Secrecy Wireless Information and Power Transfer in Fading Wiretap Channel

Hong Xing, Liang Liu, Rui ZhangIEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology 2014

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of secure wireless communication in systems that simultaneously transmit both information and power (SWIPT). They propose a novel "artificial noise" (AN) strategy that helps protect information from eavesdroppers while still allowing energy receivers to harvest power, and demonstrate its effectiveness in improving secrecy rates and reducing outage probabilities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer (SWIPT) is a promising technology where a single radio signal can deliver both data and energy to devices. However, a critical security vulnerability arises: the energy receivers (ERs), designed to harvest power, might also inadvertently eavesdrop on the confidential information intended for information receivers (IRs). This is particularly concerning because ERs are often strategically placed closer to the transmitter to maximize energy harvesting, making them ideal eavesdropping points. The paper addresses this by developing a transmission scheme that balances the need for secure information delivery to IRs with the requirement for efficient energy harvesting by ERs, all within the context of fading wireless channels.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in an artificial noise (AN) aided transmission scheme. Here's how it works:

  • Power Splitting: The transmitter splits its total power into two components: one for the confidential information signal and another for the AN.
  • AN Design: The AN is specifically designed to interfere with the ER, making it harder for them to decode the information. Crucially, the IR is assumed to be able to perfectly cancel this AN (e.g., through a pre-shared "key" or known channel information), effectively ignoring it. The ER, however, cannot cancel the AN.
  • Optimization: The paper formulates two optimization problems:
  • Minimizing Secrecy Outage Probability: For delay-limited transmission, the goal is to minimize the probability that the secrecy rate falls below a target.
  • Maximizing Ergodic Secrecy Capacity (ESC): For no-delay-limited transmission, the goal is to maximize the average achievable secrecy rate.
  • Constraints: Both problems are subject to practical constraints: average and peak power limits at the transmitter, and an average energy harvesting requirement at the ER.
  • Solutions: The formulated problems are non-convex. The authors propose:
  • Optimal Solutions: Using Lagrange duality and sub-gradient methods to find the theoretically best power allocations and AN strategies.
  • Suboptimal Solutions: Employing alternating optimization techniques for lower computational complexity, iteratively optimizing power allocations and power splitting ratios.
  • Benchmark Schemes: Two baseline schemes are considered for comparison: one with no AN, and another where AN is used but cannot be canceled by the IR.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation-based evaluation using synthetic channel models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AN as a Double Agent: The AN is ingeniously used not only to jam potential eavesdroppers (ERs) but also to contribute to energy transfer, making the SWIPT system more efficient.
  • IR's AN Cancellation is Key: The assumption that the IR can perfectly cancel the AN is critical. This allows the IR to receive the information signal cleanly while the ER is still disrupted by the AN, significantly enhancing secrecy.
  • Fading Channels are Exploitable: The paper demonstrates how fading, often seen as a challenge, can be leveraged to improve secrecy performance, particularly in minimizing outage probabilities.
  • Trade-offs are Quantifiable: The work provides a clear framework (Outage-Energy and Rate-Energy regions) to visualize and quantify the trade-offs between secrecy performance and energy harvesting capabilities.
  • Suboptimal Solutions are Practical: The proposed suboptimal algorithms offer a good balance between performance and computational complexity, making them suitable for real-world implementations.

Key Results

  • Improved Secrecy Performance: The proposed AN-aided scheme significantly outperforms benchmark schemes (NoAN, NoCancel) in terms of both secrecy outage probability and ergodic secrecy capacity. For instance, in one scenario, the secrecy outage probability was reduced from over 98% to less than 5% for a given harvested power.
  • Close-to-Optimal Suboptimal Solutions: The suboptimal algorithms achieve performance very close to the optimal solutions, especially in scenarios with high SNRs.
  • Fixed AN Ratio Performance: A simple "Fixed-ā" scheme (uniform AN power splitting) with ā=0.5 performed surprisingly well, especially when IR and ER were at similar distances, suggesting that a balanced AN strategy can be effective.
  • Impact of Distance: When the ER is closer to the transmitter than the IR, the performance gap between the proposed schemes and the NoAN/NoCancel schemes becomes even more pronounced, highlighting the importance of AN in such configurations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Perfect AN Cancellation Assumption: The assumption of perfect AN cancellation at the IR is an idealization. In reality, imperfect cancellation might occur, which could affect performance.
  • Simplified System Model: The paper considers a basic three-node (Tx, IR, ER) wiretap channel. More complex scenarios with multiple IRs and ERs, or different antenna configurations (MIMO), would require further investigation.
  • Channel State Information (CSI): The paper assumes perfect CSI at the transmitter. Practical systems often deal with imperfect CSI, which could be a direction for future research.
  • AN Key Distribution Complexity: While the paper mentions a PHY-layer key distribution method for AN cancellation, the practical implementation and overhead of such a scheme are not deeply explored.

The authors suggest future work could explore more complex network topologies, imperfect CSI scenarios, and practical AN cancellation mechanisms to further enhance the robustness and applicability of their proposed SWIPT secrecy techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

Simultaneous wireless information and power transfer (SWIPT) has recently drawn significant interests for its dual use of radio signals to provide wireless data and energy access at the same time. However, a challenging secrecy communication problem arises in the SWIPT system since the messages sent to information receivers (IRs) may be eavesdropped by energy receivers (ERs), which are presumed to receive energy from the same signals broadcast by the transmitter. To tackle this problem, we propose in this paper an artificial noise (AN) aided transmission scheme to facilitate the secrecy information transmission to IRs and yet meet the energy harvesting requirement for ERs, under the assumption that the AN can be cancelled at IRs but not at ERs. Specifically, the proposed scheme splits the power at the transmitter into two parts, to send the confidential message to the IR and an AN to interfere with the ER against eavesdropping, respectively. Under a simplified three-node wiretap channel setup, the transmit power allocations and power splitting ratios over fading channels are jointly optimized to maximize the average secrecy information rate for the IR subject to a combination of average and peak power constraints at the transmitter as well as an average energy harvesting constraint at the ER. The formulated problem is shown to be non-convex, for which we propose an efficient algorithm by iteratively optimizing the transmit power allocations and power splitting ratios over fading channels. Finally, the performance of the proposed scheme is evaluated by simulations and compared against other heuristic schemes in terms of achievable (secrecy) rate-energy trade-off.
BibTeX
@article{xing2014secrecy,
  author = {Hong Xing and Liang Liu and Rui Zhang},
  title = {{Secrecy Wireless Information and Power Transfer in Fading Wiretap Channel}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure