Seasonal Variation of the Mobility and Toxicity of Metals in Beijing’s Municipal Solid Waste Incineration Fly Ash

Hang Zhao, Yang Tian, Rong Wang, Rui Wang, Xiangfei Zeng, Feihua Yang, Zhaojia Wang, Mengjun Chen, Jiancheng ShuSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the seasonal variations in the mobility and toxicity of heavy metals (HMs) in Beijing's municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash. The findings reveal that HM concentrations, leaching behavior, and bioavailability fluctuate significantly with the seasons, with higher risks observed in autumn and summer, highlighting the need for season-specific management strategies for MSWI fly ash.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) is a common waste management practice, but it generates fly ash that can contain hazardous heavy metals (HMs). While the total concentration of HMs in fly ash is a concern, their actual environmental risk is better understood by assessing their mobility, bioavailability, and leaching toxicity. Previous research has often focused on average HM levels, but the dynamic nature of waste composition and environmental conditions suggests that these properties might vary seasonally. This paper addresses the critical knowledge gap regarding the seasonal fluctuations of HM mobility and toxicity in MSWI fly ash, which is essential for accurate risk assessment and effective environmental management. Understanding these seasonal variations is crucial because HMs can migrate into ecosystems and potentially impact human health.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to characterize the MSWI fly ash and its HM behavior:

  • Physicochemical Characterization: X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) were used to determine the elemental composition and mineral phases of the fly ash. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) provided insights into the surface morphology. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was used to understand thermal decomposition.
  • Leaching Toxicity Tests: Two standard methods were used:
  • HJ/T 299–2007 (Sulfuric Acid and Nitric Acid Method): This method simulates acidic conditions that can enhance HM leaching.
  • TCLP (Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure): A widely used regulatory method for assessing the leachability of hazardous constituents.
  • Leaching tests were also conducted at various initial pH values to understand pH-dependent mobility.
  • Chemical Speciation Analysis: The Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) sequential extraction method was employed to determine the distribution of HMs among different chemical fractions (acid-soluble, reducible, oxidizable, and residual). This helps understand their potential for release.
  • Bioavailability Assessment: An EDTA-2Na solution was used to simulate the chelation and adsorption of HMs by plant roots or organic acids, providing an estimate of the bioavailable fraction.

Datasets

The study utilized MSWI fly ash samples collected monthly over a year from the Lujiashan MSW plant in Beijing. These samples represent the real-world composition of fly ash generated in the region. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing standard methods were applied to the collected samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonal Fluctuations are Significant: The most striking finding is that HM concentrations, mobility, and bioavailability are not static but vary considerably with the seasons. This underscores the inadequacy of relying solely on average values for risk assessment.
  • Autumn and Summer Pose Higher Risks: These seasons consistently showed higher concentrations of key HMs like Pb and Zn, and in the case of Cd, an exceptionally high concentration in autumn compared to soil backgrounds. This is likely linked to seasonal changes in waste composition (e.g., more perishable materials, packaging) and increased volatilization due to higher temperatures.
  • Pb and Zn are Particularly Mobile and Toxic: These metals exhibited high leaching concentrations, especially in summer and autumn, and demonstrated significant mobility across different chemical fractions. Pb, in particular, exceeded regulatory thresholds in several seasonal tests.
  • Bioavailability Doesn't Always Mirror Total Content: The study highlights that the order of HM bioavailability does not directly correlate with their total content. For instance, Pb had high bioavailability despite not being the most abundant HM. This suggests that chemical speciation plays a crucial role in determining actual uptake by organisms.
  • MSWI Fly Ash is Hazardous: The combined results from leaching toxicity, speciation, and bioavailability analyses confirm that MSWI fly ash, particularly in certain seasons, poses a significant environmental risk.

Key Results

  • High HM Concentrations: Pb, Zn, and Cd were found in significantly higher concentrations in MSWI fly ash compared to Beijing soil backgrounds, with autumn values for Pb, Zn, and Cd being 42, 77, and 1260 times higher, respectively.
  • Leaching Toxicity Exceedances: Under the HJ/T 299–2007 method, Pb leaching concentrations exceeded the 5 mg/L threshold in summer, autumn, and winter. Under the TCLP method, Pb also exceeded the 5 mg/L threshold in summer.
  • High Mobility of Pb, Zn, and Cd: Sequential extraction revealed that these metals have a high proportion in mobile fractions (acid-soluble and reducible), with residual states being relatively low, indicating a strong potential for environmental release.
  • Seasonal Bioavailability Trends: Bioavailability of Pb, Zn, and Cd was higher in spring and autumn, while Cu bioavailability was higher in summer and autumn.
  • pH Dependency: Leaching concentrations of HMs were highest under strongly acidic conditions (pH=2), with Pb and Zn showing increased leaching at very high pH (alkaline conditions) due to their amphoteric nature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Geographic Scope: The study focused on MSWI fly ash from Beijing. While valuable, the findings might not be directly generalizable to fly ash from other regions with different waste compositions and incineration technologies.
  • Need for Long-Term Studies: The study focused on seasonal variations. Longer-term studies on the aging and weathering of fly ash could provide further insights into its evolving mobility and toxicity.
  • Further Investigation into Bioavailability Drivers: While the study showed that bioavailability is not solely dependent on total concentration, further research could delve deeper into the specific chemical forms and environmental factors that most influence the bioavailability of each HM.
  • Development of Season-Specific Management: The authors suggest that these findings can inform industries, governments, and the public to better understand the risks and develop more targeted prevention and treatment strategies for MSWI fly ash, potentially including season-specific disposal or treatment protocols.

Summary updated

Abstract

Metal mobility and toxicity of the municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash from different seasons in Beijing were studied using leaching toxicity procedures, sequential extraction procedures, and bioavailability procedures. The X-ray diffraction results showed that MSWI fly ash contained CaSO4, CaCO3, and KCl. The Pb, Zn, and Cd contents of MSWI fly ash were high, especially during autumn, being 42, 77, and 1260 times higher than that of their soil backgrounds, respectively. Leaching toxicity experiments showed that MSWI fly ash is hazardous, since Pb exceeded the maximum threshold (5 mg/L). The main alkali metal ions and anions, heavy metals total content, leaching concentration, chemical speciation, and bioavailability varied seasonally. The Pb and Zn leaching concentrations in summer and autumn were higher than that of the other two seasons. Sequential extraction procedures indicated that Pb, Zn, and Cd showed extremely high metal mobility, i.e., the residual states of Pb and Cd in spring were 5.83% and 1.21%, respectively, and that of Zn in autumn was 10.68%. These results will help industries, governments, and the public better understand the risk of MSWI fly ash and will urge them to pay more attention to preventing harm to the ecosystem and human beings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2021seasonal,
  author = {Hang Zhao and Yang Tian and Rong Wang and Rui Wang and Xiangfei Zeng and Feihua Yang and Zhaojia Wang and Mengjun Chen and Jiancheng Shu},
  title = {{Seasonal Variation of the Mobility and Toxicity of Metals in Beijing’s Municipal Solid Waste Incineration Fly Ash}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su13126532},
}
Figure