Sensing Properties of Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes Grown in MW Plasma Torch: Electronic and Electrochemical Behavior, Gas Sensing, Field Emission, IR Absorption

Petra Majzlíková, Jiří Sedláček, Jan Prášek, J Pekárek, Vojtěch Svatoš, Alexander G. Bannov, Ondřej Jašek, Petr Synek, Marek Eliáš, Lenka Zajı́čková, Jaromír HubálekSensors 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the multifaceted sensing capabilities of vertically aligned multi-walled carbon nanotubes (VA-MWCNTs) synthesized via a rapid microwave plasma torch method. The research demonstrates their potential for IR detection, electrochemical sensing, gas sensing (specifically for ammonia), and field emission-based pressure sensing, highlighting the versatility of this CNT growth technique for various sensor applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of advanced sensing technologies is crucial for environmental monitoring, medical diagnostics, and industrial control. Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) possess exceptional electrical, mechanical, and thermal properties that make them promising candidates for next-generation sensors. However, efficiently and controllably growing CNTs in specific configurations (like vertically aligned arrays) and then thoroughly characterizing their diverse sensing functionalities remains a challenge. This paper addresses the need to explore and validate the multi-modal sensing potential of VA-MWCNTs produced by a fast and scalable microwave plasma torch (MW PT) method, aiming to establish its suitability for various sensor applications.

Methods

The core of this research involves the synthesis and characterization of VA-MWCNTs using a microwave plasma torch.

  • CNT Synthesis: VA-MWCNTs were grown on silicon substrates using an atmospheric pressure MW plasma torch. The process is noted for its speed (60-120 seconds) and lack of external substrate heating. Different substrates (bare Si, Si with metallic interlayers, or Si with SiO2) were used depending on the intended application. Catalysts like iron nanoparticles were employed for growth.
  • Structural Characterization: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to examine the morphology and alignment of the grown CNTs.
  • Electrical Characterization:
    • I-V Characteristics and Sheet Resistance: Measured using a semiconductor analyzer and Van der Pauw method to assess the electrical conductivity and linearity of the CNT films.
  • Impedance Spectroscopy: Employed to understand the electrical behavior of the CNT films and contacts, modeled using an RC circuit.
  • IR Absorption: Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy in attenuated total reflection (ATR) mode was used to measure the IR absorption properties of the CNTs, crucial for bolometer applications.
  • Electrochemical Characterization: Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was performed using a VA-MWCNT electrode to evaluate its performance in mediating electron transfer for a redox couple ([Fe(CN)6]4-/3-).
  • Gas Sensing: The resistance change of CNT-based sensors upon exposure to ammonia (NH3) and isobutane (iC4H10) was measured at room temperature and 200 °C.
  • Field Emission: Field emission measurements were conducted in a vacuum chamber to assess the emission current density as a function of electric field intensity, with the setup designed to simulate pressure changes via diaphragm bending.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements performed on the synthesized CNT samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Versatile MW PT Growth: The microwave plasma torch method proves to be a highly efficient and versatile technique for growing VA-MWCNTs suitable for a wide range of sensing applications, all within a very short processing time.
  • Ammonia Sensitivity: The VA-MWCNT sensors exhibit a notable p-type semiconducting behavior, leading to a measurable increase in resistance upon exposure to ammonia. This sensitivity is observed even at room temperature, making it attractive for practical gas sensing.
  • IR Absorption Potential: The CNTs demonstrate significant absorption in the infrared spectrum (8-22 µm), aligning with the atmospheric window, suggesting their utility as an absorption layer in IR detectors and bolometers.
  • Electrochemical Activity: The VA-MWCNT electrodes facilitate efficient electron transfer, showing good electrochemical properties that make them promising for electrochemical sensors and biosensors.
  • Field Emission for Pressure Sensing: The field emission characteristics of the VA-MWCNTs are stable and exhibit a low turn-on field, making them suitable for pressure sensing applications when integrated into a diode structure with a bending diaphragm.

Key Results

  • CNT Structure: VA-MWCNTs with an average diameter < 80 nm and a film thickness of ~16 µm were successfully grown. SEM images confirmed vertical alignment, though some curling at the top was observed.
  • Electrical Properties: The CNT films exhibited a low resistance (~0.5 Ω·cm) with a small non-linearity (~0.5%). Impedance spectroscopy revealed contact resistances of ~500 Ω and CNT film resistances of ~700 Ω, with significantly higher capacitance for the contacts (15 nF) compared to the CNT film (3.5 nF).
  • IR Absorption: A mean absorbance of nearly 80% was observed in the IR range of 8–22 µm.
  • Electrochemical Performance: Cyclic voltammetry showed well-defined, symmetric redox peaks with a peak separation (ΔEp) of 83 mV and a peak current ratio (Ipa/Ipc) of 1.01, indicating good electron transfer.
  • Gas Sensing: The sensor showed a response to ammonia, with the resistance increasing upon exposure. The highest response (1.9%) was observed at room temperature for 500 ppm of NH3. The sensor was insensitive to isobutane.
  • Field Emission: A low turn-on field (< 1 V·µm⁻¹) was achieved, with current densities of hundreds of µA at 1.8 V·µm⁻¹. The field emission current was found to be reversible and dependent on electrode distance and applied voltage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CNT Alignment Imperfection: While vertically aligned, the SEM images showed some curling at the top ends of the nanotubes, which might affect performance in certain applications.
  • Gas Sensor Sensitivity: The ammonia sensor's response (1.9% for 500 ppm) is considered good for untreated CNTs, but further functionalization or decoration with nanoparticles could potentially enhance sensitivity and selectivity, as suggested by comparisons with other studies.
  • Pressure Sensor Optimization: The field emission characteristics suggest potential for pressure sensing, but further work could focus on optimizing the diaphragm design and electrode configuration for higher sensitivity and a wider dynamic range.
  • Scale-up and Durability: While the MW PT method is fast, the paper doesn't extensively discuss long-term stability or the challenges of scaling up these sensor devices for mass production.

The authors suggest that the CNT sensor can be further improved by suitable functionalization or decoration with metallic nanoparticles, and that the direct nanotube growth on the substrate allows for managing response through synthesis conditions, which is critical for scale-up production.

Summary updated

Abstract

Vertically aligned multi-walled carbon nanotubes (VA-MWCNTs) with an average diameter below 80 nm and a thickness of the uniform VA-MWCNT layer of about 16 µm were grown in microwave plasma torch and tested for selected functional properties. IR absorption important for a construction of bolometers was studied by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. Basic electrochemical characterization was performed by cyclic voltammetry. Comparing the obtained results with the standard or MWCNT‑modified screen-printed electrodes, the prepared VA-MWCNT electrodes indicated their high potential for the construction of electrochemical sensors. Resistive CNT gas sensor revealed a good sensitivity to ammonia taking into account room temperature operation. Field emission detected from CNTs was suitable for the pressure sensing application based on the measurement of emission current in the diode structure with bending diaphragm. The advantages of microwave plasma torch growth of CNTs, i.e., fast processing and versatility of the process, can be therefore fully exploited for the integration of surface-bound grown CNTs into various sensing structures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{majzlikova2015sensing,
  author = {Petra Majzlíková and Jiří Sedláček and Jan Prášek and J Pekárek and Vojtěch Svatoš and Alexander G. Bannov and Ondřej Jašek and Petr Synek and Marek Eliáš and Lenka Zajı́čková and Jaromír Hubálek},
  title = {{Sensing Properties of Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes Grown in MW Plasma Torch: Electronic and Electrochemical Behavior, Gas Sensing, Field Emission, IR Absorption}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s150202644},
}
Figure