Self-forced evolutions of an implicit rotating source: A natural framework to model comparable and intermediate mass-ratio systems from inspiral through ringdown

E. A. Huerta, P. Kumar, J. R. Gair, Sean T. McWilliamsPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new waveform model for binary black hole mergers, particularly for systems with comparable or intermediate mass ratios. It combines advanced self-force corrections with an "implicit rotating source" approach to accurately describe the entire inspiral, merger, and ringdown phases, outperforming existing models for these challenging systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black hole (BBH) mergers is a key goal of current and future observatories like LIGO, Virgo, and Kagra. While much progress has been made in modeling extreme mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) and comparable mass-ratio mergers, accurately modeling intermediate mass-ratio inspirals (IMRIs) and comparable mass-ratio systems, especially those involving intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs), remains a challenge. Existing models, like post-Newtonian (PN) approximations, break down in the strong-field regime near the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) and during the merger and ringdown. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a unified waveform model that accurately captures these crucial phases for a wider range of mass ratios.

Methods

The authors build their waveform model in four stages:

  1. Inspiral Evolution: They employ the Effective One Body (EOB) formalism, which maps the binary's motion to a test particle in a Schwarzschild spacetime. Crucially, they incorporate first-order conservative self-force corrections to the EOB potentials. These corrections are derived from recent advancements in self-force theory and are valid in the strong-field regime. They also derive second-order radiative corrections to the energy flux by minimizing the phase discrepancy between their self-force model and the EOB model.
  2. Transition Phase: To smoothly connect the late inspiral to the plunge, they extend the "transition phase" model developed by Ori and Thorne. This extension includes finite mass-ratio corrections and uses an "implicit rotating source" (IRS) model to describe the orbital phase evolution.
  3. Plunge Phase: The plunge phase is modeled using the equations of motion derived from the transition phase, with the orbital frequency evolution governed by the IRS model.
  4. Ringdown Waveform: The ringdown phase is constructed using a sum of quasinormal modes (QNMs). They also demonstrate that the IRS model can naturally produce a ringdown waveform equivalent to the QNM sum, providing a unified description.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on developing a theoretical model and calibrating it against existing numerical relativity simulations and the Effective One Body (EOB) model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Self-Force Corrections are Crucial: Incorporating first-order conservative self-force corrections into the EOB formalism significantly improves the accuracy of waveform modeling, especially in the strong-field regime near the ISCO.
  • No ISCO for High Mass Ratios: For binaries with mass ratios $q \ge 1/6$, the self-force model indicates the absence of a traditional ISCO, a significant departure from PN approximations.
  • Implicit Rotating Source (IRS) for Smooth Transitions: The IRS model provides a natural and effective way to transition from the late inspiral to the plunge and ringdown phases, ensuring continuity and accuracy.
  • Unified Model Potential: This work demonstrates the potential for a single waveform model to accurately describe systems across a broad range of mass ratios, from comparable to intermediate, which is essential for future GW detection and analysis.

Key Results

  • The developed waveform model shows substantially better performance than standard post-Newtonian (PN) approximants for modeling neutron star-black hole mergers from early inspiral to the ISCO.
  • The model reproduces the orbital phase evolution predicted by the EOB model within the accuracy of available numerical relativity simulations for various mass ratios.
  • The IRS approach provides a natural transition from late-time radiation to ringdown, equivalent to QNM-based ringdown modeling.
  • The model is computationally efficient, with their code being approximately 20% faster than an optimized EOB code.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Second-Order Radiative Corrections: While the paper derives second-order radiative corrections to the energy flux, these are obtained through optimization to match the EOB model. The formal derivation of these corrections from first principles is still an open area.
  • Spin and Eccentricity: The current model assumes non-spinning black holes and circular orbits. Future work will involve incorporating spin effects and modeling binaries with non-negligible eccentricity, which are expected in dense stellar environments like globular clusters.
  • Kerr Background: Extending the self-force calculations to the Kerr background (for spinning black holes) is a necessary next step for a more complete model.
  • Numerical Relativity Calibration: While the model is calibrated against EOB and numerical relativity simulations, further validation with a wider range of numerical relativity data, especially for higher mass ratios, would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a waveform model to describe the inspiral, merger and ringdown of binary systems with comparable and intermediate mass ratios. This model incorporates first-order conservative self-force corrections to the energy and angular momentum, which are valid in the strong-field regime [S. Akcay et al., Phys. Rev. D 86, 104041 (2012)]. We model the radiative part of the self-force by deriving second-order radiative corrections to the energy flux. These corrections are obtained by minimizing the phase discrepancy between our self-force model and the effective one body model [Y. Pan et al., Phys. Rev. D 84, 124052 (2011) and T. Damour et al., Phys. Rev. D 87, 084035 (2013)] for a variety of mass ratios. We show that our model performs substantially better than post-Newtonian approximants currently used to model neutron star--black hole mergers from early inspiral to the innermost stable circular orbit. In order to match the late inspiral evolution onto the plunge regime, we extend the ``transition phase'' developed by Ori and Thorne Phys. Rev. D 62, 124022 (2000) by including finite mass-ratio corrections and modeling the orbital phase evolution using an implicit rotating source [J. G. Baker et al., Phys. Rev. D 78, 044046 (2008)]. We explicitly show that the implicit rotating source approach provides a natural transition from late-time radiation to ringdown that is equivalent to ringdown waveform modeling based on a sum of quasinormal modes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huerta2014self,
  author = {E. A. Huerta and P. Kumar and J. R. Gair and Sean T. McWilliams},
  title = {{Self-forced evolutions of an implicit rotating source: A natural framework to model comparable and intermediate mass-ratio systems from inspiral through ringdown}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.90.024024},
}
Figure