Second Quantized Mathieu Moonshine

Daniel Persson, Roberto VolpatoOpenReview 2023 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper constructs a "second quantized" version of generalized Mathieu moonshine, yielding Siegel modular forms with infinite product representations. These forms connect to string theory partition functions and reveal a "wall-crossing formula" that unifies different approaches to generalized moonshine.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the intricate relationship between mathematical structures arising in string theory and number theory, specifically focusing on "Mathieu moonshine" and its generalizations. Mathieu moonshine conjectures a deep connection between the symmetries of the K3 surface and the largest Mathieu group, M₂₄. This connection is expressed through mathematical objects called "twining genera," which are weak Jacobi forms.

The authors aim to generalize this concept by introducing a "second quantized" version of these twining genera. This generalization is motivated by similar constructions in string theory and aims to produce more robust mathematical objects – Siegel modular forms – that are expected to have direct physical interpretations as partition functions for certain BPS states in string theory. A key challenge is to bridge the gap between different existing frameworks for generalized moonshine, particularly the one involving twining genera and Mason's earlier work on eta-products.

Methods

The core of the paper involves constructing "second quantized twisted twining genera" (Ψg,h) from the existing twisted twining genera (φg,h) using a novel "twisted equivariant Hecke operator." This construction is inspired by similar "second quantization" procedures for elliptic genera. The resulting Ψg,h are then manipulated, by multiplying with a correction factor (Ag,h), to yield Siegel modular forms (Φg,h).

A crucial technique is the use of "multiplicative lifts," which transform Jacobi forms into modular forms via infinite product representations. The paper also establishes a "wall-crossing formula" by analyzing the behavior of Φg,h in a specific limit (z → 0), which connects them to Mason's generalized eta-products. The authors also leverage concepts from group cohomology, particularly 3-cocycles, which are essential for defining the twisted actions and ensuring consistency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unifying Framework: The paper successfully unifies two seemingly distinct approaches to generalized Mathieu moonshine: the one based on twining genera (weak Jacobi forms) and Mason's earlier work on eta-products. The "wall-crossing formula" acts as the bridge.
  • String Theory Connections: The constructed Siegel modular forms (Φg,h) are strongly suggested to have direct physical interpretations as partition functions for 1/4 BPS dyons in type II string theory on K3×T² or in heterotic CHL models. This provides a concrete link between abstract mathematics and physical phenomena.
  • "S-duality" and Relabeling: The paper reveals "S-duality" symmetries in the automorphic properties of Φg,h, which are related to the exchange of electric and magnetic charges in string theory. This duality is intricately linked to a "relabeling" phenomenon of group elements, highlighting a subtle aspect of the underlying symmetries.
  • Surprising Connection to Umbral Moonshine: A remarkable finding is that some of the derived Siegel modular forms coincide with multiplicative lifts of Jacobi forms in "umbral moonshine," suggesting a deeper, yet to be fully understood, relationship between these different moonshine phenomena.

Key Results

  • Construction of "second quantized twisted twining genera" (Ψg,h) and their transformation into Siegel modular forms (Φg,h) via a multiplicative lift.
  • Proof that these Φg,h are meromorphic Siegel modular forms for certain discrete subgroups of Sp(4, R).
  • Derivation of a "wall-crossing formula" that relates the limit z → 0 of Φg,h to Mason's generalized eta-products, thus establishing a link between two versions of generalized Mathieu moonshine.
  • Demonstration of "S-duality" transformations for Φg,h, which are interpreted as exchanges of electric and magnetic charges in string theory.
  • Identification of some Φg,h with known Siegel modular forms, including squares of weight-k Siegel modular forms and umbral Siegel modular forms, revealing connections to umbral moonshine.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Physical Interpretation: While strong evidence is presented for the physical interpretation of Φg,h as partition functions for 1/4 BPS dyons, a complete rigorous proof is beyond the scope of this paper.
  • General Modularity: The paper proves modularity for Φg,h under certain subgroups of Sp(4, R). Extending this analysis to all cases and determining the precise modular groups for all pairs (g,h) is suggested as future work.
  • Borcherds Product Type: It is noted that not all Φg,h are standard Borcherds products; some correspond to rescaled products. Further investigation into whether these include rescaled Borcherds products or more general forms is proposed.
  • Dyon Counting: The authors express hope that their results will have immediate applications to the understanding of dyon counting in CHL orbifolds and plan to investigate this relation in more detail in future publications.
  • Conjecture Verification: While some cases of Conjecture 5.1 (related to S-duality) are proven, a complete proof for all relevant groups is left for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the second quantized version of the twisted twining genera of generalized Mathieu moonshine, and prove that they give rise to Siegel modular forms with infinite product representations. Most of these forms are expected to have an interpretation as twisted partition functions counting 1/4 BPS dyons in type II superstring theory on K3\times T^2 or in heterotic CHL-models. We show that all these Siegel modular forms, independently of their possible physical interpretation, satisfy an "S-duality" transformation and a "wall-crossing formula". The latter reproduces all the eta-products of an older version of generalized Mathieu moonshine proposed by Mason in the '90s. Surprisingly, some of the Siegel modular forms we find coincide with the multiplicative (Borcherds) lifts of Jacobi forms in umbral moonshine.
BibTeX
@misc{persson2023second,
  author = {Daniel Persson and Roberto Volpato},
  title = {{Second Quantized Mathieu Moonshine}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {1312.0622},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.0622},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}

Loading related content...

Figure