Selective Bias in the Collective Memory of News Public Opinion and Reflections on Governance: The Case of Watergate Scandal

Yang Gao, Haozhe MaBCP 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the media shapes "collective memory" through the lens of the Watergate scandal, arguing that historical narratives are not static but are selectively reconstructed over time. By analyzing how the U.S. press transitioned from reporting granular details to a broader "watchdog" myth, the authors draw parallels and lessons for contemporary Chinese social governance and public emergency management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the phenomenon of selective bias in collective memory. While we often think of history as a fixed record of facts, this paper argues that what the public "remembers" is actually a curated selection of events shaped by the media.

The core challenge is understanding how this selective memory influences the relationship between government power and public opinion. Using Watergate as a primary case study, the paper examines how the media's role as a "watchdog" is remembered and how those memories are later used—specifically within the context of Chinese journalism—to reflect on governance, administrative ethics, and the handling of public crises (like COVID-19).

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative historical and comparative analysis. Rather than using a specific computational algorithm, the authors utilize:

  • Case Study Analysis: A deep dive into the timeline and reporting of the Watergate scandal (1972–1974).
  • Chronological Categorization: Dividing the "memory" of Watergate into three distinct stages: the Investigation phase (1972-1974), the Cooling-off period (1975-1999), and the Extended News Coverage era (2000-2017).
  • Theoretical Framework: Applying theories of collective memory from sociologists like Maurice Halbwachs and Zhou Haiyan to explain how past events are reconstructed to reflect dominant social ideologies.
  • Comparative Reflection: Contrasting the "professionalism" of Western media with the "mouthpiece" role of Chinese media to discuss how both systems handle public emergencies.

Datasets

As a social science paper focused on historical analysis, it does not use a traditional "training set." Instead, it draws from:

  • Historical News Archives: Specifically reports from The Washington Post and The New York Times.
  • Academic Literature: Citing various Chinese and Western scholars on journalism, communication theory, and administrative ethics (e.g., Fangli Dang, Niu Yanhua, and Shen Guolin).
  • Governmental Records: References to the U.S. Senate investigative committees and the evolution of the Chinese government's press spokesperson system (from SARS in 2003 to the 2020 pandemic).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Memory is a Process of Selection: The authors argue that memory is an "ever-changing and active process" involving both recalling and intentional/unintentional forgetting. For example, while the original Watergate reporting focused heavily on complex campaign finance and money laundering, the "collective memory" has largely filtered these out, focusing instead on the abstract narrative of a president vs. the rule of law.
  • The "Transnational Journey" of Myths: The paper highlights how the Watergate narrative serves as a "narrative resource" for Chinese journalists. It is used not just as a story about America, but as a tool to clarify the boundaries of journalistic practice and "watchdog" duties within China.
  • Evolution of Crisis Communication: The paper notes a significant shift in Chinese governance. By comparing the response to SARS (2003) with COVID-19 (2020), the authors suggest that the Chinese government has increasingly adopted "press release" strategies—respecting the public's right to know while maintaining social stability—partially inspired by Western models of communication.
  • Journalistic Professionalism as a "Dominant Discourse": The Watergate scandal cemented the idea of "journalistic professionalism" (independence from authority) as a global standard, even if its application varies wildly between capitalist and socialist media systems.

Key Results

  • Identification of Memory Stages: The paper successfully maps the evolution of a scandal from a "minor story" to a "watershed event" that ended an era of U.S. politics.
  • Impact on Administrative Ethics: The authors conclude that Watergate triggered a global rethinking of civil service ethics, providing a blueprint for how governments (including China's) can construct professional ethics for administrative teams through legislation and supervision.
  • Governance Reflections: The study finds that while Western media is "decentralized and individualistic," Chinese media acts as a "bridge" between the state and the people. The "result" of this comparison is a call for Chinese media to improve its quality as a "watchman of society" while remaining the "mouthpiece of the Party."

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is primarily theoretical and descriptive. It lacks quantitative data or empirical surveys that measure how the public's memory has actually shifted (e.g., through sentiment analysis of social media or public polling).

Additionally, while it discusses the "selective bias" of the media, it doesn't deeply explore the role of digital algorithms or social media in accelerating or distorting this collective memory in the 21st century. Future research could apply these collective memory theories to "digital-native" scandals to see if the "cooling-off" periods still exist in an era of 24/7 news cycles.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Watergate scandal is one of the most disgraceful political scandals in American history, and its impact on the history of the United States itself and on the international press as a whole has been lasting. Indeed, the American press, represented by the Washington Post, played a pioneering role in exposing the Watergate scandal. In this context, media journalists showed a clear bias towards collective memory choices. On the one hand, in the face of strong government pressure, journalists continued to report the facts and to uncover the truth with objectivity, truthfulness and accuracy. On the other hand, as the years passed, the media's understanding of the Watergate scandal updated and changed, and collective memory did not remain unchanged. For contemporary China, the prominence of the press in fulfilling its role as a watchdog over the government leads us to reflect on the ability of the media, journalists and civil servants to carry out their duties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2023selective,
  author = {Yang Gao and Haozhe Ma},
  title = {{Selective Bias in the Collective Memory of News Public Opinion and Reflections on Governance: The Case of Watergate Scandal}},
  booktitle = {BCP},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54691/bcpssh.v21i.3427},
}
Figure