Security versus Reliability Analysis of Opportunistic Relaying

YuLong Zou, Xianbin Wang, Weiming Shen, Lajos HanzoarXiv 2013 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the fundamental trade-off between security and reliability in wireless communications against eavesdropping. They propose an Opportunistic Relay Selection (ORS) scheme that significantly improves this trade-off, achieving near-perfect security and reliability simultaneously by leveraging multiple relays.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless communications, by their very nature, are susceptible to eavesdropping. While traditional security methods like encryption add overhead and can be broken, Physical Layer Security (PLS) offers a more fundamental approach by exploiting the physics of wireless channels. However, a key challenge in PLS is the inherent trade-off between security and reliability. To improve reliability (e.g., by increasing transmit power), one often compromises security (making it easier for an eavesdropper to intercept). Conversely, enhancing security can degrade reliability. This paper aims to quantify this Security-Reliability Tradeoff (SRT) for direct transmissions and then proposes a novel relay-assisted scheme to overcome this limitation, particularly in fading environments.

Methods

The authors first analyze the SRT for a conventional direct transmission scenario between a source (S), destination (D), and an eavesdropper (E) in Rayleigh fading channels. They quantify security by the intercept probability (IP) – the probability that an eavesdropper can decode the message – and reliability by the outage probability (OP) – the probability that the destination cannot receive the message.

To improve the SRT, they introduce an Opportunistic Relay Selection (ORS) scheme. In this setup, multiple relay nodes (RNs) assist the communication. The core idea is that the source transmits to all RNs, and only those RNs that successfully decode the message forward it. Crucially, the scheme selects the "best" relay (the one with the highest channel capacity to the destination) to relay the signal. This approach aims to leverage the diversity offered by multiple relays to enhance both security and reliability. The analysis involves deriving closed-form expressions for the IP and OP of the ORS scheme, considering both Decode-and-Forward (DF) and Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relaying protocols (though the analysis focuses on DF).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated channel models (Rayleigh fading) and theoretical analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inherent Trade-off: Direct transmission in wireless channels inherently faces a security-reliability trade-off. Increasing transmit power or decreasing data rate improves reliability but degrades security, and vice-versa.
  • PLS as a Solution: Physical Layer Security offers a promising avenue to enhance security by exploiting channel characteristics, but it still grapples with the SRT.
  • ORS for SRT Improvement: The proposed Opportunistic Relay Selection (ORS) scheme effectively mitigates the SRT. By using multiple relays and selecting the best one, the system can achieve significantly better security and reliability than direct transmission.
  • Scalability of ORS: The benefits of ORS are amplified as the number of relays ($N$) increases. As $N$ approaches infinity, both the intercept probability and outage probability can be driven to near zero, offering near-perfect security and reliability.
  • Channel Gains Matter: The performance of the ORS scheme is influenced by the average channel gains of the main links (S-D, S-R, R-D) and the wiretap links (S-E, R-E). The ratio of these gains (MER) plays a significant role.

Key Results

  • The paper derives analytical expressions for the intercept probability (IP) and outage probability (OP) for both direct transmission and the ORS scheme in Rayleigh fading channels.
  • Numerical results demonstrate that the ORS scheme consistently outperforms direct transmission in terms of SRT, achieving lower IP for a given OP, and vice-versa.
  • As the number of relays ($N$) increases, the ORS scheme shows substantial improvements. For instance, with $N=4$, the ORS scheme is shown to be superior to direct transmission.
  • The study shows that as $N \to \infty$, the ORS scheme can achieve an outage probability that approaches zero for a given tolerable intercept probability, and conversely, an intercept probability that approaches zero for a given tolerable outage probability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Source, Single Destination, Single Eavesdropper: The current analysis is limited to a single source, destination, and eavesdropper scenario.
  • Rayleigh Fading: The analysis is primarily conducted for Rayleigh fading channels.
  • Idealized Assumptions: The paper assumes perfect channel state information (CSI) for relay selection and ideal conditions for relay decoding.

The authors suggest future work to extend the analysis to more general scenarios, including multi-source, multi-destination, and multi-eavesdropper situations. They also propose exploring cooperative beamforming as a technique to further enhance security by constructively interfering at legitimate receivers and destructively at eavesdroppers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Physical-layer security is emerging as a promising paradigm of securing wireless communications against eavesdropping between legitimate users, when the main link spanning from source to destination has better propagation conditions than the wiretap link from source to eavesdropper. In this paper, we identify and analyze the tradeoffs between the security and reliability of wireless communications in the presence of eavesdropping attacks. Typically, the reliability of the main link can be improved by increasing the source's transmit power (or decreasing its date rate) to reduce the outage probability, which unfortunately increases the risk that an eavesdropper succeeds in intercepting the source message through the wiretap link, since the outage probability of the wiretap link also decreases when a higher transmit power (or lower date rate) is used. We characterize the security-reliability tradeoffs (SRT) of conventional direct transmission from source to destination in the presence of an eavesdropper, where the security and reliability are quantified in terms of the intercept probability by an eavesdropper and the outage probability experienced at the destination, respectively. In order to improve the SRT, we then propose opportunistic relay selection (ORS) and quantify the attainable SRT improvement upon increasing the number of relays. It is shown that given the maximum tolerable intercept probability, the outage probability of our ORS scheme approaches zero for $N \to \infty$, where $N$ is the number of relays. Conversely, given the maximum tolerable outage probability, the intercept probability of our ORS scheme tends to zero for $N \to \infty$.
BibTeX
@misc{zou2013security,
  author = {YuLong Zou and Xianbin Wang and Weiming Shen and Lajos Hanzo},
  title = {{Security versus Reliability Analysis of Opportunistic Relaying}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1311.6020},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1311.6020},
}
Figure