Sequencing and Analysis of Complete Chloroplast Genomes Provide Insight into the Evolution and Phylogeny of Chinese Kale (Brassica oleracea var. alboglabra)

Yilin Wang, Qiannan Liang, Chenlu Zhang, Huanhuan Huang, Hao He, Mengyu Wang, Mengyao Li, Zhi Huang, Yi Tang, Qing Chen, Huiying Miao, Huanxiu Li, Fen Zhang, Qiaomei Wang, Bo SunInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study sequenced and analyzed the complete chloroplast genomes of white and yellow-flowered Chinese kale varieties. The findings strongly suggest that Chinese kale is a variant of Brassica oleracea, with its distinct flower colors likely arising from recent artificial cultivation rather than deep evolutionary divergence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolutionary origin and taxonomic status of Chinese kale (Brassica oleracea var. alboglabra) have been a subject of ongoing research. While Brassica oleracea is known to originate from the Mediterranean region, Chinese kale is believed to have originated in southern China. However, the precise relationship between Chinese kale and other Brassica species, particularly its parent species, remains somewhat unclear. This paper aims to clarify this by leveraging the highly conserved nature of chloroplast genomes, which are excellent tools for phylogenetic analysis, to investigate the evolutionary history and relationships of Chinese kale within the Brassicaceae family.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the chloroplast genomes:

  • Genome Sequencing and Assembly: DNA was extracted from fresh leaves of white-flower (SJCT) and yellow-flower (FZHH) Chinese kale. Universal primers were used for PCR amplification of the chloroplast genomes, followed by sequencing on an Illumina HiSeq platform. The resulting reads were assembled using SPAdes and Pilon for error correction.
  • Genome Annotation: The assembled chloroplast genomes were annotated to identify genes and their functions using the CPGAVAS tool.
  • Comparative Genomics: The newly sequenced genomes were compared with eight other Brassicaceae species. This involved analyzing:
  • Repeats: Identification of simple sequence repeats (SSRs) and long repeats (forward, reverse complement, and reverse) to understand genome structure and potential for variation.
  • Relative Synonymous Codon Usage (RSCU): Analysis of codon usage patterns to infer selective pressures and evolutionary trends.
  • Inverted Repeat (IR) Boundaries and Synteny: Examination of the structure and potential rearrangements within the chloroplast genome, particularly at the LSC/IR and SSC/IR junctions.
  • Nucleotide Variability (Pi): Calculation of sequence divergence to identify potential DNA barcoding regions.
  • Ka/Ks Ratios: Assessment of the ratio of non-synonymous to synonymous substitutions to infer selective pressures on protein-coding genes.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Phylogenetic trees were constructed using both nucleotide and protein sequences from the chloroplast genomes of Chinese kale and related Brassicaceae species. This was done using maximum likelihood (ML) methods with IQ-tree.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Newly Sequenced Genomes: Complete chloroplast genomes of two Chinese kale varieties: Brassica oleracea var. alboglabra cv. Sijicutiao (SJCT) and Brassica oleracea var. alboglabra cv. Fuzhouhuanghua (FZHH).
  • Publicly Available Genomes: Chloroplast genomes of eight other Brassicaceae species, including Brassica oleracea var. oleracea, B. rapa, B. napus, B. juncea, B. nigra, B. carinata, Sinapis alba, and S. arvensis.
  • Outgroup Species: Three chloroplast genome sequences were used as outgroups for phylogenetic analysis (specific species not detailed in the abstract but implied in the methods).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chinese Kale as a B. oleracea Variant: The most significant insight is the strong phylogenetic evidence placing Chinese kale as a direct variant of Brassica oleracea, rather than a distinct species or a distant relative.
  • Late Divergence of Flower Color: The study suggests that the differences in flower color between white and yellow Chinese kale are a relatively recent development, likely driven by artificial selection during cultivation, rather than reflecting deep evolutionary splits.
  • Conserved Chloroplast Genome Structure: Despite variations in flower color and some minor genetic differences, the overall structure and gene content of the chloroplast genomes across the studied Brassicaceae species are highly conserved, reinforcing their utility for phylogenetic studies.
  • Potential DNA Barcoding Regions: The identification of highly variable regions within the chloroplast genomes, such as matK-rps16, rpl32-trnL, and psbA, highlights their potential as DNA barcodes for species identification within Brassicaceae.

Key Results

  • Genome Size and Gene Content: The complete chloroplast genomes of SJCT and FZHH were sequenced, measuring 153,365 bp and 153,420 bp, respectively. Both contained 88 protein-coding genes, 8 rRNA genes, and a typical quadripartite structure (LSC, SSC, and two IR regions). A minor difference was noted in tRNA genes, with SJCT having 36 and FZHH having 35, due to the loss of the trnD gene in FZHH.
  • Repeat Analysis: A total of 148–162 SSRs were identified across the 10 chloroplast genomes, with Chinese kale varieties having a high number of SSRs.
  • Phylogenetic Clustering: Phylogenetic trees consistently clustered the two Chinese kale varieties together with B. oleracea var. oleracea, forming a monophyletic group.
  • Ka/Ks Ratios: Analysis of Ka/Ks ratios indicated weak selection for some genes in Chinese kale and B. oleracea var. oleracea, while positive selection was observed for certain genes in other Brassica species, suggesting differential evolutionary pressures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited B. oleracea var. oleracea Data: While the study includes B. oleracea var. oleracea, the abstract implies that the comparison might be limited by the available data for this specific variety.
  • Inferred Origin: The conclusion that Chinese kale originated in southern China is based on existing knowledge and the phylogenetic results, but direct evidence of this origin within the chloroplast genome analysis itself is not explicitly detailed.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that their findings provide valuable data for future research on the genetics, evolution, and germplasm resources of Brassicaceae. Further studies could explore the nuclear genome to complement these chloroplast findings and delve deeper into the specific genetic mechanisms behind flower color variation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chinese kale is a widely cultivated plant in the genus <i>Brassica</i> in the family Brassicaceae. The origin of <i>Brassica</i> has been studied extensively, but the origin of Chinese kale remains unclear. In contrast to <i>Brassica oleracea</i>, which originated in the Mediterranean region, Chinese kale originated in southern China. The chloroplast genome is often used for phylogenetic analysis because of its high conservatism. Fifteen pairs of universal primers were used to amplify the chloroplast genomes of white-flower Chinese kale (<i>Brassica oleracea</i> var. <i>alboglabra</i> cv. Sijicutiao (SJCT)) and yellow-flower Chinese kale (<i>Brassica oleracea</i> var. <i>alboglabra</i> cv. Fuzhouhuanghua (FZHH)) via PCR. The lengths of the chloroplast genomes were 153,365 bp (SJCT) and 153,420 bp (FZHH) and both contained 87 protein-coding genes and eight rRNA genes. There were 36 tRNA genes in SJCT and 35 tRNA genes in FZHH. The chloroplast genomes of both Chinese kale varieties, along with eight other Brassicaceae, were analyzed. Simple sequence repeats, long repeats, and variable regions of DNA barcodes were identified. An analysis of inverted repeat boundaries, relative synonymous codon usage, and synteny revealed high similarity among the ten species, albeit the slight differences that were observed. The Ka/Ks ratios and phylogenetic analysis suggest that Chinese kale is a variant of <i>B. oleracea</i>. The phylogenetic tree shows that both Chinese kale varieties and <i>B. oleracea</i> var. <i>oleracea</i> were clustered in a single group. The results of this study suggest that white and yellow flower Chinese kale comprise a monophyletic group and that their differences in flower color arose late in the process of artificial cultivation. Our results also provide data that will aid future research on genetics, evolution, and germplasm resources of Brassicaceae.
BibTeX
@article{wang2023sequencing,
  author = {Yilin Wang and Qiannan Liang and Chenlu Zhang and Huanhuan Huang and Hao He and Mengyu Wang and Mengyao Li and Zhi Huang and Yi Tang and Qing Chen and Huiying Miao and Huanxiu Li and Fen Zhang and Qiaomei Wang and Bo Sun},
  title = {{Sequencing and Analysis of Complete Chloroplast Genomes Provide Insight into the Evolution and Phylogeny of Chinese Kale (Brassica oleracea var. alboglabra)}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms241210287},
}
Figure