Seismic Performance Evaluation of Externally Reinforced Panel Water Tank Using Shaking Table Tests

Se‐Jun Park, Seong-Hwan Won, Moon-Seock Choi, Sang‐Hyo Kim, Jin‐Hwan CheungJournal of the Earthquake Engineering Society of Korea 2013 · DOI

Abstract

In this study, an externally reinforced structural system for SMC (Sheet Molding Compound) panel water tanks, designed according to Japanese design codes, was evaluated for seismic performance. A test tank measuring 3m long, 2m wide, and 3m high was subjected to shaking table tests. Experimental results revealed that measured hydrodynamic pressures were approximately 70% of the values predicted by the Japanese design code, likely due to the convex shape effect of the unit panels. Analytical results from an externally reinforced system model showed good agreement with experimental data. This suggests that with proper hydrodynamic pressure estimation, the proposed analytical model is a robust design tool, and current Japanese codes provide a conservative, safe design for SMC panel water tank external frames.

Introduction

Maintaining functional water supplies for firefighting and drinking is a critical post-earthquake requirement. However, regions like Korea often lack specific seismic design standards for modular panel-type water tanks, frequently relying on standards intended for rigid, cylindrical structures. These do not accurately reflect the behavior of flexible, rectangular, externally reinforced tanks. This research evaluates an external reinforcement system designed under the more mature Japanese codes to determine its efficacy in withstanding significant seismic loads, specifically focusing on the hydrodynamic "sloshing" forces exerted against tank walls.

Methodology

The study utilized a dual-track approach combining experimental testing and finite element analysis (FEA).

Shaking Table Experiments

A 3m x 2m x 3m test tank was constructed using SMC panels and an SM490 high-strength steel external frame. The assembly was mounted on a 3-degree-of-freedom shaking table and subjected to artificial seismic waves with a 0.154g base acceleration. Tests were conducted across various scenarios with varying water levels (up to 2.5m) and excitation intensities reaching 200% of the design acceleration.

Analytical Modeling

Finite element modeling was performed using MIDAS software. SMC panels were represented by 4-node plate elements, while the reinforcement frames were modeled as 2-node beam elements. The analysis focused on the distribution of hydrodynamic pressure across the structure, accounting for pressures on both side walls and internal partitions.

Conceptual distribution of hydrodynamic pressure on the side walls and internal partitions of the water tank.

Results and Discussion

Hydrodynamic Pressure and the "Convex Effect"

A primary finding was that measured hydrodynamic pressures were significantly lower—approximately 70%—than those predicted by the Japanese design code. This discrepancy is attributed to the convex (curved) geometry of the SMC panels, which appears to dissipate kinetic energy more effectively than flat-walled alternatives.

Measured hydrodynamic water pressure distribution across different water levels and tank heights.

Structural Integrity and Code Conservatism

The Japanese design code, based on Housner’s rigid-body theory, proved to be conservative. At the design acceleration (0.154g), the maximum measured stress in the reinforcement was 68 MPa, while the analytical model predicted 85 MPa—approximately 25% higher. Even at 200% of the design seismic load, the system maintained structural integrity with no leakage or failure, and stresses remained well below the 190 MPa allowable limit for SM490 steel. The relationship between seismic acceleration and structural stress remained nearly linear, indicating predictable behavior under extreme loads.

Conclusion

The proposed external reinforcement system successfully met safety requirements for design ground accelerations up to 0.4g. While the Japanese code provides a safe design basis, its inherent conservatism suggests opportunities for more economical, optimized structures. Future research should focus on quantifying the pressure-reducing effects of convex panel shapes and developing localized seismic standards that accurately reflect the unique dynamics of modular panel tanks.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, an externally reinforced structural system for SMC(Sheet Molding Compound) panel water tank, designed according to the Japanese design code, is experimented to evaluate its seismic performance. The test tank is 3m long, 2m wide and 3m high, considering the capacity and size of the shaking table. The measured hydrodynamic pressures are found to be approximately 70% of the Japanese design code values. It may be partially due to the convex shape effect of the unit panels. The analytical results of externally reinforced system based on the measured dynamic water pressures are found in good agreement with the test results. If the design hydrodynamic pressures are estimated properly, the proposed analytical model for the externally reinforced water tank becomes a useful design tool and the Japanese design code is found to provide a safe design for the external frames of SMC panel water tank.
BibTeX
@article{park2013seismic,
  author = {Se‐Jun Park and Seong-Hwan Won and Moon-Seock Choi and Sang‐Hyo Kim and Jin‐Hwan Cheung},
  title = {{Seismic Performance Evaluation of Externally Reinforced Panel Water Tank Using Shaking Table Tests}},
  journal = {Journal of the Earthquake Engineering Society of Korea},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5000/eesk.2013.17.4.151},
}
Figure