Seat Safety and Female (Under)representation in the U.S. Congress

Akhil Rajan, Alexander Kustov, Maikol Cerda, Frances Rosenbluth, Ян Шапиро2021 · DOI

Abstract: Women have made significant strides toward equal representation within the U.S. Congress, but their seat share has mostly increased within the Democratic—but not Republican—Party. We argue that one driver of women’s underrepresentation among Republicans is the proliferation of safe seats. Because safe seats encourage ideological extremism in candidates and because women are stereotyped as more liberal than men, we expect women candidates to outperform men in safer Democratic seats but underperform men in safer Republican seats (relative to more competitive seats). Based on a new dataset linking all candidates for the U.S. House and their districts’ partisan composition since 2000, we show women both enter and win elections in safer Republican (Democratic) seats at relatively lower (higher) rates than men. Our results strikingly suggest that, even conditional on running, a female Republican candidate has an overall better chance of winning in a competitive seat than in a safe Republican seat.

The Divergent Paths of Representation

While women have reached record representation in Congress, this progress is remarkably lopsided. Since the mid-1980s, the number of Democratic women in the House of Representatives has surged, while the number of Republican women has largely stagnated. This "partisan gender gap" suggests that institutional barriers are affecting the two parties differently.

Women's representation in the House by party, 1985-present.

As shown in the figure above, the total number of women in the House has increased, but the growth is almost entirely driven by the Democratic side. This research investigates why the Republican party has failed to keep pace, identifying the decline of competitive "swing" seats as a hidden institutional barrier to gender parity.

The Mechanism: Seat Safety and Ideological Extremism

The core of the problem lies in seat safety—the degree to which a district is "locked" for one party. In safe seats, the general election is often a formality; the real contest happens in the primary. These primary battles tend to attract and reward "ideological purists."

This creates a "double bind" for women due to persistent gender stereotypes. Voters and party activists often stereotype women as more liberal than men. In safe Democratic seats, this stereotype acts as a tailwind, helping women appear more aligned with a liberal primary base. However, in safe Republican seats, it acts as a headwind. Republican women must work significantly harder to prove their conservative credentials to a primary base that favors the extreme right.

The widening partisan gap in female representation over time.

Methodology and Data

To test this theory, the study utilized a comprehensive dataset linking candidate demographics with district-level political data from 2000 to 2020. Key data sources included:

  • Bonica (2019) / DIME: A database used to identify candidate gender and financial resources.
  • Cook Partisan Voting Index (PVI): Used to determine the partisan lean and safety of every U.S. House district independently of the specific candidates running.

The researchers employed Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regressions to estimate the probability of a candidate winning an election, controlling for campaign spending, PAC donations, and the number of primary opponents. Notably, they chose not to control for incumbency, arguing that incumbency itself is often a product of the gender biases they aimed to measure.

The Paradox of Safety

The results reveal a striking disparity in win rates based on district safety:

  • The Republican Disadvantage: In the safest Republican seats (PVI > R+20), men have an almost 50 percentage point advantage over women in their chances of attaining office.
  • The Democratic Advantage: In the safest Democratic seats, women can have an advantage of up to 20 percentage points over men.
  • The Competitive Sweet Spot: In competitive swing seats, the gender gap in win rates virtually disappears. In these districts, candidates must appeal to the center, which neutralizes the pressure for extremism and the negative impact of gender stereotypes.

Perhaps the most counterintuitive finding is that a female Republican candidate actually has a better overall chance of winning in a competitive seat than in a safe Republican seat. This suggests that the "undersupply" of Republican women candidates is a rational response to these institutional hurdles; women are less likely to enter races where their probability of winning is suppressed by the primary system.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that partisan gerrymandering, which creates more safe seats, has the unintentional side effect of suppressing female representation in the GOP. While a few women succeed in safe Republican seats by running as high-profile extremists to overcome the "moderate" stereotype, the broader institutional trend remains a barrier. Future progress toward gender parity in Congress may depend as much on electoral reform and the return of competitive districts as it does on candidate recruitment efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Women have made significant strides toward equal representation within the U.S. Congress, but their seat share has mostly increased within the Democratic—but not Republican—Party. We argue that one driver of women’s underrepresentation among Republicans is the proliferation of safe seats. Because safe seats encourage ideological extremism in candidates and because women are stereotyped as more liberal than men, we expect women candidates to outperform men in safer Democratic seats but underperform men in safer Republican seats (relative to more competitive seats). Based on a new dataset linking all candidates for the U.S. House and their districts’ partisan composition since 2000, we show women both enter and win elections in safer Republican (Democratic) seats at relatively lower (higher) rates than men. Our results strikingly suggest that, even conditional on running, a female Republican candidate has an overall better chance of winning in a competitive seat than in a safe Republican seat.
BibTeX
@misc{rajan2021seat,
  author = {Akhil Rajan and Alexander Kustov and Maikol Cerda and Frances Rosenbluth and Ян Шапиро},
  title = {{Seat Safety and Female (Under)representation in the U.S. Congress}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.33774/apsa-2021-gqlmb},
}
Figure