Search for time-independent Lorentz violation using muon neutrino to muon antineutrino transitions in MINOS

P. Adamson, I. M. Anghel, A. Aurisano, G. Barr, M. Bishai, A. Blake, G. J. Bock, D. Bogert, S. Cao, Timothy J. Carroll, C. M. Castromonte, R. Chen, S. Childress, J. A. B. Coelho, L. A. Corwin, D. Cronin-Hennessy, J. M. G. H. J. de Jong, S. De Rijck, A. V. Devan, N. E. Devenish, M. Diwan, C. O. Escobar, J. J. Evans, E. Falk, G. J. Feldman, W. Flanagan, M. V. Frohne, M. Gabrielyan, H. Gallagher, S. Germani, R. A. Gomes, T Hara, P. Gouffon, N. Graf, R. Gran, K. Grzelak, A. Habig, S. R. Hahn, J. Hartnell, R. Hatcher, A. Holin, J. Huang, J. Hylen, G. M. Irwin, Z. Isvan, C. James, D. Jensen, T. Kafka, S. M. S. Kasahara, G. Koizumi, M. Kordosky, A. Kreymer, K. Lang, P. J. Litchfield, P. Lucas, W. A. Mann, Marvin L. Marshak, N. Mayer, C. L. McGivern, M. M. Medeiros, R. Mehdiyev, J. R. Meier, M. D. Messier, William H. Miller, S. Mishra, S. Moed Sher, C. D. Moore, L. Mualem, J. Musser, D. Naples, J. K. Nelson, H. B. Newman, R. J. Nichol, J. Nowak, J. Michael O’Connor, M. Orchanian, R. B. Pahlka, J. M. Paley, R. B. Patterson, G. Pawloski, A. Perch, M. M. Pfützner, D. D. Phan, S. Phan-Budd, R. Plunkett, N. Poonthottathil, Xin Qiu, A. Radovic, B. Rebel, C. Rosenfeld, H. A. Rubin, P. Sail, M. C. Sánchez, J. Schneps, A. Schreckenberger, P. Schreiner, R. Sharma, A. Sousa, N. Tagg, R. L. TalagaarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper presents the first search for time-independent Lorentz violation in neutrino-antineutrino transitions using data from the MINOS experiment. By analyzing a large dataset of muon neutrinos and antineutrinos, the researchers placed stringent new limits on specific parameters within the Standard-Model Extension (SME) framework, finding no evidence for such violations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, doesn't fully explain phenomena like neutrino masses. The Standard-Model Extension (SME) is a theoretical framework that allows for the possibility of violations of fundamental symmetries like Lorentz invariance and CPT symmetry, which are cornerstones of modern physics. These violations would manifest as tiny deviations from expected behavior, particularly in the interactions of fundamental particles. Neutrinos, due to their weak interactions and the ability to oscillate between different types (flavors), are particularly sensitive probes for these subtle effects. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of whether neutrinos can transform into antineutrinos (or vice-versa) in a way that deviates from standard oscillation predictions, which could be a signature of Lorentz-violating effects. Such transitions are not allowed in the standard neutrino oscillation picture and would require new physics.

Methods

The MINOS experiment is well-suited for this search due to its long baseline (735 km) and its ability to distinguish between neutrinos and antineutrinos based on the charge of the outgoing muon in charged-current interactions. The researchers analyzed data from an exposure of $10.56 \times 10^{20}$ protons-on-target from the NuMI neutrino-optimized beam. They employed a two-flavor model that simplifies the SME formalism to focus on specific coefficients related to muon-tau flavor transitions and time-independent Lorentz violation. The core of the analysis involved comparing the observed number of neutrino and antineutrino events in the Far Detector to predictions based on standard oscillations and then searching for deviations that could be attributed to the SME parameters $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{μμ}$, $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{ττ}$, $(c_L)^{TT}_{μμ}$, and $(c_L)^{TT}_{ττ}$. A binned log-likelihood function was minimized to constrain these parameters, with systematic uncertainties accounted for as nuisance parameters.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis is from the MINOS experiment, specifically from the Near and Far Detectors, corresponding to an exposure of $10.56 \times 10^{20}$ protons-on-target. This dataset consists of selected muon neutrino and antineutrino charged-current interactions. The analysis also relies on simulated Monte Carlo data for detector response and oscillation predictions, which were generated to model both standard oscillations and potential SME-induced deviations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Neutrino-Antineutrino Oscillations as a Probe: The paper highlights that transitions between neutrinos and antineutrinos are a powerful, yet underexplored, avenue for searching for Lorentz violation. These transitions are forbidden in the standard model of particle physics and would be a clear sign of new physics.
  • MINOS's Unique Capability: The MINOS experiment's ability to distinguish neutrino and antineutrino events event-by-event, combined with its long baseline, makes it uniquely sensitive to these subtle effects.
  • Time-Independent Lorentz Violation: The focus on time-independent Lorentz violation simplifies the theoretical framework and allows for direct constraints on specific SME coefficients. This is distinct from searches that look for sidereal time variations.
  • No Evidence Found: The most significant finding is the absence of any evidence for neutrino-antineutrino transitions beyond standard oscillations, leading to new, stringent limits on the parameters governing these potential violations.

Key Results

The analysis found no evidence for time-independent Lorentz violation in muon neutrino to muon antineutrino transitions. This led to the following $3\sigma$ limits:

  • For $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{μμ}$ and $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{ττ}$: $|\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{μ\overlineμ}| < 3.3 \times 10^{-23}$ and $|\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{τ\overlineτ}| < 3.3 \times 10^{-23}$. These are the world's best limits for these parameters.
  • For $(c_L)^{TT}_{μμ}$ and $(c_L)^{TT}_{ττ}$: $-8.4 \times 10^{-23} < (c_L)^{TT}_{μμ} < 8.0 \times 10^{-23}$ and $-8.0 \times 10^{-23} < (c_L)^{TT}_{ττ} < 8.4 \times 10^{-23}$. These are the first limits placed on these specific parameters.

The paper also notes that the best-fit values for the standard oscillation parameters ($\Delta m^2$ and $\sin^2 2\theta$) are consistent with previous MINOS results.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that the analysis is based on a simplified two-flavor model and focuses on a subset of SME coefficients. While the systematic uncertainties were carefully considered, they represent a significant factor in the limits achieved. Future work could involve extending the analysis to include other SME coefficients, exploring time-dependent Lorentz violation, or utilizing data from future neutrino experiments with even greater precision and statistics. The authors also mention that the predicted spectra from the SME fit are nearly indistinguishable from the standard two-flavor oscillation model, highlighting the challenge of detecting these subtle effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Data from the MINOS experiment has been used to search for mixing between muon neutrinos and muon antineutrinos using a time-independent Lorentz-violating formalism derived from the Standard-Model Extension (SME). MINOS is uniquely capable of searching for muon neutrino-antineutrino mixing given its long baseline and ability to distinguish between neutrinos and antineutrinos on an event-by-event basis. Neutrino and antineutrino interactions were observed in the MINOS Near and Far Detectors from an exposure of 10.56$\times10^{20}$ protons-on-target from the NuMI neutrino-optimized beam. No evidence was found for such transitions and new, highly stringent limits were placed on the SME coefficients governing them. We place the first limits on the SME parameters $(c_{L})^{TT}_{μμ} $ and $(c_{L})^{TT}_{ττ}$ at $-8.4\times10^{-23} &lt; (c_{L})^{TT}_{μμ} &lt; 8.0\times10^{-23}$ and $-8.0\times10^{-23} &lt; (c_{L})^{TT}_{ττ} &lt; 8.4\times10^{-23}$, and the world's best limits on the $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{μ\overlineμ}$ and $\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{τ\overlineτ}$ parameters at $|\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{μ\overlineμ}| &lt; 3.3\times 10^{-23}$ and $|\tilde{g}^{ZT}_{τ\overlineτ}| &lt; 3.3\times 10^{-23}$, all limits quoted at $3σ$.
BibTeX
@misc{adamson2016search,
  author = {P. Adamson and I. M. Anghel and A. Aurisano and G. Barr and M. Bishai and A. Blake and G. J. Bock and D. Bogert and S. Cao and Timothy J. Carroll and C. M. Castromonte and R. Chen and S. Childress and J. A. B. Coelho and L. A. Corwin and D. Cronin-Hennessy and J. M. G. H. J. de Jong and S. De Rijck and A. V. Devan and N. E. Devenish and M. Diwan and C. O. Escobar and J. J. Evans and E. Falk and G. J. Feldman and W. Flanagan and M. V. Frohne and M. Gabrielyan and H. Gallagher and S. Germani and R. A. Gomes and T Hara and P. Gouffon and N. Graf and R. Gran and K. Grzelak and A. Habig and S. R. Hahn and J. Hartnell and R. Hatcher and A. Holin and J. Huang and J. Hylen and G. M. Irwin and Z. Isvan and C. James and D. Jensen and T. Kafka and S. M. S. Kasahara and G. Koizumi and M. Kordosky and A. Kreymer and K. Lang and P. J. Litchfield and P. Lucas and W. A. Mann and Marvin L. Marshak and N. Mayer and C. L. McGivern and M. M. Medeiros and R. Mehdiyev and J. R. Meier and M. D. Messier and William H. Miller and S. Mishra and S. Moed Sher and C. D. Moore and L. Mualem and J. Musser and D. Naples and J. K. Nelson and H. B. Newman and R. J. Nichol and J. Nowak and J. Michael O’Connor and M. Orchanian and R. B. Pahlka and J. M. Paley and R. B. Patterson and G. Pawloski and A. Perch and M. M. Pfützner and D. D. Phan and S. Phan-Budd and R. Plunkett and N. Poonthottathil and Xin Qiu and A. Radovic and B. Rebel and C. Rosenfeld and H. A. Rubin and P. Sail and M. C. Sánchez and J. Schneps and A. Schreckenberger and P. Schreiner and R. Sharma and A. Sousa and N. Tagg and R. L. Talaga},
  title = {{Search for time-independent Lorentz violation using muon neutrino to muon antineutrino transitions in MINOS}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1605.03146},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.03146},
}
Figure