Seismic performance analysis of a submerged “coal pillar–concrete” combined dam body under wet-dry cycles

Mingbo Chi, Hongfei Duan, Fuqin Xiong, Shuai Zhang, Honglin Liu, Nanyun Wang, Hongzhi Wang, Xianwei Meng, Jianchao ChengInternational Journal of Coal Science & Technology 2025 · DOI

Abstract

As a new type of underground water conservancy project, underground reservoirs in coal mines play a crucial role in protecting and utilizing water resources during mining operations. The safety and reliability of the dam body are key to this technology. Focusing on the basic situation of the Shendong 2–2 coal seam coal mine underground reservoir, this study analyzes the changes in the stability of the dam body during reservoir operation under the combined effects of seismic activity and water immersion. By comprehensively analyzing the changes in stress, displacement, and other parameters when the combined dam body (coal pillar + concrete) fails, the research identifies the locations and causes of damage to the dam body under the impact of earthquakes. The results indicate that under water storage conditions, the coal pillar undergoes displacement and eventually becomes unstable upon reaching its limit strength. Water immersion reduces the mechanical strength of the coal pillar by roughly 70%. The “coal pillar–concrete” combined dam body can resist earthquakes of magnitude 10 and above (1.2 g). This research provides a reference for the stability analysis and monitoring of underground reservoirs and other underground projects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As coal mines move toward sustainable "green mining," underground reservoirs are being built in mined-out areas (goafs) to store and purify water. These reservoirs rely on a hybrid dam system: natural coal pillars left in place, connected by man-made concrete walls.

Conceptual model of underground reservoirs (NO.1–NO.4) integrated into coal mine strata.

The challenge is that these structures operate in a brutal environment. They are subjected to "wet-dry cycles" as water levels fluctuate, which weakens the coal. Simultaneously, they must withstand dynamic loads from regional earthquakes and mining-induced tremors. Until now, the combined effect of long-term water immersion and seismic activity on these specific hybrid structures wasn't well understood, creating a gap in safety protocols for underground water conservancy.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-pronged approach to bridge theory and practice:

  • Similar Simulation Experiments: Scale models (1:150 for water pressure tests and 1:10 for seismic tests) were used to observe failure patterns in a controlled environment.
  • Vibration Table Testing: Using the El Centro seismic wave, researchers subjected the dam models to increasing peak accelerations (from 0.1g to 1.5g) to simulate extreme earthquake conditions.
  • Mechanical Testing (Wet-Dry Cycles): Coal samples were subjected to five cycles of 4-day immersion and 2-day drying to measure the degradation of compressive strength and wave speed.
  • Advanced Monitoring: Digital image correlation (speckle image processing) and internal pressure sensors tracked real-time stress and displacement during failure.
  • Pseudo-static Analysis: A theoretical mechanical model was developed to calculate shear deformation and stress distribution, validated against experimental results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Clamping" Advantage: Unlike surface dams, which suffer from a "whip effect" (where the top sways violently), underground dams are clamped by the roof and floor strata. This significantly enhances their seismic performance.
  • The Material Mismatch: Concrete is much stiffer than coal. During an earthquake, the concrete section moves about 1.14 times faster than the coal pillar. This differential acceleration creates intense stress concentrations at the interface, making the connection point the most likely place for the dam to fail.
  • Water as a Softener: Water immersion physically and chemically degrades the coal. The researchers found a strength reduction factor of 0.28–0.30, meaning the coal loses roughly 70% of its effective strength when submerged.
  • Failure Precursors: The study found that displacement changes occur significantly later than stress increases. Therefore, monitoring horizontal displacement is a more reliable "early warning" signal for dam instability than stress monitoring alone.
Experimental data showing the relationship between stress, displacement, and the critical point of dam failure.

Key Results

  • Seismic Resilience: The "coal pillar–concrete" dam can resist earthquakes of magnitude 10 and above (up to 1.2g acceleration) while remaining in an elastic state.
  • Storage Limits: For a 15-meter-thick coal pillar, the maximum safe water storage height is 50 meters. Beyond this, the damage to the coal pillar becomes irreversible.
  • Stress Distribution: Stress follows a "bottom > middle > top" pattern. During an earthquake, the stress peak on the submerged side of the dam is approximately 10% higher than on the dry side.
  • Model Accuracy: The theoretical shear deformation model matched experimental results with an error margin of only 21%, providing a viable tool for engineers to predict dam behavior.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study focuses on a specific coal seam (Shendong 2–2) and uses a simplified 1:10 scale for seismic testing. Real-world geology is often more fractured and heterogeneous than laboratory models. Future research could explore long-term creep deformation over decades of constant water pressure, testing against different types of seismic waves, and developing automated early-warning systems that integrate the displacement "precursor" data identified in this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract As a new type of underground water conservancy project, underground reservoirs in coal mines play a crucial role in protecting and utilizing water resources during mining operations. The safety and reliability of the dam body are key to this technology. Focusing on the basic situation of the Shendong 2–2 coal seam coal mine underground reservoir, this paper uses mechanical analysis, mechanical testing and other methods. From the perspective of the dam body stability under the combined effects of seismic activity and water immersion, this study analyzes the changes in the stability of the dam body during reservoir operation. It focuses on the dynamic impacts of earthquakes and mining-induced tremors, along with the long-term effects of water immersion. By comprehensively analyzing the changes in stress, displacement, and other parameters when the combined dam body (coal pillar + concrete) fails, the research identifies the locations and causes of damage to the dam body under the impact of earthquakes. It also proposes precursor information and characteristics of dam body instability under long-term water immersion and dynamic load effects. The results indicate that under water storage conditions (horizontal stress combined with water immersion), the coal pillar undergoes displacement and eventually becomes unstable, facturing upon reaching its limit strength. Water immersion reduces the mechanical strength of the coal pillar. For a coal pillar 15 m thick, the maximum water storage height is 50 m. It is recommended that displacement changes be used as precursor information for dam body monitoring and early warning during the actual water storage process. The “coal pillar–concrete” combined dam body can resist earthquakes of magnitude 10 and above (1.2 g). During earthquakes, the bottom and middle parts of the dam are the main locations of stress concentration, with the stress change pattern being bottom > middle > top. Due to the difference in material properties between the concrete and coal pillar dam bodies, the difference in acceleration between the two during earthquakes is about 1.14 times, causing the bottom of the coal pillar to be the first to break. Additionally, the stress peak on the submerged side body during an earthquake is about 10% higher than that on the front. This research is important for the stability analysis and monitoring and early warning of underground reservoirs in coal mines and provides a reference for the stability of other underground projects.
BibTeX
@article{chi2025seismic,
  author = {Mingbo Chi and Hongfei Duan and Fuqin Xiong and Shuai Zhang and Honglin Liu and Nanyun Wang and Hongzhi Wang and Xianwei Meng and Jianchao Cheng},
  title = {{Seismic performance analysis of a submerged “coal pillar–concrete” combined dam body under wet-dry cycles}},
  journal = {International Journal of Coal Science \& Technology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/s40789-025-00816-y},
}
Figure