Seasonal Herbage–Livestock Balance and Grassland Pressure Index Analysis in the Yellow River Source Park, Tibet Plateau, China

Yalin Wang, Yuanyue Geng, Xungang Wang, Tianwei Xu, Qian Zhang, Hongjin Liu, Na Zhao, Shixiao XuEcology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study highlights the critical importance of seasonal variations in grassland productivity and nutrient content for accurate carrying capacity assessments in the Yellow River Source Park, Tibet Plateau. By considering both livestock and wildlife, the research reveals that while grasslands may appear balanced annually, they face critical overload during certain seasons, necessitating adaptive management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Grasslands are vital ecosystems supporting livestock and livelihoods globally. Accurately determining their carrying capacity is crucial for sustainable management, preventing degradation, and ensuring ecological stability. However, most existing studies focus on annual carrying capacity, neglecting the significant seasonal fluctuations in herbage yield and nutritional quality. This oversight can lead to an underestimation of grazing pressure, particularly during periods of low forage availability, and a failure to account for the needs of both domestic livestock and wild herbivores, which share these limited resources. The Yellow River Source Park, a sensitive ecological region, faces particular pressure from a growing livestock population and its rich wildlife, making a nuanced, seasonal understanding of carrying capacity essential.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess grassland carrying capacity and pressure:

  • Field Sampling: They conducted surveys across two typical grassland types (alpine meadow and alpine grassland) in the Yellow River Source Park over four seasons (August, October, January, May).
  • Herbage Analysis: Samples were collected to measure aboveground biomass (AGB), dry matter (DM), crude protein (CP), and metabolic energy (ME). These are key indicators of forage quantity and quality.
  • Carrying Capacity Calculation: Three types of carrying capacities were calculated per unit area:
  • DM Carrying Capacity (DMCC): Based on dry matter availability.
  • Digestible Crude Protein Carrying Capacity (DCPCC): Based on protein content.
  • Metabolic Energy Carrying Capacity (MECC): Based on energy content. These calculations incorporated forage yield, nutrient content, and estimated daily intake and nutritional requirements of standard sheep units (SU), accounting for different growth stages and weight gain.

  • Seasonal Grouping: Due to low carrying capacity in the yellowing and wintering periods, these were combined into a "withering" period, resulting in three distinct grazing periods: flourishing, greening, and withering.

  • Grassland Pressure Index (GPI): This index was calculated as the ratio of actual livestock (and wildlife) numbers to the theoretical carrying capacity. Two scenarios were analyzed: one considering only livestock, and another including both livestock and wild ungulates.

Datasets

  • Field Data: Herbage yield (AGB) and nutrient content (DM, CP, ME, NDF, ADF, Ash, EE, Ca, P) were collected from sampled grassland plots in the Yellow River Source Park.
  • Livestock and Wildlife Data: Existing data on livestock numbers and wild ungulate populations in the region were utilized for the GPI calculation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonality is Paramount: The study strongly emphasizes that annual carrying capacity figures are insufficient. Seasonal variations in herbage yield and nutrient content dramatically impact the actual carrying capacity, creating periods of surplus and critical deficit.
  • Alpine Meadows Outperform: Alpine meadows consistently demonstrated higher herbage yield and nutrient output compared to alpine grasslands, particularly during the flourishing period. This suggests differential management strategies may be needed for these distinct grassland types.
  • Nutrient Limitations Emerge: While dry matter and energy are often considered primary factors, crude protein emerged as a potential limiting nutrient, especially during the withering period, highlighting the need for protein supplementation.
  • Wildlife Matters: Including wildlife in carrying capacity assessments significantly increases the calculated grassland pressure. Ignoring wildlife can lead to a false sense of balance and mask critical overload conditions.
  • Adaptive Management is Key: The findings underscore the necessity of flexible grazing strategies that adapt to seasonal conditions, potentially involving reduced stocking rates or supplementary feeding during low-productivity periods.

Key Results

  • Herbage Yield & Nutrients: Herbage yield and nutrient output peaked in spring and summer (flourishing and greening periods) and were lowest in autumn and winter (withering period). Alpine meadows generally had higher yields than alpine grasslands.
  • Carrying Capacity Variation: Unit area carrying capacity followed a seasonal trend: flourishing > greening > withering. ME carrying capacity was generally the highest, while CP carrying capacity was the lowest.
  • Seasonal Carrying Numbers: Seasonal carrying numbers were significantly higher than actual livestock numbers during the flourishing period but much lower during the withering period.
  • Grassland Pressure Index (GPI):
    • Livestock Only: The annual GPI was balanced.
  • Livestock + Wildlife: The annual GPI indicated critical overload.
  • Seasonal GPI: The flourishing period showed surplus, the greening period was critical overload (with wildlife), and the withering period was severely overloaded.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Interannual Variability: The authors acknowledge that interannual climate variations and global warming trends can cause fluctuations in grassland production and nutrients. Long-term monitoring is recommended to account for these dynamics and prevent overgrazing.
  • Wildlife Population Dynamics: While wildlife was included in the GPI, the study notes that long-term surveys and monitoring of wildlife populations are crucial due to their migratory nature. Future work should focus on better understanding and integrating these dynamics.
  • Data Granularity: The study used a three-period seasonal breakdown. More refined seasonal or even monthly analyses could provide even finer-grained insights.
  • Forage Quality for Wildlife: While CP was identified as a limiting factor for livestock, further research could explore the specific nutritional needs of the diverse wildlife in the YRSP and how current forage quality meets those needs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Grassland carrying capacity is an indicator for measuring the stability of grassland ecosystems and can provide a basis for formulating regional sustainable grazing strategies. However, most previous studies on this have only considered annual fluctuations, but seasonal changes were ignored. In this study, the herbage yield and nutrient value of two grassland types in Yellow River Source Park (YRSP) were measured by sampling point survey method in four seasons, and the seasonal and annual grassland carrying capacity, carrying numbers of standard sheep unit (SU) were estimated based on the dry matter (DM) content, crude protein, and metabolic energy of herbage. Due to the carrying capacity being low during the yellow and wintering periods, we combined them and calculated the carrying capacity for only three periods, including the flourishing period, greening period, and withering period. The grassland pressure index (GPI) was measured by the ratio of the actual standard sheep number and the calculated number. The results showed that the herbage yield and nutrient output were higher in spring and summer, lower in autumn and winter, and showed a tendency for alpine meadows to be higher than alpine grasslands during the flourishing period (<i>p</i> < 0.05). The unit area carrying capacity varied significantly with the season and showed the seasonal changing characteristics of the flourishing period > greening period > withering period. The seasonal carrying number was much higher than the actual carrying number during the flourishing period and much lower than the actual carrying number during the withering period. In terms of annual carrying capacity, the GPI was balanced when considering livestock alone, while critical overloaded when considering livestock and wildlife. This study suggested the influence of seasonal change on the grassland carrying capacity should be fully considered in the grassland utilization. Meanwhile, the feeding needs of livestock and wildlife should be taken into account, and timely supplemented when forage is in short supply.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024seasonal,
  author = {Yalin Wang and Yuanyue Geng and Xungang Wang and Tianwei Xu and Qian Zhang and Hongjin Liu and Na Zhao and Shixiao Xu},
  title = {{Seasonal Herbage–Livestock Balance and Grassland Pressure Index Analysis in the Yellow River Source Park, Tibet Plateau, China}},
  booktitle = {Ecology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/ece3.70586},
}
Figure