Seven-day COVID-19 quarantine may be too short: assessing post-quarantine transmission risk in four university cohorts

Andrew Bo Liu, Dan Davidi, Hannah E. Landsberg, Maria Francesconi, Judy Platt, Giang T. Nguyen, Sehyo Yune, Anastasia Deckard, Jamie Puglin, Steven B. Haase, Davidson H. Hamer, Michael SpringermedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Despite rising rates of vaccination, quarantine remains critical to control SARS-CoV-2 transmission. This cohort study assessed post-quarantine transmission risk for various quarantine lengths across four US universities from September 2020 to February 2021. Of 418 individuals who converted to positive, 11% were negative and asymptomatic on day 7. This significantly exceeds the 2.3–8.6% risk estimate used by the CDC to justify a 7-day quarantine. Notably, risk varied by quarantine strictness: 6% in strict vs. 14% in non-strict settings. To maintain a 5% risk threshold, the data suggests extending non-strict quarantine to 10 days.

Introduction

Quarantine is a cornerstone of public health, yet its duration is a subject of constant debate. Longer periods ensure higher safety but lead to economic hardship and "quarantine fatigue." In late 2020, the US CDC reduced the recommended quarantine from 14 to 7 days (with a negative test), based primarily on mathematical models of the virus's latent period. This study provides a real-world "reality check" of those models using high-resolution testing data from university environments.

Methods and Datasets

The researchers tracked 3,641 students and staff identified as close contacts at Boston University, Duke, Harvard, and Northeastern. Participants were tested via RT-qPCR approximately twice per week, allowing for precise mapping of when an individual "converted" from negative to positive.

Conversion time intervals for 418 individuals who tested positive during quarantine. The inset shows the daily percentage of conversions following exposure.

The study distinguished between two primary settings:

  • Strict Quarantine: Designated university housing with a private room, private bathroom, and meal delivery.
  • Non-Strict Quarantine: Staying in a home or apartment where household re-exposure was possible.

Key Results

The empirical data revealed a higher-than-expected risk of "leaked" cases after a 7-day window. While models predicted a risk below 9%, this study found that 11% of those who eventually tested positive were still negative and asymptomatic on day 7.

Percentage of individuals converting to positive after a given day, comparing strict (blue) and non-strict (red) quarantine settings.

The strictness of the quarantine environment was a major factor. In strict isolation, the risk of testing positive after day 7 was 6%. In non-strict settings, this rose to 14%, likely due to "serial exposure" from household members. By day 10, the overall risk dropped to 4.2%, and by day 14, it was only 1.2%.

Discussion and Recommendations

The findings suggest that the CDC’s 7-day guidance may be insufficient for the general population, where non-strict quarantine is the norm. To achieve the CDC's own target of a 5% post-quarantine transmission risk, the authors recommend:

  1. Strict Quarantine: A 7-day period with qPCR testing is sufficient.
  2. Non-Strict Quarantine: A 10-day period with qPCR testing is required.

Limitations include the study's focus on pre-Delta/Omicron variants and a demographic of primarily young, healthy individuals. Furthermore, the use of less sensitive antigen tests for "testing out" would likely necessitate even longer durations to account for detection delays.

Conclusion

Empirical data indicates that a 7-day quarantine period carries a higher transmission risk than previously estimated. Public health guidelines should account for the reality of household re-exposure by extending quarantine to 10 days in non-strict settings to maintain safety targets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Despite rising rates of vaccination, quarantine remains critical to control SARS-CoV-2 transmission. COVID-19 quarantine length around the world varies in part due to the limited amount of empirical data. Objective To assess post-quarantine transmission risk for various quarantine lengths. Design Cohort study. Setting Four US universities, September 2020 to February 2021. Participants 3,641 students and staff were identified as close contacts to SARS-CoV-2-positive individuals. They entered strict or non-strict quarantine and were tested on average twice per week for SARS-CoV-2. Strict quarantine included designated housing with a private room, private bathroom and meal delivery. Non-strict quarantine potentially included interactions with household members. Measurements Dates of exposure and last negative and first positive tests during quarantine. Results Of the 418 quarantined individuals who eventually converted to positive, 11%, 4.2%, and 1.2% were negative and asymptomatic on days 7, 10 and 14, respectively. The US CDC recently shortened its quarantine guidance from 14 to 7 days based on estimates of 2.3-8.6% post-quarantine transmission risk at day 7, significantly below the 11% risk we report here. Notably, 6% of individuals tested positive after day 7 in strict quarantine, versus 14% in non-strict quarantine. Ongoing exposure during quarantine likely explains the higher rate of COVID-19 in non-strict quarantine. Limitations Quarantine should be longer for individuals using antigen testing, given antigen testing’s lower sensitivity than qPCR. Results apply in settings in which SAR-CoV-2 variants do not affect latent period. Conclusions To maintain the 5% transmission risk that the CDC used in its guidance, our data suggest that quarantine with qPCR testing 1 day before intended release should extend to 10 days for non-strict quarantine. Funding Source None.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2021seven,
  author = {Andrew Bo Liu and Dan Davidi and Hannah E. Landsberg and Maria Francesconi and Judy Platt and Giang T. Nguyen and Sehyo Yune and Anastasia Deckard and Jamie Puglin and Steven B. Haase and Davidson H. Hamer and Michael Springer},
  title = {{Seven-day COVID-19 quarantine may be too short: assessing post-quarantine transmission risk in four university cohorts}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.05.12.21257117},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure