Sensory quality of soymilk and tofu from soybeans lacking lipoxygenases

Aijun Yang, Heather E. Smyth, Mridusmita Chaliha, Andrew T. JamesFood 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how removing lipoxygenase enzymes from soybeans impacts the sensory quality of soymilk and tofu. They found that soybeans lacking these enzymes produce soy foods with significantly reduced undesirable "beany" or "grassy" flavors and aromas, making them potentially more appealing to consumers, especially those less accustomed to traditional soy products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soy-based foods like soymilk and tofu are nutritious and increasingly popular, but their widespread adoption, particularly in Western markets, is often hindered by a characteristic "grassy" or "beany" flavor. This undesirable taste is primarily attributed to the oxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) in soybeans, a process catalyzed by enzymes called lipoxygenases (LOX). Soybeans naturally contain three major LOX isozymes (LOX-1, LOX-2, and LOX-3). While breeding efforts have produced soybean lines with reduced or absent LOX activity, the impact of these "LOX-free" varieties on the sensory quality of common soy foods like soymilk and tofu, and how these differences are perceived across different cultural backgrounds, has not been fully elucidated. This paper aims to bridge that gap by evaluating the sensory attributes of soymilk and tofu made from soybeans with varying LOX profiles, using both traditional and non-traditional soy consumer groups.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Soybean Characterization: They analyzed the seed characteristics of control soybeans and those genetically modified to lack LOX-1 and LOX-2 (Lx12) or all three LOX isozymes (Lx123). This included measuring seed weight, oil and protein content, and fatty acid composition.
  • Soy Food Production: Soymilk and silken tofu were produced using optimized traditional methods from the different soybean types.
  • Sensory Evaluation - Focus Groups: Two distinct consumer groups were used: "traditional soy users" (primarily Chinese panel) and "nontraditional soy users" (Anglo-Australian panel). These groups participated in semi-formal focus groups where they described and rated the appearance, aroma, texture, mouthfeel, flavor, and aftertaste of soymilk and tofu made from control and LOX-free soybeans. They also provided overall acceptability ratings.
  • Sensory Evaluation - Trained Panel: A trained descriptive taste panel evaluated soymilk and tofu from control, Lx12, and Lx123 soybeans. They used a defined vocabulary to quantify specific sensory attributes like aroma intensity, bitterness, sweetness, and grassy/rancid notes.
  • Instrumental Analysis (GC-MS): Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) was used to identify and quantify volatile compounds in soymilk and tofu. This helped to correlate instrumental findings with sensory perceptions, particularly focusing on hexanal, a key compound associated with undesirable flavors.

Datasets

Not applicable. This study generated its own data through sensory evaluations and instrumental analysis of soy products derived from specific soybean lines. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LOX Removal Significantly Reduces Undesirable Aromas: The most striking finding is that soybeans lacking lipoxygenases consistently produce soymilk and tofu with lower levels of "rancid/grassy" odors and flavors. This effect was more pronounced in soybeans lacking all three LOX isozymes (Lx123).
  • Cultural Preferences Matter, But Improvement is Universal: While traditional soy users showed a preference for control soymilk (associating the "beany" flavor with authenticity) and LOX-free tofu, non-traditional users clearly preferred the LOX-free soymilk. This highlights how LOX-free soybeans can cater to a broader consumer base.
  • Positive Sensory Attributes are Enhanced: Beyond reducing negative notes, LOX-free soy products were perceived as sweeter and less bitter, suggesting a more balanced flavor profile.
  • Hexanal as a Key Indicator: Instrumental analysis confirmed lower levels of hexanal, a major volatile compound linked to off-flavors, in LOX-free soy products, directly correlating with sensory panel observations.
  • Additive Effect of LOX Removal: The study suggests that removing multiple LOX isozymes (Lx123) has an additive effect in reducing negative sensory attributes compared to removing just one or two.

Key Results

  • Sensory Panel: A trained panel rated the rancid/grassy odor significantly lower in Lx123 and Lx12 products compared to controls. Bitterness was also significantly lower in LOX-free products. Sweetness was rated significantly higher in Lx12 and Lx123 products.
  • Consumer Panels: Traditional users preferred control soymilk and LOX-free tofu. Nontraditional users preferred LOX-free soymilk and showed no preference for tofu.
  • GC-MS: Volatile analysis showed significantly higher levels of hexanal, 1-hexanol, and butanol in control soymilk and tofu compared to LOX-free counterparts. The difference in hexanal increased with storage time.
  • Seed Characteristics: While oil content was similar, Lx12 seeds were smaller and contained more protein than controls. Fatty acid profiles were largely comparable across the soybean types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cultural Nuance: While the study differentiated between traditional and nontraditional users, the authors acknowledge that preferences can be complex and influenced by more than just cultural background. The "typical" Chinese preference for control soymilk might stem from a learned association rather than an inherent preference for the "beany" flavor itself.
  • Product Specificity: The study focused on soymilk and silken tofu. The authors note that LOX-free soybeans have shown mixed results in other food products (e.g., oils, breads, meat patties), suggesting that the impact of LOX removal is product-dependent.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that LOX-free soybean varieties hold significant potential for the Australian food industry, offering ingredients that could broaden the utilization of soybeans and soy proteins in a wider range of food applications, particularly for consumers seeking milder flavors. Further research could explore the application of these LOX-free soybeans in a wider array of processed foods and investigate long-term consumer acceptance studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The oxidation of unsaturated lipids by lipoxygenases in soybeans causes undesirable flavors in soy foods. Using a traditional and a nontraditional soy food user group, we examined the cultural difference in perceiving the sensory characteristics of soymilk and tofu produced from soybeans with or without lipoxygenases (Lx123). The two groups described the samples using similar terms. The traditional users preferred the control soy milk and lipoxygenase-free tofu while the nontraditional users preferred the lipoxygenase-free soymilk with no preference for tofu. In a separate study, a trained descriptive taste panel compared the odor of soymilk and tofu from control soybeans or those lacking lipoxygenase-1 and lipoxygenase-2 (Lx12) or all three isomers (Lx123). The rancid/grassy odor was rated the lowest in Lx123 products, followed by Lx12 products with the control products given the highest rating. The Lx12 and Lx123 products were also sweeter and less bitter than the controls. Taken together, our results demonstrated that soybeans lacking lipoxygenases can produce soy foods with less undesirable aromas and are therefore likely more acceptable to the consumers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2015sensory,
  author = {Aijun Yang and Heather E. Smyth and Mridusmita Chaliha and Andrew T. James},
  title = {{Sensory quality of soymilk and tofu from soybeans lacking lipoxygenases}},
  booktitle = {Food},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1002/fsn3.274},
}
Figure