Sensitivity of the Tibet hybrid experiment (Tibet-III + MD) for primary proton spectra between 30 TeV and a few hundreds of TeV’s

D. Kurashige, Ding Chen, N. Hotta, J. Huang, Y. Katayose, K. Kawata, M. Ohnishi, Toshiharu Saito, T. Sako, M. Shibata, Masato TakitaProceedings of 37th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2021) 2021 · DOI

Abstract

We are observing extensive air showers using the Tibet-III air shower array located at 4300 m above sea level. This high altitude enables the measurement of cosmic ray chemical composition above several tens of TeV by analyzing shower profiles. A water-Cherenkov Muon Detector array (MD) was added in 2014 to measure muon intensity, improving particle identification. We developed a method to select proton air shower events between 30 TeV and 400 TeV based on the muon count deficit in MD. Sensitivity was investigated via Monte Carlo simulations using various composition and interaction models. Protons were selected with 90% purity. Total systematic errors were found to be less than ±36%, sufficient for studying the shape of proton spectra.

Introduction

The origin and acceleration mechanisms of high-energy cosmic rays, primarily protons, remain central questions in astrophysics. A critical feature is the "knee" of the cosmic ray spectrum at approximately $10^{15}$ eV, where the flux decreases sharply. Understanding this requires precise measurements of individual elemental spectra. However, a "data gap" exists between 100 TeV and several PeV: direct measurements via balloons or satellites lack the necessary collection area, while ground-based arrays often struggle to distinguish protons from heavier nuclei. This study addresses this gap by refining a proton selection method for the 30–400 TeV range.

Methodology: The Hybrid Detector and Muon Counting

The research utilizes the Tibet AS$\gamma$ experiment, situated at 4,300 meters above sea level. The setup is a hybrid system consisting of the Tibet-III surface scintillation array and an underground water-Cherenkov Muon Detector (MD) array. The primary innovation lies in the muon-counting selection technique. At a given energy, heavier nuclei (e.g., Helium or Iron) produce significantly more muons in atmospheric air showers than primary protons.

Scatter plot of the number of muons ($N_\mu$) versus the sum of particle densities ($\Sigma \rho$) for proton events (red) and other nuclei (grey), illustrating the separation achieved through muon counting.

By analyzing the relationship between the total charged particle density ($\Sigma \rho$) and the number of detected muons ($N_\mu$), researchers can effectively isolate proton candidates. Extensive Monte Carlo simulations using CORSIKA with SIBYLL and QGSJET interaction models were employed to calibrate these selection criteria.

Key Results and Performance

The study demonstrates that protons can be isolated with a high purity of 90% across the 30–400 TeV energy range. While the selection efficiency is relatively low—ranging from 17.8% at 30 TeV to 8.6% at 400 TeV—the high purity is essential for accurately determining the spectral index without contamination from heavier elements.

Distribution of the number of muons ($N_\mu$) for protons (red) and other nuclei (blue) in the energy range $10^{2.6} \le \Sigma \rho < 10^{2.8}$, showing the clear separation between the two populations.

Energy resolution was found to improve with increasing energy, from 53% at 30 TeV to 27% at 400 TeV. The total systematic error, accounting for variations in hadronic interaction and primary composition models, is estimated at ±36%. This level of precision is deemed sufficient to resolve the shape of the primary proton spectrum in this critical transition region.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The Tibet-III + MD hybrid array provides a robust platform for bridging the gap between direct and indirect cosmic ray measurements. By achieving 90% proton purity, this method allows for a detailed investigation of the proton spectrum approaching the "knee." Future work will involve applying this validated selection technique to multi-year experimental data from the Tibet AS$\gamma$ array, potentially identifying the sources of galactic "PeVatrons."

Summary updated

Abstract

We are observing extensive air showers using Tibet-III air shower array located at 4300 m above sea level. Such situation at high altitude enables us to measure the chemical composition of cosmic rays above several tens TeV by analyzing the shower profiles. A water-Cherenkov Muon Detector array (MD) was added in 2014 to measure the muon intensity of air showers and performance of particle identification was improved. We have developed a method to select proton air shower events with the energy between 30 TeV and 400 TeV by the difference of number of muons in the air shower using MD. The sensitivity of the detector for primary proton spectra was investigated by Monte Carlo simulation with both primary composition models and the interaction models. Using the number of muons measured by the MD, it was found that the protons could be selected with 90% purity. The systematic errors between these models were summarized as less than ±36% in total, indicating that the accuracy is sufficient to study the shape of the proton spectra.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kurashige2021sensitivity,
  author = {D. Kurashige and Ding Chen and N. Hotta and J. Huang and Y. Katayose and K. Kawata and M. Ohnishi and Toshiharu Saito and T. Sako and M. Shibata and Masato Takita},
  title = {{Sensitivity of the Tibet hybrid experiment (Tibet-III + MD) for primary proton spectra between 30 TeV and a few hundreds of TeV’s}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of 37th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2021)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.22323/1.395.0205},
}
Figure