Self-Supervised Bisimulation Action Chunk Representation for Efficient RL

Lei Shi, Jianye Hao, Hongyao Tang, Zibin Dong, Yan ZhengSafeGenAi @ NeurIPS 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Action Chunk Representation (ACR), a novel self-supervised framework that learns a compact, semantically rich representation of multi-step actions (action chunks) for reinforcement learning. By leveraging a new "action chunk bisimulation metric" and a Transformer encoder, ACR effectively captures the underlying structure of these action chunks, leading to significantly improved learning efficiency and performance in complex robotic manipulation and navigation tasks compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reinforcement learning (RL) agents often struggle with high-dimensional or complex action spaces, which can slow down learning and lead to inconsistent behavior. Action chunking, a technique that groups sequences of primitive actions into "chunks," aims to alleviate this by reducing the effective decision-making frequency. However, the resulting action chunk space can be vast and contain many meaningless combinations. Existing methods for learning representations in single-step action spaces don't effectively capture the crucial temporal and semantic information inherent in these multi-step action chunks. This paper addresses the challenge of learning a structured and semantically meaningful representation space specifically for these action chunks to enable more efficient and effective RL.

Methods

The core contribution is the Action Chunk Representation (ACR) framework. ACR tackles the problem by:

  • Action Chunk Bisimulation Metric: This is a novel metric designed to quantify the "behavioral similarity" between two action chunks. It extends the concept of bisimulation from state-space to action-chunk space, measuring how similarly two chunks affect future states and rewards. This metric is used as a self-supervised objective to guide the learning of the representation space.
  • Causal Transformer Encoder: To capture the temporal dynamics within an action chunk, ACR employs a Causal Transformer. This encoder processes the sequence of primitive actions within a chunk and outputs a latent representation that encodes both temporal structure and behavioral semantics.
  • Latent Representation Space: The Transformer encoder maps action chunks into a compact, low-dimensional latent space. The goal is for chunks with similar bisimulation behavior semantics to be close to each other in this space.
  • Latent Policy Training: A standard DRL algorithm (like TD3, DDPG, or SAC) is then trained to operate in this learned latent action chunk space. This simplifies the policy learning problem.
  • Action Chunk Decoding: Once the latent policy selects a latent action chunk, a decoder maps it back to the original primitive action space for execution in the environment.
  • Periodic Updates and Adaptive Constraints: To maintain the quality of the representation space as the policy improves, ACR incorporates periodic updates to the representation learning components and adaptive constraints on the latent space range.

Datasets

The paper evaluates ACR on a range of existing benchmarks:

  • 2DoF Arm Control: Tasks like ReacherVertical, ReacherTurn, and ReacherPush from OpenAI Gym (based on MuJoCo).
  • 7DoF Arm Control: Tasks like Pusher-v2, Striker-v2, and Thrower-v2 from OpenAI Gym.
  • Maze Navigation: Tasks including Medium Maze, Large Maze, and Ultra Maze, derived from D4RL's Maze2D.

No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bisimulation for Actions is Key: The paper highlights that simply applying single-step representation methods to action chunks is insufficient. The novel bisimulation metric for action chunks is crucial because it directly enforces that chunks leading to similar outcomes (transitions and rewards) are represented similarly, capturing the behavioral semantics.
  • Temporal Structure Matters: Using a Transformer encoder to explicitly model the temporal sequence within an action chunk is vital for creating a rich and informative representation. This contrasts with methods that might treat chunks more statically.
  • Action Chunk Space is Inherently Structured: The success of ACR suggests that action chunk spaces, despite their potential for high dimensionality, possess an underlying structure that can be learned and exploited for efficient RL.
  • Generalizability: ACR is designed to be algorithm-agnostic, meaning it can be integrated with various DRL algorithms, demonstrating its broad applicability.

Key Results

  • Significant Performance Gains: When combined with DRL algorithms (DDPG, TD3, SAC), ACR consistently outperformed the base algorithms trained on the original action spaces across nine different tasks. This improvement was particularly notable in challenging tasks with sparse rewards or complex action spaces.
  • Faster Learning: ACR led to significantly faster learning efficiency, meaning agents reached higher performance levels in fewer environment steps.
  • Superiority over Other Representation Methods: ACR outperformed other self-supervised action representation learning methods (Reconstruction, Forward Prediction, Inverse Prediction) on these tasks, especially as task difficulty increased. This suggests that ACR's behavior-centric approach is more effective for action chunks.
  • Ablation Studies Confirm Component Importance: Removing the bisimulation metric, the Transformer encoder, or the periodic updates/adaptive constraints led to performance degradation, underscoring the importance of each component in ACR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While ACR improves learning efficiency, the pre-training of the representation components (encoder, decoder, transition/reward models) adds an initial computational overhead.
  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: Like many deep learning methods, ACR might be sensitive to hyperparameter choices, although the paper provides detailed settings.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring ACR in more complex scenarios, such as multi-agent systems or hierarchical RL, and investigating its potential for offline RL settings. Further research into more efficient ways to integrate the representation learning and policy optimization stages could also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Action chunking in reinforcement learning is a promising approach, as it significantly reduces decision-making frequency and leads to more consistent behavior. However, due to inherent differences between the action chunk space and the original action space, uncovering its underlying structure is crucial. Previous works cope with this challenge of single-step action space through action representation methods, but directly applying these methods to action chunk space fails to capture the semantic information of multi-step behaviors. In this paper, we introduce \textbf{A}ction \textbf{C}hunk \textbf{R}epresentation (\textbf{ACR}), a self-supervised representation learning framework for uncovering the underlying structure of the action chunk space to achieve efficient RL. To build the framework, we propose the action chunk bisimulation metric to measure the principled distance between action chunks. With this metric, ACR encodes action chunks with a Transformer that extracts the temporal structure and learns a latent representation space where action churns with similar bisimulation behavior semantics are close to each other. The latent policy is then trained in the representation space, and the selected latent action chunk is decoded back into the original space to interact with the environment. We flexibly integrate ACR with various DRL algorithms and evaluate it on a range of continuous manipulation and navigation tasks. Experiments show that ACR surpasses existing action representation baselines in terms of both learning efficiency and performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2024self,
  author = {Lei Shi and Jianye HAO and Hongyao Tang and Zibin Dong and YAN ZHENG},
  title = {{Self-Supervised Bisimulation Action Chunk Representation for Efficient RL}},
  booktitle = {SafeGenAi @ NeurIPS},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4i6RilTlhI},
}
Figure