Sequential Contrastive Learning to Master Effective Representations For Reinforcement Learning and Control

Ali Younes, Aleksandr PanovOpenReview 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel self-supervised learning framework that learns effective state representations from raw RGB video data for robotics control. By employing sequential contrastive learning and a new pixel-wise contrastive loss, the method generates both a compact latent space embedding and task-specific object descriptors, eliminating the need for manual reward engineering and enabling faster learning in low-resource scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

State estimation is crucial for optimal control and reinforcement learning (RL) systems, as it provides the current state of the environment. Traditionally, this involves complex sensor setups or engineered features. While representation learning has shown promise in automatically learning state representations from visual data, existing methods often require extensive labeled data, struggle with real-world variability, or produce representations that are not directly usable for control (e.g., not interpretable for cost/reward calculation). This paper addresses the challenge of learning robust, interpretable state representations from minimal, unlabeled RGB video data, specifically for robotics manipulation tasks, to facilitate model-based RL and optimal control.

Methods

The proposed framework consists of two main components trained sequentially: an embedding model and a descriptor model.

  • Embedding Model: This model takes an augmented RGB image as input and outputs a low-dimensional embedding in a latent space. It utilizes a pre-trained Inception network (frozen) followed by convolutional layers and a spatial softmax layer to extract spatial features. A fully connected layer then produces the final embedding. The key innovation here is the use of a sequential time contrastive loss (STCL). This loss encourages similar temporal states in the video to be closer in the latent space than dissimilar ones. Crucially, the margins for this loss are scheduled and updated during training, allowing the model to first learn to disentangle near embeddings and then separate them further, mimicking the progression of a task.
  • Descriptor Model: This model takes the spatial features from the embedding model and outputs a descriptor image. It uses transposed convolutional layers and bilinear interpolation. The novelty lies in the sequential pixel-wise contrastive loss (SPCL). This loss operates on the descriptor images, enforcing that corresponding pixels (or features) from similar temporal states are closer than those from dissimilar states. Similar to STCL, the margins for SPCL are also scheduled, allowing for fine-grained discrimination of task-related objects.

The training process is sequential: first, the embedding model is trained using STCL, and then the descriptor model is trained using SPCL, leveraging the learned spatial features.

Datasets

The authors used three videos of a USB insertion task for training. These videos were collected using a smartphone and represent a low-resource scenario. They also used a different USB flash for evaluation to test the model's generalization. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the focus was on demonstrating the framework's effectiveness with minimal, real-world data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scheduled Margins are Key: The core idea of "sequential" learning is the dynamic adjustment of contrastive loss margins. This allows the model to progressively learn more refined representations, first focusing on broad distinctions and then on finer details, which is crucial for complex tasks.
  • Bridging Representation Learning and Control: The framework aims to produce representations that are directly usable for control. The latent space embedding can be used for state estimation, and the learned descriptors can potentially inform reward functions or object manipulation strategies, reducing reliance on engineered solutions.
  • Self-Supervised from Raw Video: The ability to learn from unlabeled RGB videos is a significant advantage, as it drastically reduces the data annotation burden for robotics tasks.
  • Low-Resource Viability: The framework's effectiveness with a single GPU and minimal training data (around one hour) makes it highly practical for real-world robotics applications where data collection can be expensive and time-consuming.

Key Results

  • Improved Latent Space Distribution: Figure 4 demonstrates that sequential learning leads to a more organized and clustered latent space compared to no training or only time-contrastive training. This improved distribution results in a smoother and monotonically increasing reward function, which is desirable for RL and control.
  • Distinguishable Object Descriptors: Figure 5 shows that the descriptor model can learn to highlight task-related objects, even when the input images are augmented (e.g., color changes). This indicates robustness and the ability to focus on relevant visual cues.
  • Reduced Training Time: The paper highlights that the training time for a task is relatively short (around one hour), making the framework efficient.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Descriptor Interpretation: While the descriptor images show promise in distinguishing objects, the paper acknowledges that additional processing is needed to directly extract a reward from them. This is identified as future work.
  • Integration with Control: The framework is presented as a representation learning method. Its direct integration and performance evaluation within a full model-based RL or optimal control loop are areas for further exploration.
  • Generalization to More Complex Tasks: While demonstrated on a pick-and-place-like task (USB insertion), extending the framework to more dynamic or complex manipulation scenarios would be valuable.
  • Hardware Requirements: While low-resource in terms of data and GPU, the paper mentions using a single NVIDIA GTX 1050Ti, suggesting that while accessible, more powerful hardware could further speed up training.

Summary updated

Abstract

State estimation is an essential part of any control system. A perception system estimates a representation of the states using sensor data. Recently, an increasing interest in exploiting machine learning techniques to learn state representation. Representation learning allows estimating states in real-world scenarios. We are interested in learning representation from RGB images extracted from videos. And use the state representation to compute cost/reward suitable for control and reinforcement learning. We propose a method in which the user has to provide just a couple of videos demonstrating the task. Our approach uses a sequential contrastive loss to learn latent space mapping and descriptors of task-related objects. Our framework serves robotics control scenarios, especially model-based reinforcement learning algorithms. The resulting representation eliminates the need for engineered reward functions or any explicit access to positioning systems, aiming to improve the applicability of learning to control physical systems. Our framework allows for reducing the learning time and working with low-resource scenarios.
BibTeX
@misc{younes2023sequential,
  author = {Ali Younes and Aleksandr Panov},
  title = {{Sequential Contrastive Learning to Master Effective Representations For Reinforcement Learning and Control}},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=-WD5FOVeAx},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}

Loading related content...

Figure