Sense-antisense gene overlap is probably a cause for retaining the few introns in Giardia genome and the implications

Min Xue, Bing Chen, Qingqing Ye, Jingru Shao, Zhangxia Lyu, Jianfan WenBiology 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why the parasite Giardia lamblia retains a remarkably small number of introns, a common feature in most eukaryotes. The authors propose that the retention of these few introns is not due to their own functional importance, but rather due to "overlap constraints" imposed by overlapping sense-antisense gene pairs, suggesting a novel mechanism for intron preservation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Eukaryotic genomes are generally characterized by the presence of introns, non-coding sequences within genes that are spliced out before protein synthesis. While the last eukaryotic common ancestor is thought to have been intron-rich, many modern eukaryotes have undergone massive intron loss. However, the reasons behind this widespread intron loss, and more intriguingly, the mechanisms that prevent intron loss and lead to their retention in intron-poor organisms, remain largely elusive. Giardia lamblia is a particularly interesting case, possessing an extremely reduced genome with only eight spliceosomal introns. This study aims to understand why these few introns are retained despite the apparent evolutionary pressure for intron loss.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bioinformatics Analysis: They analyzed the Giardia lamblia genome (GiardiaDB) to identify intron-containing genes and their characteristics, including their evolutionary age (ancient vs. later-evolved) and whether their introns were conserved or Giardia-specific.
  • Comparative Genomics: They compared Giardia genes and introns with those from other eukaryotes to assess conservation and identify Giardia-specific elements.
  • Experimental Verification:
    • Strand-specific RT-PCR: This technique was used to confirm the transcription of identified antisense genes and to determine if the introns of sense genes were located within overlapping regions with these antisense genes.
  • Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends (RACE): This method was used to determine the full-length transcripts of the antisense genes, helping to characterize their nature (e.g., coding vs. non-coding).
  • Sequence Analysis: Sequencing of RT-PCR and RACE products was performed to confirm the identity and structure of the transcripts.

Datasets

  • GiardiaDB: Used as the primary source for genomic sequences and annotations of Giardia lamblia genes.
  • NCBI non-redundant protein sequences (nr) database: Used for homology searches to identify conserved proteins and assess the novelty of Giardia-specific genes.
  • GenBank: Used for comparative analysis of gene sequences with other organisms.
  • Other Giardia isolates with sequenced genomes: Used to investigate the prevalence of sense-antisense gene overlaps across different Giardia strains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intron Gain and Loss Coexist: Despite massive intron loss in Giardia, new introns have also arisen in both ancient and recently evolved genes, indicating a dynamic evolutionary process.
  • External Constraints on Intron Retention: The retention of the few Giardia introns is unlikely to be due to intrinsic functional importance of the introns themselves. Instead, the study points to external genomic constraints.
  • Sense-Antisense Gene Overlap as a Key Factor: The most significant finding is the identification of sense-antisense (SAS) gene pairs where introns of the sense gene are located within the overlapping region of transcription with the antisense gene. This "overlap constraint" is proposed as a primary mechanism preventing intron loss.
  • "Functional Constraint" Re-evaluated: The study challenges the traditional view that intron retention is solely driven by the intron's own function. It suggests that "functional constraint" might be more broadly interpreted to include constraints imposed by neighboring genomic elements.

Key Results

  • Of the eight introns in Giardia, three were found to be ancient and conserved, one was a later-evolved intron in an ancient gene, and four were Giardia-specific introns in Giardia-specific genes.
  • Two specific intron-containing genes (GL50803-17244 and GL50803-37070) were found to form SAS gene pairs with their complementary strand genes (GL50803-20429 and GL50803-28204, respectively).
  • Experimental verification confirmed that the introns in these two sense genes reside within the overlapping regions of these SAS gene pairs.
  • The antisense genes themselves were found to be transcribed but lacked introns in the corresponding overlapping regions.
  • Analysis of other Giardia isolates revealed that SAS gene overlaps are not unique to the WB isolate studied, suggesting this is a more widespread phenomenon in Giardia.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty of Antisense Gene Function: While the transcription of the two identified antisense genes was confirmed, their precise function (protein-coding or non-coding) and homology to known proteins remain unclear, even after extensive experimental efforts. This lack of definitive functional annotation for the antisense genes is a limitation.
  • Other Introns: For the remaining six introns, no ORFs were found on their complementary strands, and no transcripts were detected. However, the authors acknowledge the possibility that these introns might be retained due to other unknown genomic functional elements that are not transcribed or are difficult to identify with current methods.
  • Broader Applicability: While the study focused on Giardia, the authors suggest that this "overlap constraint" mechanism might be a general principle for intron retention in other eukaryotes, especially in compact genomes where overlapping transcription is more common. Future work could explore this mechanism in other intron-poor organisms.
  • Identification of Novel Functional Elements: The findings provide a valuable clue for identifying new genomic functional elements, particularly in regions that overlap with introns, which might have been previously overlooked as "junk DNA."

Summary updated

Abstract

This article was reviewed by Mikhail Gelfand, Michael Gray, and Igor Rogozin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xue2018sense,
  author = {Min Xue and Bing Chen and Qingqing Ye and Jingru Shao and Zhangxia Lyu and Jianfan Wen},
  title = {{Sense-antisense gene overlap is probably a cause for retaining the few introns in Giardia genome and the implications}},
  booktitle = {Biology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1186/s13062-018-0226-5},
}
Figure