Sensitivity analysis of operation parameters of the salt cavern under long-term gas injection-production

Huabin Zhang, Peng Wang, Qiqi Wanyan, Kang Li, Kai Gao, Xianru YueScientific 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Injection-production operation parameters—including minimum injection gas pressure (IGP), IGP interval, minimum IGP residence time, and cycle frequency—significantly impact the capacity and structural integrity of underground salt rock gas storage. This study utilizes a 3D geo-mechanical model to evaluate the long-term stability of salt caverns over a 30-year operational lifespan. By analyzing deformation, volume shrinkage, and plastic zone development, the research identifies the IGP interval as the most critical factor for cavern stability. These findings provide technical guidance for optimizing storage operations to ensure safety while meeting energy demands.

The Challenge of Underground Storage

As global energy systems transition, salt caverns have emerged as ideal vessels for natural gas storage. Salt rock possesses unique advantages: extremely low permeability, high plasticity, and a "self-healing" ability to close fractures. However, salt is also susceptible to creep—a slow, permanent deformation under constant stress.

Figure 3: Rising natural gas consumption and import dependence (2009–2019) highlights the urgent need for stable underground storage solutions.

Over decades of operation, improper pressure management can lead to excessive creep, causing cavern shrinkage, surrounding rock failure, or surface subsidence. Engineers must balance the need for high storage capacity with the mechanical limits of the surrounding rock.

Modeling and Operational Parameters

To address this, researchers established a 3D geo-mechanical model using FLAC3D software, simulating a layered salt rock storage site. The model incorporates the Norton Creep Law to predict steady-state deformation over time. The study focused on four primary operational "knobs":

  1. Minimum IGP: The lowest pressure maintained in the cavern.
  2. IGP Interval: The range between maximum and minimum operating pressures.
  3. Minimum IGP Residence Time: The duration the cavern stays at its lowest pressure.
  4. Injection-Production Cycle: The frequency of gas turnover per year.
Figure 2: Schematic of a salt cavern and the typical pressure-time profile of an injection-production cycle.

Stability was evaluated using a multi-index approach, tracking surrounding rock displacement, the dilatancy (expansion) safety factor, volume shrinkage rates, and the volume of the plastic zone (areas where rock reaches its yield point).

Key Insights and Sensitivity Analysis

The primary driver of instability is the "in-situ stress"—the weight of the earth pushing inward. Internal gas pressure acts as a structural brace. When gas is withdrawn and pressure drops, the earth's squeezing effect intensifies, accelerating creep.

The Sensitivity Hierarchy

Through single-factor sensitivity analysis, the researchers ranked the operational parameters by their impact on cavern health: IGP Interval > Minimum IGP > Minimum IGP Residence Time > Injection-Production Cycle.

  • Pressure is Critical: The IGP interval and Minimum IGP are the most influential. Higher average internal pressures better resist the surrounding earth's weight, significantly reducing displacement and volume loss.
  • The Danger of "Dwell Time": Staying at minimum pressure for extended periods (residence time) is detrimental. The longer a cavern remains at low pressure, the more time the salt has to creep inward, leading to permanent volume shrinkage.
  • Cyclical Fluctuations: Cavern displacement follows a "fluctuating upward trend." Displacement decreases during gas injection as the cavern is braced but surges during production phases.

Conclusion

The study confirms that while volume shrinkage typically remains within safe limits (below 20% over 30 years), aggressive low-pressure scenarios can lead to significant volume loss. To maximize the lifespan and safety of these facilities, operators should prioritize maintaining a stable IGP interval and minimizing the time the cavern spends at its lowest pressure. This research offers a vital reference for optimizing injection-production parameters in complex, layered salt formations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Injection-production operation parameters, the minimum injection gas pressure (IGP: operation pressure), IGP interval, minimum IGP residence time, and injection-production cycle of the underground salt rock gas storage under long-term operation, affect not only the capacity and working ability of a salt cavern but also be crucial to the safety and stability of the surrounding rock. A 3D geo-mechanical model of the salt cavern is established to study the stability of the storage in the operation period. The deformation, expansion safety factor, volume shrinkage, and plastic zone are comprehensively considered for predicting the feasibility and stability of the salt cavern. The stability of the surrounding rock of the cavern with different injection-production parameters and the impact of each parameter on the stability of the cavern during operating are systematically investigated. The results indicate that the displacement, the expansion coefficient of the surrounding rock, and the volume shrinkage rate of the salt cavern reduces significantly with the increment of IGP interval and minimum IGP, while they increases with raising the minimum IGP residence time and injection-production cycle. With the continuous operation of the cavity, the displacement and the volume shrinkage rate enhances significantly year by year with the augment of operation parameters, moreover, their value show a fluctuating upward trend with the alternation of the gas injection and the production. The volume of the plastic zone is enlarged with the increment of the IGP interval, minimum IGP, and injection-production cycle, while it reduces with the extension of the minimum IGP residence time. The variation becomes remarkably with the augment of parameters. The sensitivity coefficients of each injection-production operation parameter are ranked, from large to small, as follows: IGP interval, minimum IGP, minimum IGP residence time, injection-production cycle. The results can offer beneficial reference for effectively optimize the injection-production parameters, so as to provide technical guidance for ensuring the stability of the storage and meeting requirements for the storage capacity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023sensitivity,
  author = {Huabin Zhang and Peng Wang and Qiqi Wanyan and Kang Li and Kai Gao and Xianru Yue},
  title = {{Sensitivity analysis of operation parameters of the salt cavern under long-term gas injection-production}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-47352-w},
}
Figure