Seiberg duality in Chern-Simons theories with fundamental and adjoint matter

Vasilis NiarchosJournal of High Energy Physics 2008 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper explores Seiberg duality in 3D N=2 Chern-Simons gauge theories with matter in both fundamental and adjoint representations. By leveraging string theory brane constructions, the authors propose and provide evidence for a duality that relates theories with different gauge groups and matter content, offering a powerful tool for understanding strongly coupled 3D gauge theories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of quantum field theories in the infrared (IR) is a fundamental challenge in theoretical physics. For 4D gauge theories with N=1 supersymmetry, tools like Seiberg duality, NSVZ beta-function, and a-maximization have been instrumental in this endeavor. However, analogous progress in 3D supersymmetric gauge theories has been slower. This paper focuses on 3D N=2 Chern-Simons (CS) gauge theories, which are particularly interesting due to their connections to condensed matter systems and their role as solvable toy models. The specific problem addressed is to extend the concept of Seiberg duality, which relates different gauge theories with the same matter content but different gauge groups and couplings, to include matter in the adjoint representation, a feature present in many physically relevant theories.

Methods

The primary method employed is the use of string theory brane constructions. The authors realize various 3D N=2 Chern-Simons gauge theories as the low-energy effective field theories on D3-branes suspended between different types of branes (NS5, D5, and (n',k) fivebranes) in Type IIB string theory. This geometric picture provides an intuitive way to understand the dynamics of these theories, including their matter content and gauge groups.

Specifically, they:

  • Construct the "electric" theory: A configuration of D3-branes between NS5 and (n',k) fivebranes is used to describe a U(N) gauge theory with N=2 supersymmetry, Nf pairs of fundamental chiral multiplets, and two adjoint chiral multiplets.
  • Deform the brane configuration: By moving branes and performing reconnections, they generate a new brane configuration.
  • Identify the "magnetic" theory: This new configuration is argued to describe a Seiberg-dual theory with a different gauge group (U(nNf + nk - Nc)) but the same N=2 supersymmetry and a similar matter content, including adjoint fields.
  • Analyze superpotentials: The brane configurations naturally lead to specific superpotentials for the adjoint fields, which are crucial for breaking conformal invariance and generating RG flows.
  • Compare moduli spaces and symmetries: The authors verify the duality by showing that the moduli spaces of vacua and the global symmetries of the electric and magnetic theories match.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical exploration and does not involve empirical data or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seiberg duality extends to adjoint matter in 3D CS theories: The central finding is the proposal and evidence for a Seiberg duality that includes theories with adjoint chiral superfields, generalizing previous results. This is significant because adjoint matter is common in many physical systems.
  • Brane constructions provide a powerful intuition: The string theory realization of these gauge theories offers a geometric and intuitive understanding of their properties, including the origin of gauge groups, matter content, and superpotentials.
  • Superpotentials for adjoint fields are crucial: The paper highlights how superpotentials for adjoint fields, arising from brane configurations, are essential for breaking conformal invariance and determining the IR physics. The nature of these superpotentials (e.g., classically relevant, marginal, or irrelevant) dictates the IR behavior.
  • "Dangerously irrelevant" operators: The authors propose that certain operators, like Tr X^(n+1) for n>3, which are classically irrelevant, might become relevant at strong coupling due to anomalous dimensions, a phenomenon known as "dangerously irrelevant." This is an intriguing conjecture that warrants further investigation.
  • Connection to condensed matter and string theory: The work reinforces the deep connections between 3D gauge theories, condensed matter physics (e.g., quantum Hall effect), and string theory.

Key Results

  • Postulation of a Seiberg duality: The paper proposes a duality between a U(N) Chern-Simons gauge theory with N=2 supersymmetry, Nf fundamental chiral multiplets, and one adjoint chiral multiplet, and a U(nNf + nk - Nc) Chern-Simons gauge theory with the same supersymmetry and matter content.
  • Consistency checks: The duality is supported by matching the dimensions of the moduli spaces of vacua and the global symmetries of the electric and magnetic theories.
  • Identification of superpotentials: Specific superpotentials for the adjoint fields are derived from the brane constructions, which are crucial for understanding the IR dynamics. For example, for a U(N) theory with one adjoint field X, the superpotential is found to be of the form W = (s0/(n+1)) Tr X^(n+1).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Singularity in brane motion: The authors acknowledge a potential concern for the validity of the duality arising from a singularity encountered when the branes move. While they assume this can be handled, a more rigorous treatment would be beneficial.
  • Case of two adjoint chiral superfields: The paper briefly mentions the case of two adjoint chiral superfields, which leads to fractional CS levels for non-abelian groups. This scenario requires further understanding and potentially extra interactions, which is left for future work.
  • Verification of "dangerously irrelevant" operators: The proposal that certain classically irrelevant operators are "dangerously irrelevant" needs explicit verification, which is currently lacking the necessary technology.
  • Understanding the IR physics for n > 2: For the superpotential Tr X^(n+1), the IR physics for n > 2 is not fully understood, especially for n=3 where the interaction is classically marginal and for n>3 where it's classically irrelevant. This remains an open area for research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{niarchos2008seiberg,
  author = {Vasilis Niarchos},
  title = {{Seiberg duality in Chern-Simons theories with fundamental and adjoint matter}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1088/1126-6708/2008/11/001},
}
Figure