Seat and footrest shocks and vibrations in manual wheelchairs with and without suspension

Rory A. Cooper, Erik Wolf, Shirley G. Fitzgerald, Michael L. Boninger, Rhys Ulerich, William AmmerArchives 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how suspension systems in manual wheelchairs affect the shock and vibration experienced by users. Researchers found that suspension caster forks significantly reduce shock and vibration, while rear-suspension systems offer some benefit but are not clearly superior to traditional designs. This work is crucial for understanding and mitigating the risk of secondary injuries in manual wheelchair users.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Manual wheelchair users are exposed to daily shocks and vibrations from propelling their chairs, which can contribute to cumulative trauma disorders and secondary disabilities, particularly low back pain. While suspension systems (both front caster forks and rear suspension) are increasingly available, there's a lack of clear data on their effectiveness in reducing transmitted shock and vibration. This paper aims to quantify these differences to inform the design and selection of wheelchairs that can improve user comfort and reduce injury risk.

Methods

The study employed a repeated-measures engineering testing approach using six manual wheelchairs. These wheelchairs were a mix of ultralight models, with half equipped with factory-installed rear-suspension systems. The testing involved two types of "dummies": the American National Standards Institute/Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America wheelchair test dummy (WTD) and the Hybrid III test dummy (HTD).

Each wheelchair was tested under four conditions:

  1. Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) caster forks.
  2. Suspension caster forks (specifically, Frog-Legs).
  3. With rear suspension (for applicable wheelchairs).
  4. Without rear suspension.

Shocks were measured by peak acceleration and the frequency at which it occurred, while vibration was assessed by acceleration power per octave. Data was collected using triaxial accelerometers mounted on the seat and footrest of the wheelchair, operating on a double-drum test machine for 250 cycles per configuration. Data reduction involved calculating resultant acceleration vectors, applying autocorrelation and Hamming windowing for noise reduction, and then performing a fast Fourier transform to obtain frequency spectra and power spectral density (PSD). The PSD was then integrated over specific frequency octaves to quantify vibration power. Statistical analysis used paired Student t-tests and mixed-model analysis to compare conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used manufactured wheelchairs and test dummies as specimens for controlled experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Suspension Caster Forks are a Game Changer: The most significant finding is the substantial reduction in shock and vibration provided by suspension caster forks (SCFs). This suggests that upgrading to SCFs is a highly effective strategy for improving ride quality and potentially reducing injury risk.
  • Frequency Matters: The study highlights that vibrations in the 4-12 Hz range are particularly concerning, as this is the natural frequency range for seated humans, leading to amplified vibrations and increased injury risk. While SCFs generally shifted peak frequencies higher, both suspension and non-suspension wheelchairs tended to transmit peak accelerations within this critical range.
  • Rear Suspension's Nuance: Rear-suspension systems showed mixed results. They did reduce vibration power in certain lower octaves (7.81-9.84 Hz), potentially shifting it to higher octaves (12.40-15.63 Hz). This suggests a complex interaction where vibrations might be redistributed rather than entirely eliminated, and optimization is still needed.
  • Dummy Suitability: The ANSI/RESNA WTD, while less expensive and primarily used for durability testing, proved suitable for studying wheelchair shocks and vibrations, showing comparable results to the more biofidelic Hybrid III dummy for peak accelerations and frequencies. However, the WTD showed higher vibration power in certain octaves, likely due to its stiffer structure.

Key Results

  • Peak Accelerations: Suspension caster forks significantly reduced peak accelerations at both the seat (P=.0004) and footrest (P=.0007) compared to OEM caster forks.
  • Vibration Power (SCFs): SCFs significantly reduced total vibration power per octave for both seat and footrest vibrations across most frequency ranges compared to OEM caster forks.
  • Vibration Power (Rear Suspension): Wheelchairs with rear suspension showed reduced vibration power in the 7.81-9.84 Hz octave (P=.01) but increased power in the 12.40-15.63 Hz octave (P=.008) compared to standard wheelchairs.
  • Frequencies: Suspension caster forks led to significantly different frequencies at which peak accelerations occurred for both the seat (P=.01) and footrest (P=.0001), generally at higher frequencies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Human Subject Studies Needed: The study acknowledges the limitation of using test dummies and emphasizes the need for future studies with human subjects to validate these findings and account for factors like cushion effects, body mass, and individual posture.
  • Rear Suspension Optimization: Further research is required to improve rear-suspension system designs, aiming for a more consistent reduction in vibration across the critical human natural frequency range.
  • Fatigue Life and Cost Analysis: Future work should investigate whether suspension systems increase the fatigue life of manual wheelchairs and conduct life-cycle cost analyses to assess the impact of added complexity.
  • Muscle Function and Spasticity: The influence of muscle function and spasticity on vibration response in human users needs to be considered in future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cooper2003seat,
  author = {Rory A. Cooper and Erik Wolf and Shirley G. Fitzgerald and Michael L. Boninger and Rhys Ulerich and William Ammer},
  title = {{Seat and footrest shocks and vibrations in manual wheelchairs with and without suspension}},
  booktitle = {Archives},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1053/apmr.2003.50069},
}
Figure