Abstract
Adolescent smartphone addiction has increasingly attracted the attention of scholars due to the widespread use of internet technology in educational environments. This research examines whether subjective well-being mediates the relationship between self-consistency congruence—the harmony between an individual’s self-perception and their actual experiences—and smartphone addiction, and whether gender moderates this process. A study of 1,011 Chinese adolescents revealed that self-consistency congruence is a significant predictor of addiction, with subjective well-being acting as a partial mediator. Notably, the mediating process is moderated by gender; the association between internal conflict and addiction is significantly more pronounced in girls than in boys.
Introduction: The Psychological Roots of Addiction
While smartphone addiction is a recognized global issue, the underlying psychological mechanisms—particularly those related to the "self"—remain under-investigated in adolescents. Most research focuses on external factors like peers or family. This study applies Carl Rogers’ humanistic personality theory to examine self-consistency congruence. When a gap exists between one’s self-perception and actual experience (incongruence), it creates internal tension. This paper investigates whether adolescents use smartphones to escape this tension and whether their overall happiness (subjective well-being) acts as a mediator in this process.
Methodology and Conceptual Framework
The researchers employed a cross-sectional survey design, collecting data from 941 valid adolescent participants (grades 7–9) in Jiangxi Province, China. The sample was nearly evenly split by gender (49.4% boys, 50.6% girls).
To analyze the data, the authors used a moderated mediation model to test if subjective well-being mediates the link between self-consistency and addiction, and if gender moderates the strength of those relationships. Participants completed three established psychometric instruments: the Self-Consistency Congruence Scale, the Smartphone Addiction Index (SAI), and the General Well-Being Schedule (GWB).
Key Insights: The Compensation Mechanism
- The "Compensation" Mechanism: The findings support the compensation theory of addiction. Adolescents who feel internal "disharmony" experience mental distress and turn to smartphones as an anonymous, stimulating space to release tension and compensate for a lack of real-world well-being.
- Subjective Well-Being as a Bridge: The study confirms that well-being is a partial mediator. Internal inconsistency doesn't just cause addiction directly; it first erodes an adolescent's happiness, which frequently triggers the addictive behavior.
- The Gender Sensitivity Gap: A striking finding is that girls’ well-being and addiction levels are more sensitive to internal self-conflict. Because adolescent girls may be more emotionally perceptive, the "downward spiral" from internal conflict to addiction happens more rapidly for them than for boys.
Key Results
The analysis confirmed that self-consistency congruence is a significant predictor of smartphone addiction ($\beta = 0.3443, p < 0.01$). Subjective well-being accounted for 25.2% of the total effect of self-consistency on addiction.
Crucially, gender moderated these pathways. For girls, the negative impact of internal inconsistency on well-being ($\beta = -0.3757$) and the subsequent link between low well-being and addiction ($\beta = -0.6189$) were significantly steeper than for boys ($\beta = -0.2622$ and $\beta = -0.3948$, respectively).
Limitations and Future Work
Because the study is cross-sectional, it cannot definitively prove causality; longitudinal studies are needed to determine if low well-being precedes addiction. Additionally, the data relies on self-report questionnaires, which are susceptible to social desirability bias. Future research should include more diverse samples and explore specific types of smartphone use (e.g., social media vs. gaming) to see if the escape mechanism varies by content.
Summary updated