Sensorless Control Strategy for Interior Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors in the Full-Speed Section

Jianping Wang, Jian Ma, Xuan Zhao, Dean Meng, Kejie Xu, Dianxiang GuoEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel sensorless control strategy for Interior Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (IPMSMs) that operates reliably across the entire speed range, crucial for electric vehicles. It combines high-frequency signal injection for low speeds with an improved Sliding Mode Observer (SMO) for higher speeds, seamlessly transitioning between them using linear weighting. This approach enhances robustness and accuracy, mitigating the risks associated with position sensor failures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electric vehicles (EVs) increasingly rely on Interior Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (IPMSMs) due to their high power density and controllability. These motors typically require position sensors for precise closed-loop control. However, in the demanding and complex operating environments of EVs, position sensors are prone to failure, which can severely compromise the motor system's stability and performance. Existing sensorless control methods often struggle to maintain accuracy and robustness across the entire speed spectrum of an EV, particularly during transitions between low and high speeds. This paper tackles the challenge of achieving reliable, fault-tolerant sensorless control for IPMSMs across all operating speeds, addressing the critical need for robustness against position sensor failures.

Methods

The proposed solution employs a composite sensorless control strategy that leverages two distinct techniques tailored to different speed ranges:

  • Low-Speed Operation (High-Frequency Signal Injection): For low speeds, where back electromotive force (back-EMF) is weak, the paper utilizes pulse high-frequency voltage injection. This method injects a high-frequency signal into the motor windings and analyzes the resulting current to estimate the rotor position based on the motor's saliency.
  • Medium-to-High-Speed Operation (Improved Sliding Mode Observer - SMO): At higher speeds, the back-EMF becomes significant, making high-frequency injection less effective due to signal interference. Here, the paper employs a Sliding Mode Observer (SMO). A key innovation is the improved SMO, which replaces the traditional saturation function with a segmented composite function. This modification aims to enhance robustness and reduce the chattering phenomenon often associated with traditional SMOs, leading to smoother signal estimation.
  • Transition Management (Linear Weighting): To ensure a smooth transition between the low-speed and medium-high-speed control strategies, a linear weighting method is introduced. This approach dynamically adjusts the contribution of each method based on the motor's rotational speed, ensuring minimal error and smooth operation during speed changes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on simulation and experimental verification using a specific IPMSM motor model and a Speedgoat-based rapid control prototyping platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Composite Control for Full-Speed Range: The core insight is that a single sensorless control technique is insufficient for the entire speed range of an EV. Combining specialized methods (high-frequency injection for low speed, SMO for high speed) with a robust transition mechanism is essential for comprehensive performance.
  • Improved SMO for Robustness: The introduction of a segmented composite function in the SMO significantly reduces jitter and improves the smoothness of rotor position estimation compared to traditional SMOs. This is crucial for maintaining stable operation and reducing wear.
  • Linear Weighting for Smooth Transitions: The linear weighting approach effectively bridges the gap between different control strategies, preventing abrupt changes and ensuring continuous, stable operation during speed variations. This is vital for driver comfort and system efficiency.
  • Experimental Validation on a Real-Time Platform: The use of a Speedgoat-based rapid control prototyping platform provides strong evidence for the practical applicability and effectiveness of the proposed sensorless control strategy in a realistic EV drive scenario.

Key Results

  • Low-Speed Performance: The high-frequency signal injection method achieved a steady-state speed error of approximately 0.2 r/min and a position error of about 0.07 rad.
  • Medium-to-High-Speed Performance (Improved SMO): The improved SMO demonstrated a reduced steady-state speed error of about 0.1 r/min and a position error of approximately 0.015 rad, significantly outperforming the traditional SMO's 0.05 rad error.
  • Transition Smoothness: The linear weighting method ensured relatively smooth switching between control algorithms, with small errors in the transition interval.
  • Experimental Verification: The experimental results confirmed that the proposed sensorless control strategy can effectively track speed and rotor position across low, medium, and high speeds. Steady-state speed estimation errors were below 3% at low speeds and below 1% at medium to high speeds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Constant Load Assumption: The simulations and experiments were conducted under constant load conditions. The authors acknowledge that load variations can significantly impact rotor position estimation.
  • Future Work:
    • Investigate the effects of varying load gradients on rotor position estimation.
  • Enhance the adaptability of the control algorithm to complex operating conditions of drive motors.
  • Refine the weighted switching strategy to further improve the smoothness of control strategy transitions.
  • Conduct experiments with varying load gradients to further validate the robustness and adaptability of the proposed sensorless control strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Along with the advancement of modern control technology, electric vehicles have gradually become the leading force in the development of the automobile industry. Interior permanent magnet synchronous motors (IPMSMs) have gradually become a mainstream electric vehicle drive component due to their high power density and excellent controllability. This type of motor can form a high-precision closed-loop control system with position sensors, which improves the overall performance. However, the operating conditions are complicated, and position sensor failure can easily occur, which reduces the stability of the motor system. For the fault-tolerant control problem of position sensor failure, pulse high-frequency voltage injection and an improved sliding mode observer (SMO) are employed to achieve the sensorless control of both the low-speed and medium-high-speed sections of the electric motor. Combining the advantages of high-frequency voltage injection in the low-speed section with a high accuracy of position estimation and the advantages of improved SMO in the high-speed section with low computational volume, the composite sensorless control strategy is proposed for IPMSM in the full-speed section. Secondly, an improved SMO using a segmented composite function as the control function is proposed to improve the robustness of the system. It is proposed to address the issue of the smooth transition between the low-speed section and the medium- and high-speed section by using linear weighting. Finally, in order to validate the accuracy of the sensorless control technology, a rapid control prototype of IPMSMs based on Speedgoat is constructed by using a semi-physical simulation system. The efficacy of the control algorithms in the low-speed section, high-speed section and transition interval is verified.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023sensorless,
  author = {Jianping Wang and Jian Ma and Xuan Zhao and Dean Meng and Kejie Xu and Dianxiang Guo},
  title = {{Sensorless Control Strategy for Interior Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors in the Full-Speed Section}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16237701},
}
Figure