Self-organization mechanism of distinct microtubule orientations in axons and dendrites

Honda Naoki, Katsuhiro Uegaki, Shin IshiibioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a biophysical model that explains how neurons develop distinct internal structures (microtubule orientations) in their axons and dendrites. The model reveals that simple variations in neurite growth speed and microtubule hydrolysis rates can account for the different patterns observed across species, offering a unified mechanism for neuronal polarization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neurons are highly specialized cells with distinct parts: axons, which transmit signals away from the cell body, and dendrites, which receive signals. This specialization is reflected in their internal scaffolding, particularly the orientation of microtubules (MTs). Axons typically have MTs all pointing in the same direction (plus-end-out), while dendrites can have a mixed orientation (vertebrates) or MTs pointing in the opposite direction (minus-end-out, invertebrates). While these differences are known, the underlying mechanisms that cause these distinct MT organizations during neuronal development have remained largely unknown. This paper aims to bridge that gap by proposing a computational model to explain how these self-organized MT patterns arise.

Methods

The authors developed a biophysical computational model of MT kinetics within a growing neurite. The model simulates MTs elongating and shrinking within a growth cone at the neurite's tip. Key processes included:

  • MT Assembly Dynamics: MTs polymerize (grow) and depolymerize (shrink) at both their plus and minus ends. Polymerization is faster at the plus end.
  • GTP Cap and Hydrolysis: MTs are capped with GTP-bound tubulin. This GTP is hydrolyzed to GDP, which can lead to a rapid depolymerization event called "catastrophe" at the plus end. The minus end is more stable.
  • Neurite Growth: The neurite itself grows, creating space for MTs. This growth speed is a key parameter.
  • MT Replacement: Existing MTs are replaced by new, randomly oriented MT fragments, either spontaneously or when they shrink out of the growth cone.
  • Parameter Variation: The model explores how variations in neurite growth speed and the rate of GTP hydrolysis influence the overall MT orientation patterns.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a computational model and simulation, not experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Growth Speed is Crucial: The speed at which a neurite grows is a primary determinant of MT orientation. Faster growth favors different patterns than slower growth.
  • Hydrolysis Rate Dictates Species Differences: The rate at which GTP is hydrolyzed to GDP within the MTs is key to explaining the differences between vertebrate and invertebrate dendrites. A low hydrolysis rate leads to vertebrate patterns, while a high rate leads to invertebrate patterns.
  • Unified Mechanism: The model demonstrates that a single, unified biophysical framework can explain all three observed MT orientation patterns (plus-end-out, minus-end-out, and mixed) by simply adjusting the neurite growth speed and hydrolysis rate parameters.
  • Axon vs. Dendrite Distinction: The model successfully reproduces the plus-end-out pattern in fast-growing neurites (mimicking axons) and mixed or minus-end-out patterns in slower-growing neurites (mimicking dendrites), depending on the hydrolysis rate.

Key Results

The simulations yielded the following key results:

  • Vertebrate Patterns (Low Hydrolysis): In fast-growing neurites (50 µm/h), a plus-end-out MT pattern emerged. In slow-growing neurites (15 µm/h), a mixed MT pattern was observed. This aligns with vertebrate axon and dendrite MT orientations.
  • Invertebrate Patterns (High Hydrolysis): With a high hydrolysis rate (30 µm/h), fast-growing neurites still showed a plus-end-out pattern, but slow-growing neurites exhibited a minus-end-out pattern. This matches invertebrate axon and dendrite MT orientations.
  • Phase Diagram: A phase diagram was generated showing the MT orientation patterns as a function of neurite growth speed and hydrolysis speed, providing a clear visual representation of how different conditions lead to different outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several simplifications in their model:

  • Neurite Growth Independence: They assumed neurite growth speed was independent of MTs, even though MTs interact with actin filaments that drive growth. Modeling this complex interaction is currently intractable.
  • Simultaneous MT Replacement: MT replacement was modeled as occurring simultaneously with inactivation and insertion, whereas in reality, these events might be asynchronous.
  • Fixed MT Number: The model assumed a fixed number of MTs, while the actual number might vary between major and minor neurites.

Despite these simplifications, the model is considered biologically plausible and informative. Future work could involve:

  • Experimental Validation: The authors suggest their predictions are experimentally testable, for example, by manipulating tubulin concentration or CAMSAP proteins to alter MT elongation speeds, or by altering hydrolysis rates to see if vertebrate-to-invertebrate dendrite conversion occurs.
  • Incorporating MAPs: Investigating the role of microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) like tau and MAP2, which are known to be localized in axons and dendrites, respectively, could provide further insights into the acquisition of neuronal identities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The identities of axons and dendrites are acquired through the self-organization of distinct microtubule (MT) orientations during neuronal polarization. The axon is generally characterized by a uniform MT orientation with all plus-ends pointing outward to the neurite terminal (‘plus-end-out’ pattern). On the other hand, the MT orientation pattern in the dendrites depends on species: vertebrate dendrites have a mixed alignment with both plus and minus ends facing either the terminal or the cell body (‘mixed’ pattern), whereas invertebrate dendrites have a ‘minus-end-out’ pattern. However, how MT organizations are developed in the axon and the dendrites is largely unknown. To investigate the mechanism of MT organization, we developed a biophysical model of MT kinetics, consisting of polymerization/depolymerization and MT catastrophe coupled with neurite outgrowth. The model simulation showed that the MT orientation can be controlled mainly by the speed of neurite growth and the hydrolysis rate. With a low hydrolysis rate, vertebrate plus-end-out and mixed microtubule patterns emerged in fast- and slow-growing neurites, respectively. In contrast, with a high hydrolysis rate, invertebrate plus-end-out and minus-end-out microtubule patterns emerged in fast- and slow-growing neurites, respectively. Thus, our model can provide a unified understanding of distinct microtubule organizations by simply changing the parameters.
BibTeX
@misc{naoki2017self,
  author = {Honda Naoki and Katsuhiro Uegaki and Shin Ishii},
  title = {{Self-organization mechanism of distinct microtubule orientations in axons and dendrites}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/163014},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure