Sense-antisense gene overlap causes evolutionary retention of the few introns in Giardia genome and the implications

Min Xue, Bing Chen, Qingqing Ye, Jingru Shao, Zhangxia Lyu, Jianfan WenbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why Giardia lamblia, a eukaryote with a remarkably low intron count, retains its few introns. The researchers found that sense-antisense gene overlaps, where introns are located in the overlapping regions, are a key factor in preventing intron loss, suggesting that functional constraints outside the introns themselves are crucial for their retention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Eukaryotic genomes are generally characterized by the presence of introns, which are non-coding sequences within genes that are spliced out during RNA processing. However, over evolutionary time, many eukaryotes have undergone massive intron loss, leading to genomes with very few introns. While the causes of intron loss are still debated, the question of why some introns are retained under this strong selective pressure has been less explored. It's often hypothesized that retained introns possess essential functions that prevent their deletion. This paper tackles this question by examining Giardia lamblia, a protozoan with an exceptionally simple genome containing only eight spliceosomal introns, making it an ideal model to understand intron retention mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bioinformatics Analysis: They used the GiardiaDB database to identify intron-containing genes and their introns. Comparative sequence analysis was used to classify introns and genes as "ancient" or "relatively new" based on their conservation across eukaryotes.
  • Experimental Verification:
    • Strand-specific RT-PCR: This technique was used to confirm the transcription of antisense genes and to detect transcripts in overlapping regions.
  • RACE (Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends): This method was used to determine the full-length transcripts of the antisense genes.
  • Sequence Analysis: Predicted ORFs (Open Reading Frames) of antisense genes were analyzed for homology to known proteins.
  • RNA Secondary Structure Prediction: The RNAfold web server was used to predict potential secondary structures of introns.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the GiardiaDB genome database (December 1, 2017 release). Additionally, NCBI's non-redundant protein sequences (nr) database and GenBank were used for homology searches.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sense-Antisense Overlap as a Retention Mechanism: The most significant finding is the identification of sense-antisense (SAS) gene pairs where introns are located within the overlapping regions. This overlap appears to impose a "constraint" that prevents the deletion of these introns.
  • External Constraints, Not Intrinsic Function: The study challenges the prevailing hypothesis that intron retention is solely due to the intrinsic functional importance of the introns themselves. Instead, it suggests that external genomic features, like overlapping genes, play a more significant role.
  • Dynamic Intron Evolution: Despite massive intron loss, Giardia also shows evidence of intron gain, with new introns appearing in both ancient and newly evolved genes, highlighting a dynamic evolutionary process.
  • Potential for Discovering New Genomic Elements: The identification of SAS gene overlaps suggests that these regions might harbor previously unrecognized functional genomic elements, potentially including non-coding RNAs.

Key Results

  • Giardia lamblia possesses only eight spliceosomal introns, with four being in "ancient" genes and four in "relatively new" genes.
  • Two of the eight intron-containing genes were found to form SAS gene pairs with their complementary antisense genes, with the introns situated in the overlapping regions.
  • Experimental verification confirmed the transcription of these antisense genes, and they were found to lack introns themselves.
  • No special structural features or functional importance of the retained introns were identified that could explain their retention.
  • For the other six introns, no ORFs were found on their complementary strands, and no transcripts were detected in the overlapping regions, though the possibility of untranscribed functional elements remains.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty for Six Introns: While a strong case is made for the two SAS gene pairs, the retention mechanism for the other six introns remains uncertain. The authors suggest that unknown genomic functional elements, possibly untranscribed, could be responsible.
  • Characterization of Antisense Genes: The precise function and classification of the two identified antisense genes are still not fully determined, with possibilities including non-protein-coding genes or Giardia-specific protein-coding genes.
  • Broader Eukaryotic Relevance: While the findings are significant for Giardia, further research is needed to determine if this "overlap constraint" mechanism is a widespread phenomenon across other intron-poor eukaryotes. The authors believe more examples are likely to be found.
  • Finding New Functional Elements: The study opens avenues for future research to actively search for new genomic functional elements in overlapping regions, potentially by analyzing regions previously dismissed as "junk" DNA.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background It is widely accepted that the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA) and early eukaryotes were intron-rich and intron loss dominated subsequent evolution, thus the presence of only very few introns in some modern eukaryotes must be the consequence of massive loss. But it is striking that few eukaryotes were found to have completely lost introns. Despite extensive research, the causes of massive intron losses remain elusive, and actually the reverse question – how the few introns are retained under the pressure of loss is equally significant but was rarely studied, except that it was conjectured that the essential functions of some introns prevent their loss. The extremely few (eight) spliceosome-mediated cis-spliced introns in the relatively simple genome of Giardia lamblia provide an excellent opportunity to explore this question. Results Our investigation of the intron-containing genes and introns in Giardia found three types of intron distribution patterns: ancient intron in ancient gene, relatively new intron in ancient gene, and relatively new intron in relatively new gene, which can reflect to some extent the dynamic evolution of introns in Giardia . Not finding any special features or functional importance of these introns responsible for the retention, we noticed and experimentally verified that some intron-containing genes form sense-antisense gene pairs with functional genes on their complementary strands, and that the introns just reside in the overlapping regions. Conclusions In Giardia ’s evolution, despite constant pressure of intron loss, intron gain can still occur in both ancient and newly-evolved genes, but only a few introns have been retained; the evolutionary retention of introns is most likely not due to the functional constraint of the introns themselves but the causes outside of introns, such as the constraints imposed by other genomic functional elements overlapping with the introns. These findings can not only provide some clues to find new genomic functional elements -- in the areas overlapping with introngs, but suggest that “functional constraint” of introns may not be necessarily directly associated with intron loss and gain, or that the real functions or the way of functioning of introns are probably still outside of our current knowledge.
BibTeX
@misc{xue2018sense,
  author = {Min Xue and Bing Chen and Qingqing Ye and Jingru Shao and Zhangxia Lyu and Jianfan Wen},
  title = {{Sense-antisense gene overlap causes evolutionary retention of the few introns in <i>Giardia</i> genome and the implications}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/333310},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure