Sediment Grain-Size Composition in the Permafrost Region of the Greater Khingan Range and Its Significance as a Material Source

Lixin Liu, Shuying Zang, Xiaodong Wu, Rui Liu, Tianrui Li, Jiaju Zhu, Li Sun, Shaoqiang Wu, Xingfeng Dong, Zihao ZhangLand 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a sophisticated grain-size analysis technique (parameterized end-member analysis) on sediment cores from China's Greater Khingan Range to reconstruct past winter monsoon strength and identify sediment sources. The findings reveal a cyclical pattern in monsoon activity over the last ~30,000 years, linking stronger monsoons to coarser sediment transport and potentially accelerating permafrost degradation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the history of permafrost and its response to climate change is crucial, especially in regions like the Greater Khingan Range, which are experiencing rapid warming. Permafrost degradation is influenced by soil physical properties, and grain-size distribution (GSD) is a key factor affecting soil stability and thermal behavior. While GSD provides insights into sedimentary sources and environmental changes, traditional methods struggle to fully capture the complexity of these distributions. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by using a more advanced technique to disentangle the various sources and transport mechanisms contributing to the sediments in this permafrost region, thereby providing a clearer picture of past climate and its impact on the landscape.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the application of parameterized end-member analysis (EMA). Unlike simpler statistical methods or curve-fitting techniques, EMA treats a sediment's GSD as a mixture of several distinct "end-member" (EM) components, each representing a specific source or transport process. The researchers used the Gen. Weibull function within the EMA framework, which is a parametric approach that offers advantages in separating mixed end-members and providing descriptive statistics.

The process involved:

  1. Collecting sediment cores: Four soil cores were extracted from the Greater Khingan Range, representing different vegetation types and permafrost conditions.
  2. Grain-size analysis: A laser particle analyzer was used to determine the GSD of samples from these cores.
  3. End-member modeling: The parameterized EMA method was applied to the GSD data to identify and quantify the contributions of different EM components. This involved determining the optimal number of EMs for each core and analyzing their characteristic particle sizes (mode, Mo).
  4. Radiocarbon dating: AMS radiocarbon dating was performed on selected samples to establish a chronological framework for the sediment cores.
  5. Elemental analysis: Al and Fe content was measured to provide geochemical context for the sediment sources.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of sediment grain-size distribution (GSD) data from four drilling cores (BJC-1, BJC-2, BJC-3, and HZ-1) collected from the Greater Khingan Range in northeastern China. These cores represent different permafrost conditions and vegetation types.

Additionally, the study utilized:

  • Radiocarbon dating data from the BETA Laboratory for chronological control.
  • Published data on windblown sediment from various regions (e.g., Xi'an loess, Harbin dust, Xifeng laterite) for comparative analysis of EM components.
  • Paleoclimate proxy data (e.g., temperature and humidity records from Baiyangdian and Ningjinbo lakes, Greenland ice core data, deep-sea oxygen isotope data) to correlate sediment composition with past climate changes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unmixing the complexity: EMA proved to be a powerful tool for dissecting the complex GSDs, revealing distinct sediment sources and transport mechanisms that simpler methods might miss.
  • Multiple sediment sources: The study identified several distinct end-member components, suggesting a combination of local and regional sources, including weathering/pedogenesis, wind transport (both high-altitude and low-altitude), and potentially flood plain contributions.
  • Winter monsoon as a driver: The research strongly links the strength of the winter monsoon to the characteristics of the deposited sediments, particularly the transport of coarser grain sizes.
  • Permafrost sensitivity: The findings highlight how changes in sediment composition, driven by climate shifts, can directly impact permafrost stability and degradation.

Key Results

  • End-member identification: Four to five end-member (EM) components were identified across the four cores.
  • EM1 (Mo: 1.26–1.66 µm) was attributed to weathering and pedogenesis.
  • EM2 (Mo: 4.37–5.01 µm) likely represents components transported by the upper westerly wind.
  • EM3 (Mo: 7.58 µm) and EM4 (Mo: 11.48 µm) were interpreted as wet and dry dust deposition, respectively.
  • DEM5 (Mo: 831.76 µm) was a large particle-size component, likely from rock weathering.
  • Winter monsoon reconstruction: Based on EM components and radiocarbon dating, the study reconstructed a weak-strong-weak-strong trend of the winter monsoon in the Greater Khingan Range since Marine Isotope Stage 3a (MIS 3a).
  • Climate-permafrost linkage: Stronger winter monsoons in the past were associated with the transport of coarser grain sizes, which can exacerbate permafrost degradation.
  • Regional variations: Sediment composition differed slightly between vegetation areas, with birch forests showing finer soils than larch forests.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EM model limitations: The authors acknowledge that due to the limitations of the EMA model, some end-members might not be completely separated, and the coupling of end-member distributions with abundances can complicate interpretation. For some cores, the distinction between near-source and local-source transport was challenging to resolve into distinct EMs.
  • Data gaps: Core A and D lacked detailed age data, limiting direct comparison with the dated cores for certain analyses.
  • Future directions: The study provides a scientific reference for understanding climate change and permafrost evolution in the region. Future work could involve expanding the spatial coverage of sampling, integrating more detailed paleoclimate proxies, and further refining EMA techniques to improve end-member separation and source attribution. The findings also underscore the need for addressing permafrost protection in the face of ongoing global warming and increased coarse sediment transport.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sediment grain-size distribution (GSD) provides rich information about sedimentary sources and can potentially do the same with regard to environmental and climatic changes. However, neither traditional descriptive statistics nor curving-fitting methods can fully address its complexity. We selected the Greater Khingan Range in northeastern China as the study area and used parameterized end-member analysis (EMA) of the GSD of four drilling cores to extract different end-member (EM) components. The results show that EM1 (mode particle size (Mo): 1.26–1.66 μm) originates from weathering and pedogenesis. The EMs with Mo values of 4.37–5.01 μm represent components transported by the upper westerly wind. EMs with Mo values of 7.58 μm and 11.48 μm represent wet dust deposition and dry dust deposition. The wind transport of particles in winter consists of low-level near-source transport and local-source transport (possibly from the flood plain of the Amur River). Due to the limitations of the EM model, the two sources have one or two EM components: AEM3 + AEM4, BEM3 + BEM4, CEM4, and DEM4. DEM5 is the only large particle-size component and may represent coarse-grained detritus generated via rock weathering. The components related to the winter monsoon and the 14C dating data suggest a weak-strong-weak-strong trend of the winter monsoon since the Marine Isotope Stage 3a (MIS 3a). Our results suggest that the strengthening of the winter monsoons in the previous few thousand years has caused the transportation of coarser grain sizes and further exacerbated permafrost degradation, providing a scientific reference for understanding climate change and the formation and evolution of permafrost in the Greater Khingan Mountains since the MIS 3a.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023sediment,
  author = {Lixin Liu and Shuying Zang and Xiaodong Wu and Rui Liu and Tianrui Li and Jiaju Zhu and Li Sun and Shaoqiang Wu and Xingfeng Dong and Zihao Zhang},
  title = {{Sediment Grain-Size Composition in the Permafrost Region of the Greater Khingan Range and Its Significance as a Material Source}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/land12091728},
}
Figure