Search for the<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>Z</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>4430</mml:mn><mml:msup><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo><mml:mo>−</mml:mo></mml:msup></mml:math>atBABAR

B. Aubert, M. Bóna, Y. Karyotakis, J. P. Lees, V. Poireau, E. Prencipe, X. Prudent, V. Tisserand, J. Garra Ticó, E. Graugés, L. Lopez, A. Palano, M. Pappagallo, G. Eigen, B. Stugu, L. Sun, G. S. Abrams, M. Battaglia, D. N. Brown, R. N. Cahn, R. G. Jacobsen, L. T. Kerth, Yu. G. Kolomensky, G. Lynch, I. L. Osipenkov, M. T. Ronan, K. Tackmann, T. Tanabe, C. M. Hawkes, N. Soni, A. T. Watson, H. Koch, T. Vazquez Schroeder, D. Walker, D. J. Asgeirsson, B. G. Fulsom, C. Hearty, T. S. Mattison, J. A. McKenna, M. Barrett, A. Khan, V. E. Blinov, A. D. Bukin, А. Р. Бузыкаев, В. П. Дружинин, V. B. Golubev, A. P. Onuchin, S. I. Serednyakov, Yu. I. Skovpen, E. P. Solodov, K. Yu. Todyshev, M. Bondioli, S. Curry, I. Eschrich, D. Kirkby, A. J. Lankford, P. Lund, M. Mandelkern, E. C. Martin, D. P. Stoker, S. Abachi, C. Buchanan, H. Atmacan, J. W. Gary, F. Liu, O. R. Long, G. M. Vitug, Z. Yasin, L. Zhang, V. Sharma, C. Campagnari, T. M. Hong, D. Kovalskyi, M. A. Mazur, J. Richman, T. W. Beck, A. M. Eisner, C. J. Flacco, C.a. Heusch, J. Kroseberg, W. S. Lockman, A. J. Martínez, T. Schalk, B. A. Schumm, A. Seiden, M. G. Wilson, L. O. Winstrom, C. H. Cheng, D. A. Doll, B. Echenard, F. Fang, D. G. Hitlin, I. Narsky, T. Piatenko, F. C. Porter, R. Andreassen, G. Mancinelli, B. Meadows, K. Mishra, M. D. SokoloffPhysical 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

The BABAR experiment searched for the exotic Z(4430)⁻ particle in B meson decays. Despite a thorough analysis of the Kπ system's mass and angular distributions, no significant evidence for the Z(4430)⁻ was found, leading to stringent upper limits on its production rate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The discovery of the Z(4430)⁻ by the Belle collaboration in 2008 sparked significant interest as it could be evidence for a tetraquark state (a bound state of four quarks). However, its existence and properties were not definitively confirmed. This paper addresses the crucial need for independent verification of this exotic particle's existence. The authors aim to search for the Z(4430)⁻ in specific B meson decay channels (B → J/ψπK and B → ψ(2S)πK) and to provide precise measurements or limits on its production. This is important for understanding the nature of exotic hadrons and testing quantum chromodynamics (QCD) in the non-perturbative regime.

Methods

The BABAR experiment utilized a large dataset of B meson decays collected at the PEP-II collider. The core of the analysis involved reconstructing B meson decays into final states containing a J/ψ or ψ(2S) meson, a pion, and a kaon. A key challenge was disentangling potential Z(4430)⁻ signals from the complex background originating from the decay products of the Kπ system.

The authors employed a sophisticated approach:

  1. Kπ System Analysis: They first meticulously studied the mass and angular distributions of the Kπ system within the B decays. This involved fitting the Kπ mass spectra with Breit-Wigner distributions for known resonances (K(892) and K(1430)) and an S-wave contribution. The angular distributions were described using Legendre polynomial moments.
  2. Reflection Modeling: The crucial insight was that the Z(4430)⁻ signal would manifest as a peak in the ψπ mass distribution, and this peak could be influenced by the underlying Kπ structure. The authors developed a method to model this "reflection" of the Kπ system's properties onto the ψπ mass distribution using Monte Carlo simulations.
  3. Efficiency Correction: A detailed study of the detector's efficiency for reconstructing these particles was performed and applied to the data to ensure accurate comparisons.
  4. Signal Search: Finally, the efficiency-corrected ψπ mass distributions were compared to the modeled Kπ background. Any significant deviation from this background was investigated as a potential Z(4430)⁻ signal.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis is from the BABAR detector at the SLAC PEP-II asymmetric-energy e⁺e⁻ collider. The data corresponds to an integrated luminosity of 413 fb⁻¹. This dataset was collected at the ϒ(4S) resonance. Monte Carlo simulations were extensively used to model the detector response, background processes, and to study efficiency corrections.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Kπ System Dominance: The Kπ system's mass and angular distributions are complex and play a crucial role in shaping the observed ψπ mass spectra. Understanding these distributions is paramount for any search for exotic states.
  • Reflection as a Background Source: The "reflection" of the Kπ system's properties into the ψπ mass distribution is a significant source of background that must be accurately modeled. Failing to account for this can lead to misinterpretations of the data.
  • Importance of Angular Distributions: The angular distribution of the Kπ system varies significantly with its mass. This variation, when reflected, can create structures in the ψπ mass spectrum that might be mistaken for a narrow resonance if not properly accounted for.
  • No Evidence for Z(4430)⁻: The comprehensive analysis, which carefully accounted for the Kπ system's contributions, found no statistically significant evidence for the Z(4430)⁻. This independent result is vital for the ongoing debate about the nature of this exotic particle.

Key Results

  • The analysis found no significant evidence for the Z(4430)⁻ in the searched decay channels (B → J/ψπK and B → ψ(2S)πK).
  • Stringent upper limits were placed on the branching fractions for the production of the Z(4430)⁻, with values as low as $3.1 \times 10^{-5}$ at 95% confidence level for the B⁰ → Z⁻K⁺, Z⁻ → ψ(2S)π⁻ channel.
  • The Kπ mass and angular distributions were well-described by a superposition of known resonances and S-wave contributions, with no indication of a narrow structure around the Z(4430)⁻ mass.
  • The ψπ mass distributions were found to be well-described by the reflection of the Kπ system's properties, indicating that the observed structures are likely not due to a new exotic particle.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Uncertainty: While the dataset is large, the statistical uncertainties, particularly for the ψ(2S)π decay modes, limited the precision of some measurements.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: The paper mentions that systematic error studies were not fully completed for all measurements, particularly for branching fraction upper limits.
  • Kπ Background Modeling: The authors acknowledge that their low-order Legendre polynomial representation of the Kπ angular structure might lead to a small systematic reduction of a potential Z(4430)⁻ signal. They estimate this effect to be around 10%.
  • Future Work: The authors express that it will be of great interest to see if the Z(4430)⁻ is confirmed by future analyses with even larger datasets. The paper also highlights the importance of future studies to understand the nature of exotic hadrons and test QCD.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the results of a search for Z(4430)− decay to J/ψπ− or ψ(2S)π− in B−,0→J/ψπ−K0,+ and B−,0→ψ(2S)π−K0,+ decays. The data were collected with the BABAR detector at the SLAC PEP-II asymmetric-energy e+e− collider operating at center-of-mass energy 10.58 GeV, and the sample corresponds to an integrated luminosity of 413 fb−1. Each Kπ− mass distribution exhibits clear K∗(892) and K∗2(1430) signals, and the efficiency-corrected spectrum is well described by a superposition of the associated Breit-Wigner intensity distributions, together with an S-wave contribution obtained from the LASS I=1/2 Kπ− scattering amplitude measurements. Each Kπ− angular distribution varies significantly in structure with Kπ− mass, and is represented in terms of low-order Legendre polynomial moments. We find that each J/ψπ− or ψ(2S)π− mass distribution is well described by the reflection of the measured Kπ− mass and angular distribution structures. We see no significant evidence for a Z(4430)− signal for any of the processes investigated, neither in the total J/ψπ− or ψ(2S)π− mass distribution, nor in the corresponding distributions for the regions of Kπ− mass for which observation of the Z(4430)− signal was reported. We obtain branching-fraction upper limits B(B−→Z−K⎯⎯⎯0,Z−→J/ψπ−)&lt;1.5×10−5, B(B0→Z−K+,Z−→J/ψπ−)&lt;0.4×10−5, B(B−→Z−K⎯⎯⎯0,Z−→ψ(2S)π−)&lt;4.7×10−5, and B(B0→Z−K+,Z−→ψ(2S)π−)&lt;3.1×10−5 at 95% confidence level, where the Z(4430)− mass and width have been fixed to the reported central values.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aubert2009search,
  author = {B. Aubert and M. Bóna and Y. Karyotakis and J. P. Lees and V. Poireau and E. Prencipe and X. Prudent and V. Tisserand and J. Garra Ticó and E. Graugés and L. Lopez and A. Palano and M. Pappagallo and G. Eigen and B. Stugu and L. Sun and G. S. Abrams and M. Battaglia and D. N. Brown and R. N. Cahn and R. G. Jacobsen and L. T. Kerth and Yu. G. Kolomensky and G. Lynch and I. L. Osipenkov and M. T. Ronan and K. Tackmann and T. Tanabe and C. M. Hawkes and N. Soni and A. T. Watson and H. Koch and T. Vazquez Schroeder and D. Walker and D. J. Asgeirsson and B. G. Fulsom and C. Hearty and T. S. Mattison and J. A. McKenna and M. Barrett and A. Khan and V. E. Blinov and A. D. Bukin and А. Р. Бузыкаев and В. П. Дружинин and V. B. Golubev and A. P. Onuchin and S. I. Serednyakov and Yu. I. Skovpen and E. P. Solodov and K. Yu. Todyshev and M. Bondioli and S. Curry and I. Eschrich and D. Kirkby and A. J. Lankford and P. Lund and M. Mandelkern and E. C. Martin and D. P. Stoker and S. Abachi and C. Buchanan and H. Atmacan and J. W. Gary and F. Liu and O. R. Long and G. M. Vitug and Z. Yasin and L. Zhang and V. Sharma and C. Campagnari and T. M. Hong and D. Kovalskyi and M. A. Mazur and J. Richman and T. W. Beck and A. M. Eisner and C. J. Flacco and C.A. Heusch and J. Kroseberg and W. S. Lockman and A. J. Martínez and T. Schalk and B. A. Schumm and A. Seiden and M. G. Wilson and L. O. Winstrom and C. H. Cheng and D. A. Doll and B. Echenard and F. Fang and D. G. Hitlin and I. Narsky and T. Piatenko and F. C. Porter and R. Andreassen and G. Mancinelli and B. Meadows and K. Mishra and M. D. Sokoloff},
  title = {{Search for the<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>Z</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>4430</mml:mn><mml:msup><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo><mml:mo>−</mml:mo></mml:msup></mml:math>at<i>BABAR</i>}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.79.112001},
}
Figure