TL;DR
The BABAR experiment searched for the elusive $f_J(2220)$ resonance in radiative $J/\psi$ decays, a particle whose existence and properties have been debated for decades. This analysis found no evidence for the $f_J(2220)$ and set new, stringent upper limits on its production and decay rates, which are significantly lower than previously reported by the Mark III experiment.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The $f_J(2220)$ (also known as the $\xi(2230)$) is a particle that was first observed by the Mark III collaboration in the 1980s in radiative $J/\psi$ decays, specifically in the $K^+K^-$ and $K_S^0K_S^0$ decay channels. What made this particle particularly intriguing was its narrow width, suggesting a distinct quantum state, and its mass, which aligned with theoretical predictions for a scalar glueball (a bound state of gluons). However, subsequent searches by other experiments, including BES, have yielded conflicting results, with some finding evidence at a similar significance and others finding none. This discrepancy has led to significant debate about the $f_J(2220)$'s existence and its nature (e.g., is it a glueball, a hybrid state, or something else entirely?). This paper addresses this puzzle by performing a high-statistics search for the $f_J(2220)$ using a much larger dataset than previously available, aiming to provide a definitive answer or at least significantly constrain its properties.
Methods
The BABAR experiment utilized a large dataset of $e^+e^-$ collisions collected at the PEP-II collider, specifically focusing on events where a $J/\psi$ meson decays into a photon and the $f_J(2220)$ resonance. The $J/\psi$ mesons were produced via initial state radiation (ISR), which allows for the study of resonance production across a range of center-of-mass energies.
The analysis involved reconstructing two main decay channels for the $f_J(2220)$: $J/\psi \to \gamma K^+K^-$ and $J/\psi \to \gamma K_S^0K_S^0$. For the $K^+K^-$ channel, events were selected by identifying two oppositely charged tracks as kaons and a photon. For the $K_S^0K_S^0$ channel, events with a photon and four charged tracks were selected, with $K_S^0$ candidates reconstructed from pion pairs. Rigorous selection criteria were applied to minimize background, including vetoing events with $\pi^0$ candidates and applying momentum cuts for kaons in the $K^+K^-$ channel.
The analysis also considered various hypotheses for the spin and helicity of the $f_J(2220)$, as its spin was not definitively determined by the original observations. The signal extraction involved fitting the invariant mass spectra of the $K^+K^-$ and $K_S^0K_S^0$ final states with a Breit-Wigner distribution (convolved with a Gaussian resolution function) for the signal and a Chebychev polynomial for the background.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this analysis consists of 460 fb⁻¹ of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected by the BABAR detector at the SLAC PEP-II collider. This dataset includes 425 fb⁻¹ recorded at a center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s} = 10.54$ GeV and 35 fb⁻¹ recorded at 40 MeV below this energy. This large dataset corresponds to approximately 16.4 million directly-produced $J/\psi$ decays. Monte Carlo simulations based on GEANT4 were used extensively for detector acceptance studies, efficiency determination, and background modeling.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The $f_J(2220)$ might not be what we thought: The lack of a significant signal, despite a large dataset, strongly suggests that the $f_J(2220)$ is either not a prominent resonance in these specific decay modes or its properties are significantly different from what was initially reported.
- Stringent limits challenge previous observations: The 90% confidence level upper limits set by BABAR are substantially lower than the central values reported by the Mark III experiment, making it difficult for the Mark III results to be consistent with the BABAR findings across most spin/helicity hypotheses.
- Spin and helicity matter: The analysis systematically explores different spin and helicity assignments for the $f_J(2220)$, highlighting how these assumptions can influence the interpretation of experimental results and the setting of limits.
- Glueball or not? The initial excitement about the $f_J(2220)$ as a potential glueball candidate is significantly dampened by these new results, as the predicted properties of glueballs might not align with a non-existent or extremely weak signal.
Key Results
- No evidence for the $f_J(2220)$ resonance was observed in either the $K^+K^-$ or $K_S^0K_S^0$ decay channels.
- The number of signal events for the $f_J(2220)$ was determined to be $1.0 \pm 0.9 \pm 1.5$ for $K^+K^-$ and $-0.8 \pm 2.1 \pm 0.6$ for $K_S^0K_S^0$ (statistical and systematic uncertainties).
- 90% confidence level upper limits on the product of branching fractions ($J/\psi \to \gamma f_J(2220)$ and $f_J(2220) \to K^+K^-$ or $K_S^0K_S^0$) were set at the level of $10^{-5}$, which are below the central values reported by the Mark III experiment. For example, for the $J=2, h=0$ hypothesis, the upper limit for $K^+K^-$ is $<1.9 \times 10^{-5}$.
Limitations and Future Work
- Systematic Uncertainties: The main sources of systematic uncertainty include the parametrization of signal and background shapes, the determination of the number of $J/\psi$ mesons, and the efficiency calculations. While efforts were made to quantify these, they contribute to the overall uncertainty in the results.
- Spin/Helicity Dependence: The limits are presented as a function of assumed spin and helicity for the $f_J(2220)$. While this covers the most plausible scenarios, the possibility of a very narrow resonance with unusual spin/helicity properties cannot be entirely excluded without further theoretical guidance.
- Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that future searches for exotic states should be guided by these stringent limits. Further theoretical work to refine predictions for glueball masses and decay modes, or to explore alternative interpretations of the $f_J(2220)$ if it exists, would be valuable. The BABAR collaboration's extensive dataset and sophisticated analysis techniques provide a strong benchmark for future experimental efforts.
Summary updated