Selection of high-quality sperm with thousands of parallel channels

Mohammad Simchi, Jason Riordon, Jae Bem You, Yihe Wang, Sa Xiao, Alexander Lagunov, Thomas Hannam, Keith Jarvi, Reza Nosrati, David SintonLab 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Sperm selection is essential for successful fertilization and embryo development. Current clinical sperm selection methods are labor-intensive and lack the selectivity required to isolate high-quality sperm. Microfluidic sperm selection approaches have shown promise but present a trade-off between the quality and quantity of selected sperm - clinicians demand both. The structure of the female reproductive tract helps to isolate a sufficient quantity of high-quality sperm for fertilization with densely folded epithelium that provides a multitude of longitudinally oriented pathways that guide sperm toward the fertilization site. Here, a three-dimensionally structured sperm selection device is presented that levers this highly parallelized in vivo mechanism for in vitro sperm selection. The device is inserted in a test tube atop 1 mL of raw semen and provides 6500 channels that isolate ∼100 000 high-DNA-integrity sperm for assisted reproduction. In side-by-side clinical testing, the developed approach outperforms the best current clinical methods by improving the DNA integrity of the selected sperm subpopulation up to 95%. Also, the device streamlines clinical workflow, reducing the time required for sperm preparation 3-fold. This single-tube, single-step sperm preparation approach promises to improve both the economics and outcomes of assisted reproduction practices, especially in cases with significant male-factors.

The Challenge of Sperm Selection

In assisted reproduction technologies such as In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) and Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI), the selection of a single high-quality sperm cell is a critical determinant of pregnancy success. Current clinical standards, including Swim-up (SU) and Density Gradient Centrifugation (DGC), are labor-intensive and involve multiple centrifugation steps. These steps can generate reactive oxygen species, leading to physical damage of the sperm DNA.

While microfluidic "sperm-on-a-chip" technologies have emerged as a gentler alternative, they have historically faced a significant trade-off: high selectivity (quality) often comes at the cost of low yield (quantity). Clinicians require both high DNA integrity and a sufficient number of motile sperm for successful fertilization procedures.

Biomimetic Design and Device Architecture

To overcome the limitations of planar microfluidic devices, researchers took inspiration from the human female reproductive tract. The fallopian tubes feature a densely folded epithelium that creates microgrooves and corners, which guide sperm through boundary-following navigation.

Figure 1: Biomimetic sperm selection device design and workflow.

The developed device replicates this environment using a novel 3D architecture. The fabrication process involves micro-scratching triangular v-grooves into a thin polyethylene terephthalate (PET) film using a standard cutting plotter. This patterned film is then rolled around a glass tube to create a 3D matrix containing over 6,500 parallel channels and approximately 23,000 interior corners. A "stepped" entrance at the bottom of the device maximizes the contact area (960 mm²) with the raw semen, ensuring a high throughput of motile sperm into the selection channels.

Experimental Validation and Clinical Results

The device was tested using both human donor samples and clinical patient samples from individuals facing various male-factor infertility challenges. The results demonstrated that the 3D rolled architecture successfully breaks the quality-quantity trade-off:

  • Superior DNA Integrity: In clinical testing, the device improved DNA integrity by up to 95% compared to raw samples, consistently maintaining a DNA Fragmentation Index (DFI) below 5%.
  • High Yield: The device isolated approximately 100,000 high-quality sperm from 1 mL of raw semen—an 8 to 10-fold increase over previous high-selectivity microfluidic designs.
  • Workflow Efficiency: The single-step, gravity-and-motility-based process reduced total clinical preparation time 3-fold, eliminating the need for damaging centrifugation steps.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By parallelizing the selective mechanisms of the female reproductive tract, this 3D microfluidic device provides a scalable solution for isolating high-quality sperm. The ability to maintain high DNA integrity even in poor-quality raw samples suggests significant potential for improving outcomes in difficult male-factor infertility cases. While initial clinical results are promising, future work will focus on larger cohort studies to correlate this improved selection method with live birth rates, the ultimate metric of success in assisted reproduction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sperm selection is essential for successful fertilization and embryo development. Current clinical sperm selection methods are labor-intensive and lack the selectivity required to isolate high-quality sperm. Microfluidic sperm selection approaches have shown promise but present a trade-off between the quality and quantity of selected sperm - clinicians demand both. The structure of the female reproductive tract helps to isolate a sufficient quantity of high-quality sperm for fertilization with densely folded epithelium that provides a multitude of longitudinally oriented pathways that guide sperm toward the fertilization site. Here, a three-dimensionally structured sperm selection device is presented that levers this highly parallelized in vivo mechanism for in vitro sperm selection. The device is inserted in a test tube atop 1 mL of raw semen and provides 6500 channels that isolate ∼100 000 high-DNA-integrity sperm for assisted reproduction. In side-by-side clinical testing, the developed approach outperforms the best current clinical methods by improving the DNA integrity of the selected sperm subpopulation up to 95%. Also, the device streamlines clinical workflow, reducing the time required for sperm preparation 3-fold. This single-tube, single-step sperm preparation approach promises to improve both the economics and outcomes of assisted reproduction practices, especially in cases with significant male-factors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{simchi2021selection,
  author = {Mohammad Simchi and Jason Riordon and Jae Bem You and Yihe Wang and Sa Xiao and Alexander Lagunov and Thomas Hannam and Keith Jarvi and Reza Nosrati and David Sinton},
  title = {{Selection of high-quality sperm with thousands of parallel channels}},
  booktitle = {Lab},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1039/d0lc01182g},
}
Figure