the midday (10:00–14:00) and evening (16:00–20:00) periods.

Psychological Burden and Treatment

Women reported significantly higher levels of anxiety and depression. While both sexes experienced high rates of suicidal ideation (21.7% in women vs. 17.9% in men), the difference was not statistically significant, underscoring the severe impact of CH on mental health regardless of sex. Regarding treatment, while oxygen therapy was highly rated by both groups, women were more likely to use oral rizatriptan, potentially reflecting their higher rate of migraine comorbidity.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study provides the most comprehensive analysis to date of sex differences in Chinese CH patients. The shifting gender ratio (now 1:3.94) suggests improved diagnostic awareness for women in China, aligning with global trends. The identification of a "migraine-like" profile in women highlights a significant risk for misdiagnosis, necessitating sex-aware diagnostic protocols.

Limitations

The study is subject to recall bias due to its questionnaire-based design and potential selection bias as a hospital-based cohort. Additionally, the underlying biological mechanisms, such as the role of sex hormones or the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis, were not explored in this phase.

Future Directions

Future research should focus on the biological drivers of these sex differences and the implementation of standardized treatment protocols. Currently, only a small fraction of patients (15.75%) receive appropriate preventive therapy, indicating a clear need for improved clinical education and precision medicine approaches in the management of cluster headache.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background</bold> Sex differences in the clinical characteristics of cluster headache (CH) remain controversial in both Eastern and Western studies, and such differences have not been thoroughly investigated among Chinese patients. <bold>Methods</bold> This large-scale, multicenter cohort study included 1,206 patients from 31 provinces across China diagnosed with CH between May 2021 and December 2024, and was conducted within the framework of the Chinese Cluster Headache Register Individual Study. Demographic and clinical data were systematically collected from each participant using an electronic structured questionnaire, and compared all variables between sexes. <bold>Results</bold> In total, 1,206 patients were enrolled, with a female-to-male ratio of 1:3.94. Demographic analysis showed that women had an earlier mean age of onset, higher educational attainment, and fewer unhealthy lifestyle factors compared with men. Women were also more likely to have comorbid migraine (28.28% vs. 15.90%, P &lt; 0.001) and psychological conditions such as anxiety and depression, and to use oral rizatriptan for acute treatment (27.78% vs. 15.80%, P &lt; 0.001). With respect to cranial autonomic symptoms (CASs), women experienced eyelid edema (18.85% vs. 12.47%, P = 0.010) and ptosis (56.97% vs. 49.90%, P = 0.048) more frequently, and reported migraine-associated symptoms more often. Conversely, men more commonly presented with conjunctival hyperemia (56.03% vs. 38.52%, P &lt; 0.001), rhinorrhea (47.92% vs. 38.93%, P = 0.012), and facial sweating (38.15% vs. 30.74%, P = 0.032). Women had significantly higher frequencies of attacks during the early morning hours (2:00–8:00), whereas men experienced significantly more attacks during midday (10:00–14:00) and evening (16:00–20:00). <bold>Conclusion</bold> This study provides the first comprehensive analysis of multidimensional sex differences in Chinese patients with CH, encompassing social characteristics, clinical phenotypes, psychological burden, and circadian attack distribution. These findings offer valuable evidence for developing precision medicine approaches and sex-specific clinical management strategies for CH.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2025sex,
  author = {Yuhan Wu and Chun-Fu Chen and Sui-yi Xu and Hongru Zhao and Xingkai An and Kaiming Liu and Wensheng Qu and Hongling Zhao and Ran Zhang and Dan Wang and Zhiliang Fan and Yuanrong Yao and Zhibin Zhou and Huifang Xu and Wei Gui and Yabin Ji and Ling Chen and Jianjun Chen and Bing Wen and Zheman Xiao and Hebo Wang and Liang Zhang and Qiuling Tong and Xiaosu Yang and Zhonglin Liu and Songjie Liao and Ziru Li and Kunlin Zhang and Lin Ma and Shuhua Zhang and Shengyuan Yu and Mingjie Zhang and Zhao Dong},
  title = {{Sex Differences in Cluster Headache: Insights from the Chinese Cluster Headache Register Individual Study (CHRIS)}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-8245699/v1},
}
Figure