Semiring Reasoning Frameworks in AI and Their Computational Complexity

Thomas Eiter, Rafael KieselJAIR 2023 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a generalized framework for computational complexity in AI, called NP(R), that accounts for semiring-based reasoning. It establishes NP(R)-completeness for key AI problems like SAT(R) and provides a tetrachotomy of complexity for semirings, revealing how their structure dictates computational hardness. This work offers a unified approach to understanding the complexity of diverse quantitative AI problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many AI problems, such as probabilistic inference, weighted model counting, and learning, go beyond simple "yes/no" answers. They often involve computing quantities associated with solutions, like the number of solutions or optimal values. To handle these diverse quantitative problems uniformly, researchers have adopted the "semiring paradigm," where abstract algebraic structures called semirings parameterize problem definitions. While specific semiring-based frameworks have been studied, a systematic understanding of their computational complexity based on the chosen semiring has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a unified framework and complexity analysis for these semiring-based AI reasoning systems.

Methods

The core contribution is the introduction of Semiring Turing Machines (SRTMs), a novel machine model designed to handle computations over semirings. SRTMs allow for atomic semiring operations, summing values from nondeterministic computations, and using semiring values in calculations. Based on SRTMs, the paper defines NP(R), a generalization of the complexity class NP to semiring settings. SAT(R), a semiring version of the Boolean satisfiability problem, is then introduced as a canonical NP(R)-complete problem. This NP(R) framework serves as a toolbox for analyzing the complexity of various semiring-based AI formalisms. The paper also introduces Karp surrogate-reductions to handle semiring values on tapes and explores the impact of semiring properties like periodicity and offset on complexity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Semirings as a Unifying Complexity Parameter: The paper demonstrates that the choice of semiring fundamentally impacts the computational complexity of AI reasoning problems. This provides a principled way to analyze and compare different quantitative AI approaches.
  • NP(R) as a Generalization of NP: The introduction of NP(R) offers a powerful abstraction for understanding complexity in semiring-based settings, bridging the gap between classical complexity theory and quantitative AI.
  • Tetrachotomy of Semiring Complexity: The paper reveals that non-trivial commutative semirings can be categorized into four distinct complexity classes (NP-like, MODpP-like, MODpP ∪ NP-like, or #P-like) based on their periodicity and offset properties. This provides a high-level understanding of semiring hardness.
  • Encoding Matters, but Structure is Key: While the encoding of semiring values can influence complexity, the paper emphasizes that the inherent algebraic structure of the semiring (periodicity, offset) plays a more significant role in determining the fundamental hardness of problems.

Key Results

  • NP(R)-completeness of SAT(R): The paper proves that SAT(R) is NP(R)-complete for any commutative semiring R, establishing it as a central problem for this complexity class.
  • NP(R)-completeness for various AI frameworks: Problems like Sum-Of-Products, Weighted First-Order Logic Evaluation, Semiring-based Constraint Satisfaction Problems, Algebraic Model Counting, and Semiring-induced Propositional Logic are shown to be NP(R)-complete.
  • Tetrachotomy Result: Non-trivial commutative semirings are shown to fall into one of four complexity categories: NP-like, MODpP-like, MODpP ∪ NP-like, or #P-like.
  • Complexity Bounds for Specific Semirings: The paper provides detailed complexity results for semirings like N, Z, Q, Rmax, and polynomial semirings, relating them to classical complexity classes such as NP, #P, GAPP, and OPTP. For instance, SAT(bin(N)) is shown to be #P-complete.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Encoding Influence: The paper acknowledges that the choice of encoding for semiring values can affect complexity, especially for arbitrary semirings. While they focus on the semiring's structure, efficient encodings are crucial for practical applications.
  • Non-commutative Semirings: The current work focuses on commutative semirings. Investigating non-commutative semirings is suggested as a future direction, as it is expected to lead to even harder problems.
  • Other Semiring Properties: Exploring additional properties of semirings beyond periodicity and offset could reveal further insights into complexity.
  • SRTM vs. BSS Machines: Further research is suggested to understand the power differences between SRTMs and other algebraic computation models like Blum-Shub-Smale (BSS) machines, particularly concerning recursive computations.
  • Descriptive Complexity: Connecting NP(R) and second-order logic over semirings is proposed as a way to generalize Fagin's theorem and assess the expressiveness of AI reasoning frameworks.
  • Knowledge Compilation: The application of polynomial semirings in knowledge compilation is highlighted as a promising area, potentially leading to more efficient representations and inference.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{eiter2023semiring,
  author = {Thomas Eiter and Rafael Kiesel},
  title = {{Semiring Reasoning Frameworks in AI and Their Computational Complexity}},
  journal = {J. Artif. Intell. Res.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1613/jair.1.13970},
}

Loading related content...

Figure